As they gathered in the front rows for the lighting of Shabbat and Hanukkah candles on Friday night, the 80 or so worshipers from Congregation Dor Hadash might have seemed to be dwarfed by the cavernous sanctuary where they’re meeting at Rodef Shalom Congregation in Shadyside.

But since the terrible events of Oct. 27, attendance has more than doubled at a typical service. People are showing up more regularly, joined by visitors.

Members are sensing “the need for community,” said longtime member Ray Engel. “It’s helping us heal.”

Dor Hadash was one of three congregations meeting at the Tree of Life / Or L’Simcha synagogue in Squirrel Hill that was targeted by an anti-Semitic gunman. Eleven were killed, including Dr. Jerry Rabinowitz, a Dor Hadash member and widely regarded physician. Another member, health-care chaplain Dan Leger, is recovering from extensive injuries.

Advertise with us

At this past Friday’s service, members offered Shabbat prayers for healing and of mourning, which took on special resonance for the congregation’s circumstances. They sang a capella, some in harmony, to numerous psalms and prayers, some of which picked up on the Hanukkah theme of restoring a defiled sacred space. Capping it was a member’s long-scheduled talk about his medical research into the aging process, mingling it with reflections on how Jewish sages have interpreted and puzzled over biblical depictions of aging and frailty.

The hearty singing, the lay-led service, the intellectually challenging talk — all was in keeping with the spirit of Congregation Dor Hadash, which has occupied a unique niche in Pittsburgh’s Jewish spectrum since its founding in 1963.

Evolving from a study group into a congregation, it drew in learned types who didn’t fit into the existing synagogue models of the 1960s. Their disputatious side was legendary enough, according to a congregational history, that the inaugural participants weren’t even unanimous on whether to vote the group into formal existence.

Dor Hadash has never owned a building, has never hired a senior rabbi and, at least in recent years, has been Western Pennsylvania’s only congregation in the Reconstructionist movement — a small Jewish denomination that blends traditional ritual with a progressive and non-doctrinaire ethos.

“Always from the beginning it's been lay-led,” said long-time member Sarah Angrist. “We expect members to take responsibility, and we’ve done very well.”

Advertise with us

Late last month, she and her husband, Stan Angrist, sat in their Squirrel Hill apartment with a reporter and brought out old memorabilia from Congregation Dor Hadash, such as the histories and programs from anniversary celebrations marking the 40 years (a biblical landmark) and 50 years since its creation in 1963.

“These were very happy events,” Ms. Angrist said. “None of us could have imagined what happened here.”

Since Oct. 27, Dor Hadash has regrouped, meeting first at space lent by nearby Beth Shalom and then at Rodef Shalom. (Tree of Life has also begun meeting at Rodef, while the third congregation that was using the building, New Light, is meeting at Beth Shalom.)

As part of its lay-led emphasis, Dor Hadash members have stepped up to answer the voluminous mail sent from all over the world, to lead worship services and serve on the “schlepper team,” bringing supplies to the new worship site.

“We're all there supporting each other, embracing each other and getting through this unthinkable tragedy together,” said Ellen Surloff, president of Dor Hadash. “They took one of our most beloved members from us, and yet we will be strong. We will move on.”

Advertise with us

The congregation has even been growing in recent weeks, with some people becoming members who had been attending but had not belonged until now.

“We have such a vibrant community of people eager to volunteer and help out, so our services go forward without missing a beat,” added Ms. Surloff. “That’s not without missing Dan and Jerry. They’re sorely missed.”

But it’s fitting for newer members to step up, she said: “Dor Hadash means New Generation, so this was a new generation,” said Ms. Surloff.

Yael Engel, left, who led the service with Zoe Feinstein, not pictured, and Rabbi Cheryl Klein prepare for a Dor Hadash service at Rodef Shalom, Friday, Dec. 7, 2018, in Shadyside. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Zoe Feinstein agreed. “It’s been obviously difficult, but it’s also really invigorating to see so many people coming back,” she said. She was helping to lead the Friday night service, something she hadn’t done since she was a teen several years ago. “I definitely feel the draw to be in the Jewish community now.”

Dor Hadash was formed in 1963 in Squirrel Hill as a havurah, or study group.

Advertise with us

Many of the first attendees were researchers recruited by Westinghouse. Others were academics, like Stan and Sarah Angrist, who joined in the 1960s after they moved here to teach at what is now Carnegie Mellon University.

One charter member, quoted in a congregational history by Mr. Angrist, described the founders as “unwealthy workers, engineers, and academics. They didn’t like big synagogues and they didn’t like to pay dues.”

Early on, some established synagogues suspected that the upstart group was siphoning off members from other congregations, but one early leader said Dor Hadash was actually providing a home for those who would otherwise “probably be lost to the Jewish Community.”

The story goes that early members picked the Reconstructionist prayer book because it was the cheapest — but it turned out to be a good fit, and soon the group joined the movement that created it.

Reconstructionism emerged in the mid-20th century based on the ideas of Rabbi Mordecai Kaplan, who envisioned an observance of Judaism to include not just religious but also cultural, literary and other endeavors. He saw the past as having “a voice but not a veto,” Ms. Surloff said. The Reconstructionist prayer book used by Dor Hadash includes commentary that offers readers the option of interpreting miraculous tales like the parting of the Red Sea in symbolic, mythic terms.

Advertise with us

Reconstructionism combines age-old Jewish traditions and ritual with with progressive views. It pioneered the holding of bat mitzvahs — coming-of-age ceremonies for girls similar to the bar mitzvahs held for boys.

Its umbrella organization is called Reconstructing Judaism, and its members from throughout North America have offered visits and other support since Oct. 27.

Ms. Angrist said she had grown up in a Yiddish-speaking yet secular household in Montreal. When she and Stan were raising a young family in Pittsburgh, they found a source of community at Dor Hadash.

“It actually opened up Judaism for me in a way that I found very enriching,” said Ms. Angrist. “It made me come to the recognition that I enjoy being Jewish, that it's not an obligation. It's something that we raised our children with and they were very comfortable with it because it's broad-based. It includes learning and studying but it also includes a tremendous amount of community and a feeling of belonging without the doctrinaire aspects.”

As with many synagogues, some members of Dor Hadash attend Shabbat services on Friday nights, others on Saturday mornings, still others both.

Advertise with us

Dr. Rabinowitz and Mr. Leger were regulars on Saturday morning, and their fellow members feared the worst when they learned of the shootings. If there was a silver lining, it was that a monthly, family-oriented Saturday service was not being held that day; it typically draws a larger attendance.

Members took comfort in Dr. Rabinowitz’s legacy of a quiet commitment to the needy — such as AIDS patients in the early days of the epidemic.

“I have to say I never knew things about Jerry until his funeral because he would never brag,” Ms. Surloff said.

Members are still coping with the trauma.

“It’s very painful because the random shooting and the evil that seems to go with it and the anti-Semitism that seems to be increasing,” said Ms. Angrist. “It defies explanation. It’s hard to believe we’re living in a country where this is happening.”

Advertise with us

Earlier in October, Dor Hadash had taken part in a National Refugee Shabbat. Plans for such a worship service, oriented toward the needs of migrants, were circulated by HIAS, the historic Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society that now resettles refugees of various lands and creeds.

From left, Johanne Rokholt, of Highland Park, Maria Cramer, of State College, and Robin Banerji, of Washington, D.C., look at the ceiling of the Rodef Shalom sanctuary before a Dor Hadash service at Rodef Shalom, Friday, Dec. 7, 2018, in Shadyside. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The gunman charged in the synagogue attack had raged online against HIAS, Jews and immigrants and is believed to have sought out Dor Hadash at its address because it was listed as participating in the National Refugee Shabbat.

But ultimately the attacker targeted anyone in the synagogue because “we were Jews,” said Ms. Surloff. “Part of our Judaism is our belief in social justice and the need to make the world a better place. And that includes a whole lot of social justice work, social action work. Work with immigrants was just one of small part of the kind of work we do.”

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.