A Kittanning pastor used his Easter sermon last month to confess a sinful thought: He said he had hoped the accidental Holy Week fire at Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris had in fact been set by Muslim terrorists so it would provoke a backlash that would drive Muslims from France.
Pastor Carl Johnson of St. John's Lutheran Church said his point was that his impulses were wrong. But his voicing of the wish has drawn criticism, as has his statement that France is “lost” due to a Muslim population boom that he said would lead to it becoming an Islamic nation.
“The intended point of my sermon was that I need Jesus, I need Jesus to forgive me for horrible thoughts, words and deeds,” he said in a phone interview this week. “Jesus teaches me to repay evil with good. The world teaches violence against our enemies. My confession was meant to say that only through Christ do I have any chance of getting it right.”
His sermon remarks, and criticism of them by some in the congregation, was first reported by Keystone Crossroads, a public-radio reporting collaborative.
“I was hoping it was Muslim terrorism so that, hopefully, there would be a violent purge of Muslims from France,” he said in the sermon. “I wanted that because France is lost.” He was saying the Muslim birthrate is higher than average in France.
But he then said in the sermon that his violent wish was sinful.
French investigators say the cause of the cathedral fire was likely accidental, perhaps an electrical short. Online conspiracy theorists tried to pin it on Muslims.
Pastor Johnson’s congregation is part of the conservative North American Lutheran Church, which also lists Rev. Johnson as dean of its Mid-Northeast Mission District, an administrative role.
The NALC was created in 2010 by congregations that left the more liberal Evangelical Lutheran Church in America amid its move toward ordaining gays and lesbians.
Bishop Kurt Kusserow of the Southwestern Pennsylvania Synod of the ELCA, issued a statement to area Muslim leaders, emphasizing support for cooperation with Muslims and those of other faiths.
“We know that words have the power to cause harm, but words also have the power to foster healing,” wrote Bishop Kusserow, thanking Muslim leaders for their “robust commitment to interfaith cooperation and respect that exists in the Pittsburgh area.”
Pastor Johnson said that his “confession of an absolutely horrible thought has been misconstrued as a statement of my belief. Confession by its very nature, is a statement of, ‘This is wrong.’” He posted a similar statement on his church’s website.
Asked about saying that France is “lost” to Muslim population growth, he said, “I would fully expect Muslims in France would want France to be a Muslim nation, just like atheists in France would want France to be an atheist nation. Why is it weird that Christians would want France to be a Christian nation? The point is when we go to be evangelists, we go bearing Christ’s love and mercy and never violence.”
He said that while he has studied about Islam in college, he has not had dialogue with Muslims and would welcome that opportunity.
Andrew Fuller, spokesman for the North American Lutheran Church, said in a statement that “critics are taking a short soundbite without listening to the entire sermon. Pastor Johnson began the sermon by making a confession regarding evil thoughts, hatred, and prejudice following the fire at Notre Dame. He was making the point of how easy it is for people to connect pieces of information and come to conclusions and thoughts that are unjust and evil, but he then establishes that this is wrong for us to do....”
Critics “probably do agree with Pastor Johnson, if they had taken the opportunity to stay, hear the whole message, and chat with him about their concerns,” he said.
Safdar Khwaja, president of the Pittsburgh chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said after reading about the sermon and Pastor Johnson’s subsequent statements: “It seems that this pastor is substantially misinformed about Islam. We will seek an opportunity to have a dialogue with him.”
He said the organization often gets “random hate mail, with bizarre prejudices about Islam,” which it has been trying to dispel.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterS





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.