The state Department of Environmental Protection has approved the first of a handful of permits needed to reopen the Tri-County Landfill near Grove City in Mercer County.

The DEP operating permit, announced Monday, allows Tri-County Inc. to construct a new landfill within the 99-acre footprint of the old one and bring in 600 truckloads or up to 4,000 tons of trash a day. It also requires the landfill operator to excavate more than 1.5 million cubic yards of waste from the old unlined landfill and relocate it to new lined and monitored areas of the landfill.

Reopening the landfill, which started operating in Liberty and Pine townships in 1950 and closed in 1990 after it couldn’t meet new state regulations, was opposed by those testifying at a public hearing in October 2019. They said the permit would allow the previous municipal trash landfill to also accept residual waste, a classification that includes construction waste, acid mine drainage sludge, and radioactive shale oil and gas drilling waste.

They also cited potential problems with noise, odors, truck traffic, water and air pollution, and bird-airplane collisions. The landfill, 60 miles north of Pittsburgh, is about 1.5 miles from the Grove City Airport, closer than Federal Aviation Administration rules allow.

Advertise with us

“DEP carefully reviewed the information contained in the permit applications, asked many questions and were eventually satisfied that Tri-County provided sufficient information to meet the regulatory requirements for approval,” James Miller, director of the DEP Northwest Regional Office, said in a DEP news release. “We gave careful consideration to the comments received from residents and Liberty and Pine townships and made sure Tri-County’s application addressed those concerns.”

Edward R. Vogel, vice president of Vogel Holding Inc., which owns the Tri-County Landfill and another in Butler County, the Seneca Landfill, said the amount of waste material from shale gas drilling and fracking operations ''depends on the market,” and added that most of that waste is handled by larger disposal firms.

Tri-County has applied for additional permits for water discharges, wetland mitigation and air emissions, and operation of the landfill cannot begin until all are approved. Mr. Vogel said he expects those approvals soon.

The DEP’s response document to public comments about fracking waste disposal said waste trucks are monitored at landfills for radioactivity, and it cites a 2004 study — done well before any shale gas development occurred in the state — that found only low levels of radioactive materials in landfill water runoff. The DEP document states, “the potential for negative effects on surface water from accepting oil and gas hydraulic fracturing wastes at the landfill should be minimal.”

But Jane Cleary, a member of the Citizens Environmental Association of the Slippery Rock Area, and one of more than two dozen people who voiced opposition to the landfill at the DEP hearing in October, said the department’s operating permit approval was “quite a shock.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Cleary said the group hadn’t met to decide whether it will appeal the permit approval, but it is continuing to press the department to hold another public hearing to get comments on the landfill’s water pollution discharge permit. The DEP did extend the comment period on that National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit to Jan. 12, but has not yet decided whether to hold a hearing.

She said the landfill intends to cover its perishable wet garbage with shale gas drilling and fracking waste, producing 85,000 to 120,000 gallons of runoff a day that contains radioactivity.

“Our concerns are that the landfill can’t treat that radioactive material,” Ms. Cleary said, “and it will flow into Wolf Creek, a tributary of Slippery Rock Creek.”

The 10-year operating permit would also allow Tri-State to increase the height of the 79-acre landfill from 40 feet to more than 100 feet, a height that has prompted opponents to dub it “Trash Mountain.” The total proposed capacity of the landfill would be 10.2 million cubic yards, or approximately 7.5 million tons, according to the DEP.

The permit allows the landfill to operate 24 hours a day, six days a week (Monday through Saturday), but will only dispose of waste subject to decay, such as household garbage, during nighttime hours to reduce the attraction of birds in the area of the nearby airport.

Advertise with us

”The birds of concern are seagulls,” Mr. Vogel said, “and seagulls only feed during the day.”

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1983.