ERIE, Pa. — Former President Donald Trump in a rally here Sunday emphasized Erie County’s importance to the presidential race, and pledged to bring Pennsylvanians “to the promised land” if they send him back to the White House to reverse the so-called “radical” policies of Vice President Kamala Harris and President Joe Biden.

One of several recent visits by the candidates to the must-win Keystone State, Trump’s return to Erie nearly five weeks before Election Day put the spotlight on a crucial region where he encouraged voters to turn out in big numbers. The county twice voted for Democrat Barack Obama before flipping to Trump in 2016, then helped delivered a narrow win to Mr. Biden in 2020.

“Erie County was known as a Democrat area until Trump came along and then they said, ‘What the hell happened to Erie County?’ ” Trump said. “Well, we love you. We’re the same people. We need each and every one of you to make a plan to vote early, vote absentee. Do whatever you want. ... The main thing we have to do is get out the vote.”

Flanked by sign-waving supporters in bleachers under a massive screen occasionally reading “Too Big to Rig” and “Kamala is responsible for a broken economy, broken border and broken world,” Trump hit his standard bombastic rally and campaign talking points. He slammed Ms. Harris for her previous support for a fracking ban and criticized border and economic policies he claimed have left Pennsylvania and the country less safe and worse off. 

Advertise with us

“I think Nov. 5 will be the most important day, potentially, in the history of our country,” he said. “Our country is going bad. We have stupid people running it. If we win in Pennsylvania, we’ll win the whole thing. We’re going to win and turn our whole country around.”

Trump made clear he was well aware of Erie’s special status as a bellwether, saying he was glad to be among the region’s workers while claiming Mr. Biden was “sleeping” at a Delaware estate as Ms. Harris spent the day raising funds in San Francisco. In the past two elections, the candidate who went on to win the presidency did so after declaring victory in Erie County; Trump in 2016 and Mr. Biden in 2020, albeit by a less than 2% margin in each of those years.

Sunday’s appearance marks the former president’s second visit to Western Pennsylvania in a week, as the candidate blitz of the swing state continues. Trump was in Indiana and Westmoreland counties on Monday. Ms. Harris went to Carnegie Mellon University on Wednesday to talk economics, and GOP vice presidential candidate Sen. JD Vance of Ohio was in Monroeville Saturday for an event tied to the topics of addiction and religion.

Trump and Ms. Harris are effectively in a dead heat, and Democrats’ edge on voter registration in Pennsylvania has dwindled over the past few election cycles. Pollsters and number crunchers see the path to the White House as coming directly through Pennsylvania’s 19 Electoral College votes.

Trump plans to return to the state Saturday for a rally in Butler County, where in July a would-be assassin opened fire and nearly took his life. The shooting sparked ongoing investigations and concerns over security in a heightened threat environment for lawmakers on both sides of the aisle.

Advertise with us

The former president thanked Rep. Mike Kelly for chairing the bipartisan House task force investigating the assassination attempt. He also credited Democrats in Congress for their efforts investigating the attempt on his life, but he claimed Mr. Biden — who ordered heightened Secret Service protection for Trump after July 13 — had made life “more dangerous” for him by not publicly threatening nations like Iran who have been tied to assassination plots.

Trump said he plans next weekend to honor former firefighter Corey Comperatore, who was killed at the July 13 rally.

But immigration, crime and energy dominated Trump’s speech on Sunday. 

The Republican nominee stoked fear that more than 150 million immigrants could flood the country and make it “unrecognizable” if he doesn’t win. Towns in Pennsylvania and across the country, he claimed, are “petrified” of “stone cold killers” from across the U.S. border. He said rapists, murderers, human traffickers and drug dealers should send a “thank you note” to Ms. Harris for allegedly allowing them into the country. 

“The invasion ends and the deportations begin,” on day one of his second presidency, he pledged. 

Advertise with us

The FBI reported last week that the homicide rate declined in 2023 and is 16% lower than in 2020. Violent crime dropped again last year and is at a near 50-year low, the agency said. The White House cited more than $15 billion in public safety funding that helped state and local governments avoid cuts to police departments while investing in community violence interventions and other crime-cutting measures.

Trump also pledged to cut Pennsylvanians’ energy prices by 50% within a year of taking office. He promised to stop the temporary ban on approvals of new liquefied natural gas export terminals, along with electric vehicle mandates meant to help slash greenhouse gas emissions.

He repeated the false suggestion that Democrats only won in 2020 due to cheating, and he urged voters to turn out early and in large numbers — even if they see polls showing him tied or leading.

Lining up for the rally

The first people to arrive at the rally showed up at 1:30 a.m., more than 12 hours before the former president was scheduled to speak. “Front Row Joes,” as they call themselves, said they’ve been traveling the country, attending dozens of Trump rallies, before making their way to Erie.

Throughout the dreary morning, thousands lined up behind them — descending upon the shore of the Lake Erie bay to see the Republican nominee speak at the Bayfront Convention Center. Trump was scheduled to get on stage at 2 p.m., but started a bit late and spoke for more than 90 minutes.

Advertise with us

Those in line on Sunday were a mix of hard-core fans who’ve been with him for years and some who said more recent issues have convinced them he’s the right candidate this time around.

Topics ranging from the economy to immigration and allowing fracking to tap oil and gas in the state were on the attendees’ minds.

Jared Petri, a 24-year-old from Cleveland, was part of the group at the front of the line. “Some of us travel all over the country to follow [Trump] all over,” said Mr. Petri, who has attended more than 30 Trump rallies.

He was joined by Greg Cari, 61, from Lakewood, N.Y., who cast his first presidential ballot in 2016 when he voted for Trump.

“He piqued my interest and I liked what he had to say, and he wasn’t a politician, so I’m like, ‘I like this guy,’ ” Mr. Cari said. “When I listened to what he had to say and the things that were going on in this country that we didn’t pay attention to before he got into office.”

Advertise with us

The consensus among the group at the front of the line, aside from the need for coffee, was that immigration and the economy were the primary issues.

That sentiment was echoed by others in the crowd. “Now you go to a store, you get three bags of groceries and it cost you as much as a half a [shopping] cart used to,” said Jason Dunkle, a 43-year-old from Franklin. “Everything seems to be going downhill right now.”

Mr. Dunkle, who works in heavy equipment repair, said he is voting for Trump because life had been better for him four or five years ago.

Inflation has been a persistent problem in recent years, hitting a peak in 2022. It wasn’t until this month that the Federal Reserve policymakers saw inflation indicators fall to levels that would justify cutting benchmark interest rates.

Gracie Smith, 43, who lives in Erie, said she has been frequenting the local food bank to make ends meet and she hopes a Trump presidency will provide a boost to the economy.

Advertise with us

“I should not be crying every time I go to the grocery store trying to figure out what can last me the longest,” she said.

’You know what you’re getting’

Immigration, another key campaign issue, was top of mind among those in line. Ms. Harris went to the border last week to call for further tightening of asylum restrictions, with Trump using a rally in Wisconsin a day later to blame her for migrants committing crimes after entering the U.S. illegally.

Ms. Smith, who said her mother is Mexican and moved to the United States after meeting her American father, lamented the state of immigration.

“Being a resident alien, she did not have the same rights … we understood that,” Ms. Smith said. “Now she’s a citizen and does have certain rights now. So to see people come in illegally and get food stamps, housing allotment ... I can’t even get food.”

Dennis Gore, 59, from nearby Buffalo, N.Y., worried that people with criminal records are getting in. “It’s ridiculous common sense to make sure they’re vetted and safe to come here. … It’s a very common sense thing, but the Democrats don’t care. They just want power.”

Advertise with us

Up until a few weeks ago, Anthony McGowan, 50, had been a lifelong Democrat. He said he changed his mind after seeing Ms. Harris speak on television. He wasn’t convinced. “She never answers a direct question. You can see right through her.”

In his opinion, “Trump says it like it is. You know what you’re getting from Trump.”

Fracking — a controversial drilling method used to extract petroleum or natural gas from deep in the earth — has routinely been a point of contention between Republicans and Democrats.

Ms. Harris has said repeatedly that she will not ban fracking. But Trump claimed Sunday that people do not change, and that her policies would “decimate” Pennsylvania’s robust fossil fuel industry.

For the Millers, who travelled to Erie from just outside of Marienville in Forest County, a downturn in the energy industry can be felt throughout their community.

“In our area you either have oil and gas or you have timber, that’s it,” said Jake Miller, 66, who attended the rally with his wife, Sherry, and 38-year-old daughter Sarah.