The Citizens Coal Council once again has called on the state Department of Environmental Protection to do a better job of protecting structures, springs and streams from subsidence damage caused by longwall mining.
The Washington County-based non-profit made its latest appeal for regulatory rigor and enforcement of Act 54, the state’s mining law, in a report issued during the DEP’s Citizens' Advisory Council virtual meeting last week.
Act 54 is the sweeping and still controversial 1994 mining law amendment that cleared the way for longwall operations to undermine houses and other structures, roads and bridges, water supplies and springs, as long as the mining company repaired the structures and replaced water supplies.
The CCC’s 106-page report to the advisory council contains a laundry list of longstanding regulatory failures, topped by the assertion that fewer than 10% of the thousands of structures, residential water supplies and streams damaged by mining subsidence have been fixed as the law requires.
“For years, we have seen the (DEP) issue approvals for longwall mining throughout our region with little to no concern paid to the impacts it has on our environment and local residents,” said Aimee Erickson, Citizens Coal Council executive director, in a news release announcing the group’s study. “While longwall mining is permitted under the law, the DEP must protect surface landowners and it must prohibit damages to water resources that are predictable and avoidable, irrespective of the type of mining used.”
Longwall mining is a method that removes almost all of the coal in wide, mile-long ”panels,” 300 to 800 feet below ground, leaving behind no coal support pillars and causing widespread surface subsidence of three to four feet. The subsidence can damage homes and other surface structures, crack and sink roads, cause hillsides to slide, and drain streams and springs.
“This is not an attack against the coal industry, but rather a heartfelt request to the DEP to do the right thing,” Ms. Erickson said. “This agency is supposed to protect our environment and people, and for far too long DEP has failed to fully exercise its oversight authority over this mining practice.”
Jamar Thrasher, a DEP spokesman, said in an email response to questions that the department was reviewing the report and that DEP Secretary Patrick McDonnell planned to meet with the organization.
Stephen Kunz, senior ecologist with Schmid & Co., an environmental consulting firm headquartered in Media, Delaware County, told the advisory council that 95% of the structural damages caused by mining subsidence from 2013-2018 occurred above longwall mines.
He said longwall mines also drained or damaged more than two-thirds of the 27.4 miles of streams impacted by coal operations during the same five-year period, and that fixing such flows averaged eight years and, in an earlier case, took 13 years.
“Fixing streams is not easy, guaranteed or quick,” Mr. Kunz said. “Even five years is way too long for a stream to remain damaged.”
This is not the first time CCC has criticized the DEP’s longwall mining program. A July 2014 report found the DEP was making longwall permitting decisions based on incomplete application data, and as such was not providing adequate protection of air and water resources where longwall mining was operating in southwestern Pennsylvania.
Rachel Gleason, executive director of the Pennsylvania Coal Alliance, an industry advocacy organization, said the CCC report misrepresented structure, water supply and stream damage data in the state’s January 2020 report.
She said such damage is often resolved quickly in agreements between property owners and mining companies.
“In most scenarios, those agreements are private between the parties involved, and the path to resolution is the decision of the landowner,” Ms. Gleason said. “The data reported by the Citizens Coal Council is outrageously inaccurate, and ignores all resolutions that are amicably reached between parties.”
When the DEP released its latest five-year report in January 2020 that showed a high percentage of coal company purchases of subsided property, Ms. Gleason said that was a “common practice that’s been used for a long time” and was allowed by Act 54.
The coal mining industry in the state is in decline, mostly due to the electric power industry’s fuel switch to lower-cost natural gas.
The latest five-year mining report, completed for the DEP by the University of Pittsburgh in December 2019 and released in January 2020, counted 49 active underground bituminous coal mines — seven of them longwall mines — operating in the state.
A little more than a year later, according to the DEP, there were 24 active mines, four of them longwall operations.
Despite the downturn that has idled mines, Mr. Kunz said there was enough coal left in the Pittsburgh coal seam for longwall mines to operate for another 40 years at their current mining rate, so improvements to DEP’s oversight remain important.
“There’s still more than 277,000 acres of the Pittsburgh coal seam that’s unmined today,” he said. “But the thing is, 71% of that acreage is under special-protection streams — the state’s best waterways.
“The DEP needs to do a better job identifying the resources at risk, because if they’re not identified, they can’t and won’t be protected,” he said.
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.