Students at a Catholic grade school in O’Hara staged a walkout from class in the mid-1970s with hopes of stopping what they said was sexual abuse by their teacher.
The students went to the principal of St. Joseph School, Sister Annalita Fox, and reported their concerns. But Sister Fox didn’t believe the students, and instead made them confess their “sins” to a priest.
Those allegations were laid out in a lawsuit filed Thursday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court against the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh and St. Joseph Parish.
The lawsuit, filed by the firm Robert Peirce and Associates on behalf of a victim identified only as D.A.L., claims that a teacher sexually assaulted the victim on multiple occasions during class while other students were occupied with schoolwork.
The teacher accused of assaulting D.A.L. and others was not identified in the lawsuit, but he is described as a “large, intimidating man with a loud, booming voice who would slam doors and other things and threw chairs, which deterred [the victim] from attempting to spurn his advances.”
Ann Rodgers, spokeswoman for the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh, said "We have not seen the lawsuit and cannot say anything about it at this time."
According to the lawsuit, the victim was abused from 1975 to 1977, when he was in sixth and seventh grade.
The teacher would wait until other students were working then approach D.A.L. at his desk, the lawsuit said. The teacher would stand behind the victim, kiss him on the back of the head, then reach around and caress and grope his body, according to the lawsuit.
The lawsuit does not name any other alleged victims, but it said the teacher also preyed on other “insecure, defenseless” students.
The students walked out of class and went into Sister Fox’s office when D.A.L. was in seventh grade. Instead of helping the students, she made them confess individually to a priest in the “cry room,” the lawsuit said.
The assaults stopped after the walkout, according to the lawsuit, but the teacher kept his job and the issue was never addressed by diocese officials.
D.A.L. attempted to repress the memories of the abuse, but he has suffered mental anguish and attended therapy to cope with the lasting effects, the lawsuit says.
The lawsuit seeks damages including money for past and future medical and therapy expenses and pain and suffering, as well as punitive damages for the diocese’s failure to address the abuse.
The diocese did not respond to a request for comment Friday evening.
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.