A Presbyterian minister whose videotaped emotional outburst at President Donald Trump’s motorcade as it drove past her Squirrel Hill home went viral and sparked a nasty national backlash, said Thursday that she doesn’t regret her words but rues any harm she has caused.
“My model for ministry is Fred Rogers. I was like the anti-Fred Rogers, right?" said the Rev. Susan Rothenberg, 57.
“While I don’t regret what I said, I do regret the pain that it’s caused. … It has spiraled, and it’s incredibly sad that that has happened. I love my church, and I love my denomination, and I have deep regret for any harm they may be experiencing.”
On Thursday, the Pittsburgh Presbytery temporarily disabled its Facebook page in response to what it said was an avalanche of hateful attacks launched online against Rev. Rothenberg, who was caught on camera Tuesday screaming at the presidential motorcade as it made its way through Squirrel Hill to the Tree of Life synagogue, where 11 people were killed.
The video by WTAE-TV showing Rev. Rothenberg yelling for roughly a minute at the president’s procession went viral, registering more than 7 million views (of at least three seconds each) on the station’s Facebook page. It has been shared about 63,000 times.
“Let the families grieve! This is our neighborhood! You are not welcome here!” shouted Rev. Rothenberg from the front steps of her house on Shady Avenue near Tree of Life. “You are not welcome on my street! These are my neighbors that were killed! You are not welcome in Squirrel Hill. Do you understand that?”
Read More
Rev. Rothenberg, who said she has watched only a few seconds of the video, said the eruption of anger was spontaneous and a culmination of the stress, sadness and frustration she had been feeling since the shooting.
“It just felt important that the president could hear the voice of the neighbors of the Tree of Life,” Rev. Rothenberg said. “While the president is certainly not responsible for what happened at Tree of Life, we do know … that people are feeling deeply divided, deeply unable to care for one another, that people feel isolated, and I think that all came together on my steps on Tuesday.”
In an interview she gave Tuesday to CBS outside Tree of Life, she said, “I was reacting to people who were just trying to mourn, just trying to grieve. A good friend saying, ‘I’m stuck in traffic, I can’t get to the family’s house,’ ” she said. “This visit caused, as you’ve seen, a pretty significant disruption in that happening. I think the president, he should certainly come to cities where these tragedies happened, I question the timing, and I think that our city and state officials emphasized that you can come, just give these families some space.”
Mr. Trump’s controversial visit to the Tree of Life and UPMC Presbyterian in Oakland, where he visited police officers, medical staff and the widow of a victim, spurred protests in Squirrel Hill.
Democratic leaders including Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto, County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf all turned down invitations to appear with him. Authorities have charged Robert Bowers in the massacre Saturday with killing 11 congregants and wounding six others, including four police officers, before he was shot and taken into custody.
In an open letter titled “A Season of Travail” and published online Thursday, the Rev. Sheldon W. Sorge, the Presbytery’s general minister, expressed dismay at what he termed a “rush of anger unleashed on Facebook” at Rev. Rothenberg.
In an interview Thursday, Rev. Sorge said he was concerned by the level of animosity that has permeated emails, Facebook posts and phone messages that have flooded not only the Pittsburgh Presbytery but the church’s national office and presbytery offices elsewhere in the U.S.
Calls have come in for Rev. Rothenberg, who currently works at a church consulting agency, to be dismissed or defrocked. And while Rev. Sorge said he is unaware of any threats of violence made, he said callers have resorted to denouncing Rev. Rothenberg in spiritual terms, telling her she can go to hell.
“I find it extraordinarily troubling. It indicates the level of division that is within our culture that is deep and hostile. And I pray that people of faith and the Christian church in particular, which is my part of that, would model a different way of dealing with people with whom we differ,” Rev. Sorge said.
“Unfortunately this experience has underscored for me that people of faith oftentimes are just as full of reactivity and blame-throwing as anybody else, and so my heart is saddened by that, and it tells me that we need to have a vastly alternative way of being a people than what this indicates.”
The CBS News interview with Rev. Rothenberg from earlier this week:
In his letter, Rev. Sorge said that Rev. Rothenberg grew upset at the disruption that the visit by the president — along with the first lady, his daughter Ivanka and her husband, Jared Kushner, both of whom are Jewish — would cause to the seven-day Jewish ritual of sitting shiva, where visitors pay their respects to mourning families.
“Susan, one of our ministers, lives just five houses down from Tree of Life, and her neighbors are part of its family. They were actively participating in the seven-day Jewish Shiva mourning rites, when they were put on forced lockdown due to the presidential motorcade’s planned drive through the neighborhood. Under lockdown, they were unable to keep shiva with mourning families,” wrote Rev. Sorge.
“As the presidential procession drove by her home, Susan shouted her dismay at the disruption his visit caused to her grieving neighbors, hoping that the president could hear her voice through his sound-proofed car doors.”
Rev. Sorge said the video shot by a TV cameraman, which showed Rev. Rothenberg clutching a cell phone and standing with two other people (she declined to identify them), captured her denunciation “without showing that she was trying to get the attention of the retinue passing by her home.”
On Thursday, Rev. Sorge expanded on that.
“That brief snippet is so devoid of context. You can be killed by 30 seconds of video,” he said. “Without context, it’s crazy.”
As reaction quickly mounted to the video, Rev. Rothenberg went on national television to do an on-scene interview with CBS.
“Well, we didn’t really plan a protest. We were locked down by Secret Service in our home, and as my son and I were driving home from school, we saw some folks out with signs and we decided, well, we’ll make a couple of signs, not expecting that the president would see them or that the president would notice us, But it was just a way for us to kind of feel like we were speaking into this time in our neighborhood,” Rev. Rothenberg said.
“So we made the signs. We hung out on our front steps, which was as far as we were allowed to go. … We saw the motorcycles come. We saw the large vehicles start to come up the street. We were astonished that we were going to be that close, and we felt like even if he can’t hear us and can’t notice us we would still speak out.
“So I began to just chant loudly, ‘You’re harming my neighbors, these people need room to breathe. Your words are divisive. And your words have consequences.’ And some of my neighbors began to wander over to me and they said, ‘Yeah, go and we all began to wander up the street a little bit. And before you knew it there were 15 of us. There were children, there were some members of the synagogue, my children and myself, and it was just neighbors, I think, reacting to the last three days, which had been very stressful and just that feeling of disorientation, we felt like we wanted our president to know that the words he speaks have consequences. We wanted the president to know that folks who were coming out of funerals couldn’t get to sit shiva with the families because of the traffic his visit created.”
Rev. Sorge said by Thursday he felt compelled to respond to the vitriolic comments pouring in by publishing an open letter and by temporarily suspending the Presbytery’s Facebook page.
“The pent-up anger this has revealed is astonishing. Susan’s protest has had the effect of a breach in a dam, and the torrent of hate-filled speech it has unleashed is vast and truly alarming,” the letter said.
“I am grief-stricken for our city, especially for the members and neighbors of Tree of Life who have suffered deadly assault grounded in unmitigated hate. And I am grief-stricken over the volume and venom of attack that has poured forth from across the country in response to one of our own expressing her dismay over the disruption caused by the presidential visit.”
Rev. Sorge said his colleague is holding up amid the national backlash.
”She’s doing, I think, remarkably well. She’s sheltering in place as best she can. She’s a strong person. … She’s a very measured, competent, capable minister and leader, and this kind of expression is very, very uncharacteristic of her, and it speaks to the level of the distress that she felt in the moment,” Rev. Sorge said. “The moment that the president’s motorcade was passing by and she wanted to try to be heard in soundproof cars, and so in the heat of the moment she spoke out what was in her deepest gut.
“She has been massively vilified by many, but she also has been supported and encouraged by many of her colleagues.”
Rev. Sorge said he does not expect any efforts within the church to oust his colleague and note that Presbyterians have a long history of supporting political activism.
“We have to give voice to pain and suffering. And sometimes pain and suffering is not attractive and doesn’t look like we have it all together. And I think that’s what it looked like,” Rev. Rothenberg said. “My sorrow is I’ve become the story when the story is really about neighbors trying to help each other hold on.”
Rev. Rothenberg, a Uniontown native and mother of two whose husband is a Jewish orthopedic surgeon, said a single moment caught on video does not represent her or her ideology.
“We try to move through the world with compassion,” Rev. Rothenberg said — with her healing the soul while her husband tends the body. “Probably no one’s going to believe that about us anymore. Or at least about me.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.