A panel of Pennsylvania-based legal experts broke down the impact of several election lawsuits and spoke about police responses to potential unrest in the latest press conference hosted by Keep Our Republic, a nonprofit focused on explaining legal issues in this year’s swing states.
Violence at polling stations and election offices is a top concern for election officials following significant unrest during the 2020 election. This year, officials in local counties like Butler and Washington, among others, have installed bulletproof glass and panic buttons to guard against potential threats.
In Allegheny County, plainclothes constables will observe security at polling places and sheriffs will be parked at a distance in patrol cars, while county police will protect the warehouses where votes are being counted, said Pittsburgh-based former U.S. Attorney Frederick Thieman.
Mr. Thieman urged voters not to be misled by the lack of uniformed officers at polling stations.
“That's to make sure decoding takes place without any appearance of threat [or] coercion,” he said. “But it doesn't mean that the law enforcement community isn't entirely focused on security, more so than any time in the past.”
Former federal judge John Jones III said that county governments have conducted “tabletop exercises” and are prepared to handle election-related incidents.
Read More
“Law enforcement is standing at the ready, and there would be a pretty rapid response in the event that anybody gets hassled or threatened on election day,” he said. “I suspect there's going to be a very low tolerance for that, given the prevailing climate.”
Mr. Jones addressed a recently dismissed lawsuit filed by Republican U.S. Reps. Guy Reschenthaler, Dan Meuser, Glenn Thompson, Lloyd Smucker, and Mike Kelly against Secretary of State Al Schmidt challenging the state’s verification process for military and overseas voters. The representatives argued that Pennsylvania’s overseas ballots should be segregated from the rest of the state’s votes until the case was resolved – a request that Mr. Jones previously said reminded him of Republican attempts at voter suppression during the 2020 Election.
The U.S. District Court dismissed the case on Oct. 29 in observance of the “Purcell principle,” which says that courts should not change the basics of voting procedures just before an election.
Middle District Judge Christopher Conner ruled that the plaintiffs had access to this information years ago and waited too long to speak up about it, said Mr. Jones.
As such, Pennsylvania will continue to exempt overseas voter applicants from certain eligibility requirements. Republicans have moved on to challenging thousands of overseas ballots individually, but since Mr. Schmidt has provided guidance about proper voter registration, county election bureaus should deny the petitions fairly quickly, said Mr. Jones.
In another case, the Pennsylvania Democratic Party filed suit against the Erie County Board of Elections over several issues regarding the county’s mail-in ballots. In an “epic fail” by the Board’s ballot vendor, ElectionIQ, at least 13,000 Erie County residents who applied for mail-in ballots did not receive one, and an additional 365 received ballots with the wrong voter’s barcode, said Mr. Jones.
The court ruled that the Board had to expand its hours through election day to allow affected voters to cast ballots at drop boxes at the Erie County Courthouse. Voters who received incorrect ballots – as well as those for whom the ballots were intended – can cast replacement ballots to rectify the issue. Their signatures will be compared to what the Board has on file and will be reviewed after Election Day if they do not match.
“It's pretty messy, but it appears that the relief afforded by the court will let eligible voters vote, albeit not the way they had hoped to in the beginning of the process,” said Mr. Jones.
The State Supreme Court affirmed on Oct. 23 that voters who forgot their secrecy envelopes could cast provisional ballots, clarifying three conflicting statutes about technical defects in ballots. The United States Supreme Court then denied a Republican attempt to delay enforcement of the ruling until after the election, which was “not a big surprise” because the challenge was based on fringe legal theories, said Robert Cindrich, a former federal judge in Pittsburgh.
The State Supreme Court ruled on Nov. 1 that undated mail-in ballots will not be counted in this year’s election. This was to clear up any confusion from an Oct. 30 Commonwealth Court ruling that mandated the Philadelphia Board of Elections count otherwise valid mail-in votes for the city’s special election from September, said Mr. Cindrich.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.