The Pennsylvania Supreme Court late Friday put on hold a ruling by a lower court concerning undated and improperly dated mail ballots, saying it might have created confusion just days ahead of the presidential election.
The stay issued in response to a filing by Republicans was one of several election-related court actions in various venues and places entering the last weekend before the election Tuesday. In another, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected an appeal by Republicans in an action that cleared the way for some Pennsylvania voters whose mail ballots are deemed invalid to cast provisional ballots in person.
And in Erie County late Friday, a judge ordered the elections offices in the county courthouse to be open to the public on both Saturday and Sunday after a series of mistakes that could have affected roughly 17,000 mail ballots.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, in an unsigned order, issued a stay on a ruling issued only two days earlier by Commonwealth Court pertaining to undated and improperly dated mail ballots -– and justices made clear they believed the lower court should not have taken action so close to the election.
The case originated in Philadelphia. The Board of Elections there ruled soon after a pair of September special elections for two state House seats that a small number of undated or improperly dated mail ballots would not be counted.
A series of court filings culminated with Wednesday’s Commonwealth Court ruling that the ballots should be counted.
Read More
The lower court ruling was clear that it applied only to the Philadelphia situation. But Republicans who went to the Supreme Court for the stay said the ruling “unleashed chaos” by opening the possibility that other courts around the state might look at it as a guide.
Justice Christine Donohue, joined by Chief Justice Debra Todd, wrote in a statement that “county boards of election might look to it for guidance in canvassing and pre-canvassing mail in ballots in the upcoming election thus disturbing the status quo.”
Separately, Justice Kevin Dougherty harkened back to a statement the Supreme Court had made only weeks earlier that said, “This court will neither impose nor countenance substantial alterations to existing laws and procedures during the pendency of an ongoing election.” The justice wrote that those words “apparently were not heard in the Commonwealth Court, the very court where the bulk of election litigation unfolds. Today’s order, which I join, rights the ship.”
The order from the state Supreme Court said it was putting the Commonwealth Court ruling on hold for the Nov. 5 election but left open the possibility of considering an appeal.
Meanwhile, in Erie, Judge David Ridge issued the order that opened the main county elections office on both Saturday and Sunday. The judge identified multiple mistakes involving groups of mail ballots and called for the extended office hours and other measures to address the situation.
The judge said as many as 17,000 voters may not have received mail ballots they requested.
Besides the extended hours, the judge also ordered the county Board of Elections to add an additional printer immediately, and to allow voters who requested a mail ballot to cancel that existing request and be issued a new mail ballot immediately.
He also ordered the release of names of about 1,200 county voters who temporarily live out-of-state who requested mail ballots but did not receive them.
The judge also found that at least 365 duplicate ballots were sent to voters with barcodes that pertained to different voters, and he ordered that all those who received duplicate ballots be contacted by the board and specific steps be taken to rectify the problem.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.