WASHINGTON — Cardinal Donald Wuerl, who has said repeatedly that he didn’t know about years of sexual misconduct complaints involving his predecessor in the District of Columbia, Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, was named in a 2005 settlement agreement that included allegations against Cardinal McCarrick, according to the accuser in the case and documents obtained by The Washington Post.
Robert Ciolek, who left the priesthood and later became an attorney, spoke for the first time publicly this summer about the $80,000 settlement he reached in June 2005 with three New Jersey dioceses over his allegations against Cardinal McCarrick and a teacher at his Catholic high school. Cardinal McCarrick led the church in Newark and Metuchen before coming to the District in 2001; Mr. Ciolek’s high school was in New Jersey as well.
In an interview with The Post this month, Mr. Ciolek said for the first time publicly that the settlement included allegations against a third person, a Pittsburgh priest Mr. Ciolek says made unwanted sexual contact with him in seminary, where the priest was a professor. The first page of the settlement agreement lists the Diocese of Pittsburgh and Cardinal Wuerl, who supervised the priest as bishop of Pittsburgh at the time, among the numerous parties to the settlement. The agreement was signed by Mr. Ciolek and the three New Jersey dioceses.
Mr. Ciolek shared a copy of the settlement with The Post.
The presence of Cardinal Wuerl’s name on Mr. Ciolek’s settlement agreement raises questions about the cardinal’s assertion that he did not know about any allegations against Cardinal McCarrick before they became a topic of public discussion this summer.
Cardinal Wuerl’s Washington D.C. spokesman, Ed McFadden, said this week that Wuerl had been unaware of the legal agreement.
Read More
“As he has stated consistently ... Cardinal Wuerl had no knowledge of the settlements until the existence of the settlements was made public” this summer, Mr. McFadden said.
Pope Francis in June suspended Cardinal McCarrick, a hugely popular cleric known as a prolific fundraiser for the church, after he was accused of groping an altar boy. Since his suspension, another alleged young victim has surfaced, as have years of rumors about Cardinal McCarrick’s alleged inappropriate treatment of seminarians and young priests.
Cardinal McCarrick has made no comment about the various allegations against him since the first allegation. At the time, he said he had no memory of the incident and maintained his innocence, but accepted the pope’s decision.
An increasingly vocal segment of Catholics in D.C. have expressed skepticism about Cardinal Wuerl’s claim that he didn’t know about either the rumors about Cardinal McCarrick’s alleged behavior or the settlements, and they have demanded more transparency.
A bombshell letter in August from former Vatican ambassador Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, alleging Cardinal Wuerl knew about sexual misconduct accusations against Cardinal McCarrick, has intensified the skepticism.
The letter, which offered no proof, came shortly after a detailed grand jury report by Pennsylvania prosecutors described rampant cover-up in the Catholic church of clergy sex abuse — including mishandling of cases by Cardinal Wuerl, when he was bishop for the Diocese of Pittsburgh from 1988 to 2006.
Cardinal Wuerl issued a statement right after the letter from Archbishop Vigano, denying the allegations in the letter — including that the archbishop himself had communicated about Cardinal McCarrick’s misconduct to Cardinal Wuerl. The statement suggested the Vatican investigate Archbishop Vigano, along with Cardinal McCarrick.
Mr. Ciolek said he waited to publicly discuss the Pittsburgh connection in his settlement until after he sought legal permission from the Diocese of Pittsburgh to speak about it. He spoke to various media earlier this summer about the other two alleged abusers — Cardinal McCarrick and his high school teacher — after his name spread and the New Jersey dioceses released him from the document’s confidentiality clause.
He spoke to The Post about the Pittsburgh priest on the condition the priest not be named because Mr. Ciolek said he considers the details of that encounter too personal. He said “there was inappropriate sexual contact toward me” in the 1980s by the priest, who was a faculty member at Mount St. Mary’s Seminary in Emmitsburg, Md., when Mr. Ciolek was a student there. The priest was not mentioned in the recent grand jury report.
The settlement document does not mention Cardinal McCarrick by name, nor does it specify Mr. Ciolek’s allegations beyond saying Mr. Ciolek was making “numerous claims of sexual misconduct by various priests” in the various dioceses. The signatories to the agreement were Mr. Ciolek, and officials of the three New Jersey dioceses — Newark, Trenton and Metuchen — who paid into his settlement.
Asked what Pittsburgh knew about the Ciolek settlement, the diocese initially put out a statement saying it was unaware that it was mentioned on the document.
“The Diocese of Pittsburgh was surprised to learn in early July 2018 that it was named as a release in the settlement agreement with Mr. Ciolek. The Diocese of Pittsburgh was not a party to this agreement and was not a signatory,” the diocese said in a statement. “This summer, when Mr. Ciolek asked the Diocese of Pittsburgh to be released from a confidentiality provision, the diocese responded that since we hadn’t signed the agreement we had no authority to release him.”
The Post also asked whether anyone on the Pittsburgh staff was told about Mr. Ciolek’s allegations against his alleged abusers, which included Cardinal McCarrick. Ann Rodgers, a spokeswoman for the Pittsburgh diocese, answered that the staff did not know, then or now “about the settlement until early July 2018.”
But Ms. Rodgers’ statement appears to conflict with the contents of a 2004 letter between officials with the dioceses of Metuchen and Pittsburgh.
On an Aug. 11, 2004, letter to Metuchen officials, Mr. Ciolek laid out all of his allegations, and Metuchen soon contacted Pittsburgh. In a letter dated Aug. 17, 2004, Metuchen’s then-Vicar General Monsignor William Benwell alerted then-auxiliary Pittsburgh Bishop William Winter about the Pittsburgh priest, who Mr. Ciolek says was still in ministry at the time. Mr. Ciolek shared both letters with The Post.
Mr. Ciolek said he finds it “inconceivable” that none of the three dioceses in New Jersey would have mentioned to Cardinal Wuerl that they’d just reached an $80,000 settlement involving both Cardinal McCarrick and Cardinal Wuerl’s own priest.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.