Carl E. Jones Jr. has resigned as director of the state Department of Environmental Protection’s Office of Environmental Justice, just two years after taking the job and before he could implement changes that would extend the office’s review and protections to shale gas permitting.

Environmental justice advocates are concerned that the vacancy, at a time when the DEP faces budget cuts, could delay the fulfillment of the department’s goal to recognize, elevate and address the interests of poor and minority communities.

Mr. Jones’ departure on Oct. 12, to become a staff attorney in Philadelphia with Earthjustice, a national environmental law firm, leaves the DEP with only two regional environmental justice staffers on the department’s payroll.

“I am troubled by the deconstruction of the DEP in Harrisburg. They’re carving the heart out of the department, and losing the EJ director is really disheartening,” said Larry Schweiger, president and chief executive officer of Citizens for Pennsylvania’s Future.

Advertise with us

He said that given the possible health impacts associated with fracking, allowing drilling to occur in poor and rural residential areas without environmental justice program review is “outrageous.”

There are more than 850 environmental justice communities in the state, defined as those where at least 20 percent of the population is living below the poverty line or 30 percent are non-white. Hundreds of gas wells, compressor stations and pipelines have been installed in those communities without Environmental Justice office review or citizen input.

James Rosenberg, a Fayette Marcellus Watch member who testified at one of nine “listening sessions” held by Mr. Jones’ office this spring, said he’s less concerned about the director than he is about strengthening the policies of the office.

“I want the EJ office to do oil and gas permit reviews. That should have been happening already,” Mr. Rosenberg said. “But if oil and gas permits are just added to the trigger list to help enhance public participation, I’ve got to ask: What is the point if there’s no requirement to change those permits?”

The DEP established an Office of Environmental Advocate in 2002 to help minority and poor communities learn about potential health and environmental impacts from proposed industrial developments such as landfills, industrial wastewater facilities, commercial waste incinerators and concentrated animal feedlots, all of which are disproportionately located in those places. The office name was changed to Environmental Justice in 2014, but shale gas development proposals weren’t added to the list of industrial use permits that trigger notification of residents living near those wells, pipelines and compressor stations.

Advertise with us

When Mr. Jones was appointed director in October 2015, the Environmental Justice office had been without a director or staff for more than two months, and then-DEP Secretary John Quigley said the office’s mission would be “rebuilt from the ground up.”

“Clearly the department has suffered through more than 10 years of budget cuts and is struggling to meet its mission,” Mr. Quigley said last week. “The EJ office needs to work statewide, and whether the DEP budget allows for that is an open question.”

Kirk Jalbert, a member of the state’s environmental justice advisory board, said Mr. Jones had been making good progress on updating the state’s environmental justice policies and participation tools but had been hampered by staffing and budget limitations and industry opposition.

“My personal opinion is that the EJ changes are being held close to the chest because revising those policies is not a popular topic for the industries, from oil and gas to landfills, to wastewater,” Mr. Jalbert said.

He also noted that a proposal that would require the DEP to use private, licensed contractors to speed permit approvals could further reduce opportunities for Environmental Justice participation and review.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s a particularly important time in the Environmental Justice conversation at the DEP. Now we have an opportunity to put oil and gas permitting into the EJ conversation,” said Mr. Jalbert, a researcher at Fractracker, a nonprofit that maps and tracks risks related to oil and gas development. “But at the same time, the department is facing draconian rules changes about farming out permit application approval work that could thwart that. EJ communities deserve better.”

Contacted at his new Earthjustice office last week, Mr. Jones said adding oil and gas permits to a trigger list isn’t as important as developing a “holistic policy approach” that encompasses community information, permitting, enforcement and compliance.

“Most members of EJ communities are aware of what’s going on now. But information only gets you so far,” Mr. Jones said. “The EJ office must more actively engage with the community on a grassroots level to make sure people who don’t have a voice have a voice.”

He said his new position, manning Earthjustice’s first Pennsylvania office in Philadelphia will allow him to do “a lot more on clean energy issues and in environmental justice communities in the state to get their voices heard by government and in the courts.”

DEP Secretary Patrick McDonnell said last week that budget concerns would not prevent him from filling the EJ director’s job, but he added that the process could take two months. Arthur Frank, chair of the EJ advisory board, said the board feels strongly that it should have input on Mr. Jones’ replacement, and the secretary said it will.

Advertise with us

But adding oil and gas permits to the EJ trigger list is more difficult, Mr. McDonnell said

“We are looking at updates to the EJ policy,” he said. “We’re trying to figure out the mechanics of how to do an EJ review since the gas law requires us to issue permit rulings within 45 days and our review process now pretty much exhausts that time. But we remain very much committed to addressing environmental justice issues.”

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.