WASHINGTON — The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Monday ruled that undated or misdated mail-in and absentee ballots “shall not be counted” by any of the state’s boards of elections — including in the handful of counties where Democratic officials already voted to defy the high court’s previous rulings on the matter in the middle of a high-stakes U.S. Senate race that’s headed to a recount.

State and national Republican leaders have pledged to fight what they describe as a brazen betrayal of public trust by Pennsylvania Democratic election officials as the heated race between Sen.-elect David McCormick and incumbent Sen. Bob Casey plays out in court.

Mr. McCormick leads Mr. Casey by about 17,000 votes — a margin that’s within the half-a-percentage-point threshold for a state-mandated recount, but one that Republicans say is insurmountable. The race was called by the Associated Press two days after Election Day.

But the race is also tied up in Pennsylvania’s court system after at least Philadelphia, Bucks, Montgomery and Centre counties chose to count batches of hundreds of undated or misdated mail ballots — with some officials openly acknowledging they’re doing so in defiance of state Supreme Court rulings.

Advertise with us

Democrats, including Mr. Casey’s campaign attorneys, say the defiance is grounded in protecting voters’ rights according to the state constitution. Republicans blast it as electioneering on Mr. Casey’s behalf, and pledged Monday to pursue legal action against local officials who’ve openly defied the state’s highest court. The McCormick campaign, Republican National Committee and state GOP have asked the state Supreme Court to block the counties from counting the deficient ballots.

The Supreme Court answered late Monday afternoon in a 4-3 decision, saying the counties in question “shall comply with the prior rulings of this court in which we have clarified that mail-in and absentee ballots that fail to comply with the [dating requirements] SHALL NOT BE COUNTED” for the purposes of the 2024 election.

“Elections need rules and they must be applied consistently,” Lawrence Tabas, the state GOP chair, said in a call with reporters Monday.

He said the state Supreme Court previously ruled “clearly and unambiguously” that undated or incorrectly dated ballots will not be counted, and ruled on Nov. 1 that “it will not allow changes to existing election laws and procedures during the election,” even after a lower court ruling had struck down the dating requirements earlier this year.

In a concurring opinion Monday, Justice P. Kevin Brobson sought to “disabuse local elections officials of the notion that they have the authority to ignore Election Code provisions that they believe are unconstitutional ... Indeed, this Court has held that administrative agencies, like county boards of elections, lack the authority to declare unconstitutional the very statutes from which they derive their existence and which they are charged to enforce.”

Advertise with us

How the ruling fully plays out after the counties’ votes last week remains to be seen. But it’s clear in the eyes of the court, those batches of ballots won’t add any votes to Mr. Casey’s total.

Mr. Tabas called on Gov. Josh Shapiro to urge Bucks, Philadelphia, Montgomery and Centre counties to reverse course and disqualify undated ballots, as the overwhelming majority of the counties did.

In a statement after the state Supreme Court ruling, Mr. Shapiro said he believed all eligible votes should be counted in every race. He said local officials were left with a lack of clarity: “damned if they did and damned if they didn’t” count undated votes, “likely facing legal action no matter which decision they made.”

“The Department of State had advised counties repeatedly of their duty to segregate challenged provisional ballots and undated ballots in anticipation of a ruling by the court,” he added. “I expect all county election officials to adhere to this ruling and all the applicable laws governing our elections. As we move forward, I want to be clear: any insinuation that our laws can be ignored or do not matter is irresponsible and does damage to faith in our electoral process. The rule of law matters in this commonwealth, and as I have always said, it is critical for counties and officials in both parties to respect it with both their rhetoric and their actions.”

In Bucks County, Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia, a Democrat, said during a vote on the issue last week that “precedent by a court doesn’t matter anymore in this country. And people violate laws anytime they want. For me, if I violate this law, it’s because I want a court to pay attention to it.”

Advertise with us

The Bucks County Board of Elections voted along party lines to count more than 400 ballots that were incorrectly dated or had no date at all, despite warnings from Deputy Solicitor Dan Grieser that it may trigger a lawsuit, according to the Bucks County Courier Times.

Allegheny County will not count undated or misdated mail-in ballots during the Senate recount beginning on Wednesday, in line with the state Supreme Court’s decision from earlier this month.

The votes in question were primarily military and absentee overseas ballots that didn’t have to come in until Nov. 12, a full week after the election, said Abigail Gardner, the director of communications for County Executive Sara Innamorato. Any such ballots received after the deadline will not be counted, she added.

“This is a very normal part of the process that provisional ballots always take weeks to count,” she said. “Mail-in for overseas and military always have an extra week to come back. It happens every election year, it’s just that normally, elections are not close enough that most people continue to pay attention to that process in the days and weeks after Election Day. It does take extra time, but it’s truly just evidence of the process working. People should know that there’s a lot of care and research and staff time that goes into making sure that every eligible vote counts and that nothing that’s not eligible is counted.”

The Allegheny County Board of Elections approved an additional 1,310 provisional ballots to be counted out of the final 3,328 that were up for consideration during a meeting on Monday morning. Those ballots had been held back for a variety of reasons, not all of them due to voter errors; 302 provisional forms were missing a signature from at least one member of the board, which then voted unanimously to count them.

Advertise with us

All of the ballots that Allegheny County has already processed will take no more than two days to re-count, said Ms. Gardner. If no appeals are filed, the approved provisional ballots will be counted on Wednesday. If any ballots are challenged, they will be held for Judge John McVay Jr. in the Allegheny Court of Common Pleas later in the week, she said.

A spokesman for Attorney General Michelle Henry’s office told the Post-Gazette on Monday that the “matter is already being litigated by the parties and interested entities in the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. No state entity has been sued in that action, so our office does not have a client to represent. We will continue to monitor the situation and any developments that would prompt Office of Attorney General involvement.”

Mr. Casey’s campaign attorneys said in a filing with the state Supreme Court Friday that Republicans aim to disenfranchise voters whose constitutional rights would be violated if their vote is dismissed “solely because of a missing or incorrect handwritten date.”

“The Republican National Committee and the Republican Party of Pennsylvania … however, ask this court to turn a blind eye to those serious constitutional concerns and invoke its extraordinary King’s Bench power to short-circuit the regular judicial review process,” wrote Mr. Casey’s campaign lawyers. 

Attorneys for Philadelphia, Bucks and Montgomery counties noted in a court filing that the state Supreme Court stayed the lower court’s decision on ballot dating requirements and “did not decide the merits of the underlying constitutional question.” The attorneys said Republicans were improperly asking for “an expedited, sweeping edict directing all 67” counties not to count undated or misdated ballots — even though “there are multiple cases percolating through the system that will provide an opportunity for this court to address these issues in an orderly fashion and on a full record.” 

Advertise with us

Mr. Casey’s supporters have also noted that Mr. McCormick fought to include undated ballots on constitutional grounds during a narrow primary loss against celebrity doctor Mehmet Oz two years ago. At the time, his attorneys said those voters were being disenfranchised over “a technical error that is immaterial under both state and federal law.” 

“Pennsylvanians deserve to trust that when they cast a vote legally, it is counted,” Mr. Casey posted on X Monday afternoon. “Regardless of the final result, I am committed to ensuring Pennsylvanians’ voices are heard.”

But Mr. Tabas, RNC Chairman Michael Whatley, and U.S. Rep. Dan Meuser called out Democratic officials for their actions Monday, saying they were trying to tip the scales in Mr. Casey’s favor. The Republicans were adamant, however, that Mr. McCormick has the votes to win regardless of ballots left to adjudicate or the recount set to be completed by Nov. 26.

“When election officials pick and choose at the last minute which rules to follow and which to ignore, it naturally leads voters to lose trust in the process,” said Mr. Whatley. “The RNC and the Republican Party in Pennsylvania are aggressively fighting back to bring an end to this corrupt and despicable conduct.”

Mr. McCormick’s spokeswoman, Elizabeth Gregory, called Monday’s ruling “a massive setback to Senator Casey’s attempt to count illegal ballots. Bucks County and others blatantly violated the law in an effort to help Senator Casey.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Meuser said in a “worst-case scenario,” Mr. Casey could tighten the margin by little more than 3,000 more votes. He noted that in three statewide recounts since 2000, the average change was fewer than 400 votes.

“The race was called for good reason,” he said. “There’s no mathematical way to achieve what the Casey folks think they can achieve.” 

Post-Gazette reporter Adam Babetski contributed.