Incumbent Democratic Sen. Bob Casey and leading Republican candidate David McCormick are headed for a recount in a controversial race that could flip a key swing state seat for the GOP.

Here’s what Pennsylvanians need to know about the recount process:

What is a recount?

A recount is the process of re-tallying all of the votes cast in an election to make sure that the results are accurate.

In Pennsylvania, votes that were cast electronically are recounted using a different tabulation method than the first time to check if the numbers are the same. Paper ballots, which make up the vast majority of Pennsylvania’s votes, are recounted by hand.

Advertise with us

What triggers a recount?

Under Pennsylvania’s current recount law laid out in Act 97, a recount triggers automatically if the margin of an election or ballot measure is still within half of a percentage point by the second Thursday following election day.

As of Wednesday afternoon, Mr. McCormick led Mr. Casey by 0.43 percentage points, a margin of fewer than 30,000 votes.

Mr. Casey could have stopped the recount by writing to Mr. Schmidt, but his campaign believes that he still has the votes to win. Just over 80,000 mail-in, absentee, and provisional ballots had not been counted by the time the recount was triggered – theoretically enough to close the 30,000-vote gap between the two candidates.

How often do recounts happen?

This is the eighth time a recount has been triggered in an election in Pennsylvania since Act 97 passed in 2004. Of the seven previous races eligible for a recount, four proceeded.

Mr. McCormick was involved in the most recent recount in 2022 when he trailed Mehmet Oz in the Republican Senate primary by a razor-thin margin of 0.07 percentage points, or 972 votes. The automatic recount affirmed Mr. Oz’s victory and Mr. McCormick promptly conceded.

Advertise with us

How long will a recount take?

As outlined in Act 97, the 67 county boards of elections must begin their recounts by Wednesday, Nov. 20, and complete them by noon on Tuesday, Nov. 26. The boards must send Mr. Schmidt the results of their recounts no later than noon on Wednesday, Nov. 27.

Will a recount change the outcome?

Recounts that have changed the result of a statewide election are exceptionally rare. Of the 6,929 statewide election recounts across the country between 2000 and 2023, only three resulted in the trailing candidate coming out ahead, according to an analysis by the election-focused nonprofit FairVote.

The four automatic recounts that have taken place in Pennsylvania during that time have all confirmed the leading candidates’ victories.

Facing long odds, Mr. Casey has decided to stay in until the last ballot is counted.

“The American democratic process was born in Pennsylvania and that process will play out,” he wrote in a post on X earlier this week.

Advertise with us

The Associated Press called the race for Mr. McCormick on Nov. 7, writing that the outstanding votes “were not enough in areas supporting Casey for him to make up the difference.” The New York Times has yet to call the race.

Mr. McCormick has urged Mr. Casey to concede and has already moved into an office on Capitol Hill.

"Senator-Elect McCormick’s lead is insurmountable, which the AP made clear in calling the race,” Mr. McCormick’s spokeswoman, Elizabeth Gregory, wrote in a statement after the recount was approved. “A recount will be a waste of time and taxpayer money, but it is Senator Casey’s prerogative. Senator-Elect McCormick knows what it’s like to lose an election and is sure Senator Casey will eventually reach the right conclusion."

Mr. McCormick has filed several lawsuits and appeals to invalidate batches of votes across the state, including 405 misdated or undated ballots in Bucks County that he alleges the local board of elections counted in violation of the state’s ballot dating requirement. How many of these votes were for Mr. Casey has not been released publicly.

During a news conference last Friday, Mr. McCormick said that his campaign’s legal action was merely procedural, rather than being sparked by a concern that he could lose.