Seven Lawrence County parishes gather for first combined Mass

NEW CASTLE, Pa. — Susie Parran, a member of SS. John and Paul Parish in Franklin Park, regularly attended her church for years in large part because of the Rev. Joseph McCaffrey.

Now, amid church restructuring, Father McCaffrey, like many others, is being shifted elsewhere.

Ms. Parran, though, realized that the sacrifice Father McCaffrey was making by leaving SS. John and Paul meant he could go to the aid of others who need him more.

“I wasn’t sure how I would feel, but I got tears in my eyes because I was watching him do his thing,” she said Saturday evening shortly after watching Father McCaffrey lead the first Mass for newly merged Lawrence County parishes. “There’s just magic in him, there’s just the Holy Spirit. And to watch other people get that, I can almost say ‘OK now, he gets to help [more] people. We’re OK.’”

Advertise with us
The Rev. Joseph R. McCaffrey, left, and Deacon Dan Kielar organize readings before the first Mass. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

This weekend marks the first set of weekend Masses since the long-planned reorganization of parishes in the Diocese of Pittsburgh was officially implemented on Oct. 15.

Seven Lawrence County parishes are forming a grouping that is on track to merge in the next two years.

For the first weekend, Father McCaffrey, administrator of the Lawrence County parish, said it was important to bring everyone together on neutral turf, so the grouping held Masses at New Castle Area High School’s auditorium.

The school’s parking lot was filled to capacity, and more churchgoers parked on nearby streets as several hundred attended the first of two joint Masses Saturday. Upon entering, parishioners were handed a prayer program that had the new parish logo on the cover — a white dove under seven golden stars on a blue background — as well as a bookmark with the parish prayer.

Father McCaffrey said he wouldn’t be able to preside at Masses at all seven parishes, and this way he could speak to all of them together and also help the parishioners beginning to see themselves as part of a single community.

Advertise with us

“That’s what we’ve got to do anyway. This sets the tone for what we’re trying to do.”

He’s using the weekend’s Gospel reading to illustrate the point. In it, the apostles James and John ask to have places of honor in heaven. But “we can get caught up on what we want” instead of what “God wants, and what do we need to do to pass the faith on to future generations.”

He’s adopting a parish motto, “Keeping the main thing the main thing.”

“What is the main thing to even have a Catholic parish? What’s the main thing?” Father McCaffrey asked parishioners Saturday. “Is it the building? Is it the roof? Is it where it is at on the face of the globe? Or is it what goes on under that roof … and passing that faith onto the next generation? That, to me, is the main thing. And everything else has to support that.”

He said there was a sense of excitement as volunteers from the parishes rehearsed on Wednesday for the joint Masses.

Advertise with us

“It’s a morale boost” at a time when Catholics need one, he said. “We need something hopeful and positive and not only to focus on all the decline.”

The parish reorganizations, under the name On Mission for the Church Alive, is being conducted in response to a long-running decline in parishioners, participation and priests. It’s being implemented even as the diocese continues to reel from a state grand jury report into its history of sexual abuse by clergy, followed by news on Thursday that federal investigators have begun their own probe.

The Rev. Anthony Sciarappa puts on his vestment before the first Mass of seven Lawrence County parishes Saturday, Oct. 20, 2018, at New Castle High School. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Under the On Mission plan, 188 parishes in six counties are now organized into 57 groupings with the aim of them becoming parishes in two to five years.

Members of the new parish in Lawrence County appeared mostly optomistic about the convergence.

“Change is good,” said Marsha Galanski, a member of Mary Mother of Hope in New Castle. “We’ve already lost churches in the past, and so, to merge like this, to me, it’s a good idea.”

Advertise with us

“I think it’s nice,” said Emma Ferguson, also of Mary Mother of Hope Parish. “We’ll get to know more people in town.”

Catholics, while still the largest religious population in southwestern Pennsylvania, have declined by 16 percent to 632,138 since 2000. Their Mass attendance and other key indicators of spiritual vitality have declined by 40 percent to 50 percent, according to church statistics.

The seven Lawrence County parishes in the new grouping include St. Joseph the Worker, Mary Mother of Hope, St. Vincent de Paul and St. Vitus, all of New Castle; Christ the King in Bessemer; St. Camillus in Neshannock; and St. James the Apostle in Pulaski.

“This fire of faith that’s burning in Lawrence County can be fanned into a huge bonfire if every single one of us is willing to feed the fire, to make some sacrifice, for Jesus’ sake, and for the next generation sake,” Father McCaffrey said. “All those who have gone before us at all these parishes made sacrifices at different times in history.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352. Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.