The Pittsburgh region too often still has an oily, sulfuric, industrial “stink,” and tougher regulation is needed to reign in the unhealthy malodors, said Mark Dixon, who testified at an Allegheny County Health Department hearing last week on permit changes at coke and steel making facilities in the Mon Valley.

Mr. Dixon, a Squirrel Hill resident and independent environmental filmmaker, said the proposed permit adjustments at U.S. Steel’s Clairton Coke Works, its Irvin Works in West Mifflin and its Edgar Thomson Works and Braddock Recovery Inc. in Braddock don’t go far enough, fast enough.

Mr. Dixon said the malodorous days are linked closely to the region’s numerous weather inversions, which trap industrial emissions in low-lying areas along the region’s rivers, and he called out the steelmaker and the health department for not doing more to prevent the smelly, unhealthy industrial pollution.

He was particularly critical of the steelmaker’s plans to construct a 230-foot tall emissions stack at the Edgar Thomson Works, which he said was too short to break through the inversions — commonly at an altitude of 300 feet — and disperse sulfur dioxide and volatile organic compounds.

Advertise with us

“We can no longer tolerate half-measures,” Mr. Dixon said. “It’s well past time to bring Pittsburgh into the 21st century. We can and must use innovative industrial approaches to eliminate the stench in this great city once and for all.”

The proposed permit changes include use of lower-sulfur coke oven gas for fuel at the Braddock Recovery facility and at the Irvin and Edgar Thomson steel plants. They also include increased monitoring of and improvements to the desulfurization facility at the Clairton Coke Works and upgrades at Edgar Thomson to the flue gas system that will improve dispersion of emissions from existing boilers. Those upgrades include the new emissions stack.

Meghan Cox, a U.S. Steel spokeswoman, issued a statement saying the company is “committed to significant reductions of sulfur dioxide,” and is working collaboratively with the health department.

She said the height of the new stack at Edgar Thomson conforms to a county air dispersion model that accounts for inversions, and “a 300-foot stack is not required based upon the modeling that ACHD used.”

The permit changes would allow the four industrial facilities to comply with the 2010 one-hour, national ambient air quality standards for sulfur dioxide. But Thurman Brendlinger, energy project director for the Clean Air Council, a statewide environmental group, said the Oct. 4, 2018, attainment date in the permits provides the company with too much time to do the work.

Advertise with us

Written testimony submitted by the council also urged the health department to clarify and correct errors in emissions totals for the steelmakers facilities, require emissions stack testing before the final compliance date and require more stringent quarterly emissions testing.

The health department is required to seek approval of the installation permit modifications from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency before they can be incorporated in the Pennsylvania State Implementation Plan, a federal planning document that identifies major sources of air pollution and identifies strategies to reduce emissions. There is no timetable for seeking federal approval.

Edgar Thomson is listed non-compliant with county air pollution regulations due to “numerous emissions violations,” according to an online list of significant air pollution sources in the county.

The Clairton Coke Works also has had numerous emissions violations but is listed as complying with a March 2016 consent order schedule intended to “drive the source into compliance.”

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.