In a whirlwind visit to Western Pennsylvania on Monday, former President Donald Trump met with farmers, business owners and many supporters, promising them all that if elected, he’ll put tariffs on companies doing business out of the country and lower the prices of their groceries and utilities.

Just outside Smithton in Westmoreland County, Trump sat with local farmers at a table set up in a farmer’s equipment barn, and actively participated in a roundtable discussion with the farmers, who discussed the issues they’ve been facing and pitched some ideas on how the federal government can help them be more successful.

Some of their ideas included tax breaks for Americans trying to buy farm land, incentivizing purchasers to buy domestic products over foreign-made ones and place tariffs on foreign products, particularly from China.

Trump heard their call for tougher tariffs loud and clear. After noticing two large John Deere tractors behind him in the barn, Trump said the company recently announced it’s moving part of its manufacturing to Mexico and said he would levy a 200% tariff on everything the company tries to import from there.

Advertise with us

“They think they'll make product cheaper in Mexico and then sell it in for the same price as they did before, making a lot of money but getting rid of our jobs,” Trump said.

He lauded John Deere as an iconic American brand, but said “if they want to build in country — in the United States — you go ahead, you can build in any one of 50 states. … But John Deere has got to understand that if they build in Mexico,” they will be facing 200% tariffs.

It’s not clear the impact that would have on farmers.

“I honestly don’t know,” said Bill Beam, a Chester County farmer who owns John Deere equipment and who served as the USDA deputy administrator of farm programs during the Trump administration regarding the impact it could have.

“I’m a farmer; I use a lot of John Deere equipment. I do know a lot of it is made in various countries already. I don’t know if we are paying tariffs now or not. You’d have to ask John Deere,” he said. “It’s a worldwide company.”

Advertise with us

“I don’t even want to touch the tariffs thing,” concluded Mr. Beam, who noted the Biden administration just put tariffs on solar panels; he knows, he said, because the move is going to increase the cost of a solar project he had been considering.

And that’s the point most economists make: Tariffs end up being paid by the consumer as companies pass the costs along.

When asked about that in Smithton, Trump said “the ones that understand business are all for it.”

Mona Pappafava-Ray, the president and CEO of General Carbide, a manufacturing company, said her business was trying to create different parts for agriculture equipment, but when it came down to it, potential customers preferred to buy Chinese products for a cheaper price.

“This is why you need tariffs,” Trump told her. Ms. Pappafava-Ray was one of five residents who spoke during the roundtable. Others were meat and dairy farmers that are seeing small family farms disappear and be replaced by large industrial-type farming.

Advertise with us

“We must be strong and powerful again and we must put tariffs on foreign predators,” Trump reiterated at his rally later in the day at Indiana University of Pennsylvania.

In addition to tariffs, several of the speakers in Westmoreland County bemoaned Chinese interests buying agricultural land in the U.S.

“We’ve got to stop this,” said former hedge fund CEO and Republican candidate for U.S. Senate David McCormick.

“It hasn't hit Pennsylvania much yet, but nationally it's growing dramatically,” Mr. McCormick said. “It'll come to Pennsylvania, too.”

Former President Trump speaks at the Smith Family Farm on Monday, Sept. 23, 2024, in Westmoreland County. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

However, Pennsylvania has a law from 1980 that restricts foreign ownership of agricultural land. In total, about 400,500 acres of agricultural land in Pennsylvania is foreign-owned, most of it by Canada, according to the most recent figures from the U.S. Department of Agriculture; 83% of it is forest land.

Advertise with us

Nationwide, China is not even in the top five countries that hold the most amount of agricultural land in the country, according to the USDA. Behind Canada is the Netherlands, Italy, the United Kingdom and Germany.

The Trump campaign has “to go a long way” to have Chinese-owned agricultural land be an issue in Pennsylvania, said Chris Herr, executive vice president of PennAg.

While it is an issue in the Midwest, according to an NPR analysis of 2021 USDA data, there are just 680 acres in Pennsylvania owned by entities from China — 1 acre in Lebanon County and 679 acres in Lehigh County owned by a development company that reports indicate were intended for a housing development.

About 60 miles north of Smithton, Trump made a pit stop at Sprankle’s Neighborhood Market in Kittanning to talk with the owner and some of the customers.

The Sprankle family has been in business for 25 years, but with inflation, owner Ryan Sprankle told the Republican candidate, their “prices are up but sales are down.”

Advertise with us

“It’s been brutal,” he said.

Donald Trump visits Sprankle's Neighborhood Market in Kittanning

Customers and Trump all lamented the rise in prices — particularly for groceries.

“Eggs are up 84%,” Trump said. “Bacon, I won’t even say what the price is. We’ve never seen numbers like this.”

While taking a short tour of the store, Trump promised the customers there that if he wins in November, he’ll lower the prices.

Trump dropped a few hundred dollar bills on the checkout conveyor belt and told the customer checking out: “[Your bill] just went down a couple hundred bucks. We’ll do that for you from the White House.”

Advertise with us

During the event at Smithton, Trump also promised that he would reduce Americans’ energy bills by 50% within his first year in office if elected.

He did not elaborate on how — but reiterated the promise at the rally Monday night.

“If you vote for me, I will cut your energy and electricity prices in half in 12 months,” he said at the rally.

As Trump’s motorcade crisscrossed the region, his supporters took any opportunity they could to line the streets and wave American or Trump flags or merchandise sporting Trump’s face as the vehicles passed.

Rounding out the day at the rally at IUP, hundreds of people turned out and filled the Ed Fry Arena to its capacity of about 5,000.

Advertise with us

In addition to his typical talking points, Trump specifically called out two Pittsburgh-centric matters: the pending sale of U.S. Steel and the small river town of Charleroi, Washington County.

He pledged to keep U.S. Steel American-owned, even as it waits on the final approvals of its acquisition by Japanese steelmaker Nippon.

“The United States needs steel production in case they need it in times of war,” Trump said. "We have to make U.S. Steel great again.”

On immigration, Trump repeated claims about the influx of Haitian immigrants to Charleroi, which has been thrust into the national spotlight after the former president first mentioned the town as part of a rally in Tucson, Ariz., two weeks ago.

He had cast Charleroi as a cautionary tale in his continuing rhetoric about Haitian immigrants, a group he previously accused — falsely — of stealing and eating pets in Springfield, Ohio.

Advertise with us

During Monday’s rally, he claimed that the town was full of "lawless gangs" and that Democrats were responsible for the rising immigrant populations in small towns.

"Think of the cruelty Kamala Harris is inflicting on the people of Pennsylvania," Trump said, claiming that they were overcrowding hospitals, schools, and other public institutions. "This isn't an attack on any group of people, it's common sense.”

One man who had been turned away at the door, while walking back to his car was overheard saying: “I’ve never seen this many people in Indiana. Not even on Jimmy Stewart’s 100th. Hulk Hogan has been here, John Cena … but I’ve never seen anything like this.”

Actor Jimmy Stewart grew up in Indiana.

“2016 or 2020 we never had the enthusiasm that we had right now,” Trump said during the Indiana rally.

Advertise with us

But it wasn’t all supporters outside the university arena.

A group of physicians showed up with a mobile billboard to protest Trump and his “concept of a plan” to replace Barack Obama’s Affordable Care Act if he wins a second term.

“The billboard is a little bit gimmicky, but necessary,” said Dr. Max Cooper, an emergency physician in southeastern Pennsylvania and co-state lead for the Committee to Protect Health Care.

Dr. Zeke Taylor, an anesthesiologist and critical care physician in the Philadelphia area, said that many of his patients are post-cardiac surgery and their conditions were discovered during exams covered by the ACA.

“Without the ACA, Medicaid, and the recent capping of insulin prices, many of my patients would be at increased risk of health care complications if they were unable to afford their insulin therapy,” he said.

Advertise with us

At all three stops, Trump found time to hit on topics regularly mentioned in his stump speeches including immigration and crime rates, while criticizing Vice President Kamala Harris on her handling of both issues.

Ms. Harris is scheduled to hold a campaign event in Pittsburgh on Wednesday, though further details have not been made available.