JOHNSTOWN, Pa. — Bisected by three rivers and once boasting a population of more than 67,000, Johnstown carries echoes of Pittsburgh’s story on a smaller scale: an economy once driven by steel mills and industry that has in many ways faded, leaving fewer and fewer people to carry on the area’s legacy.
This city famed for a catastrophic flood in the late 19th century has lately taken a spot on the nation’s stage for a different reason — both the Republican and Democratic presidential candidates have spent time here in recent weeks as they hunt for every available vote in the swing state of Pennsylvania.
Former President Donald Trump held a rally at 1st Summit Arena in late August, drumming up support from the 4,000 people who could fit inside the facility and hundreds more outside. This is friendly territory for him.
He carried Cambria County by roughly 37.3 percentage points against President Joe Biden in 2020, and by 37.1 points over Hillary Clinton in 2016. Mitt Romney, a Republican who has been critical of the former president, beat former President Barack Obama by 18 points in Cambria in 2012.
Undeterred, Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic nominee, spent time earlier this month at the city’s airport with hundreds of supporters and at a coffee shop in downtown Johnstown.
Nina Licastro, the chair of Cambria County’s Democratic Party, sees plenty of voters that her party and Republicans still have an opportunity to persuade.
Read More
“This isn't a countywide election. This is a statewide election … if you're the Democrats, you can't focus on just the big cities. And you can't just rely on the rural areas if you're Republican. That's just blatant,” Ms. Licastro said.
“Not everyone that owns a farm is Republican, and not everyone who lives in a big city is a Democrat.”
A political shift
Cambria wasn’t always ruby red politically.
Democrats once held a healthy registration advantage, according to the Johnstown Tribune-Democrat. Following local elections last year, the city’s newspaper of record reported that registration data in November 2000 showed 57,060 Democrats, 28,818 Republicans, and 5,500 voters registered as “other” in Cambria County.
By November 2023, 43,134 voters had registered as Republican, compared to 32,309 Democrats. More than 9,100 voters were registered as either third-party or with no affiliation.
The gap between the two major parties has since grown. As of mid-September, state data showed 45,239 Republicans, 31,595 Democrats, and more than 9,600 with no party affiliation or other.
The city, politically speaking, is a blue dot in a sea of red. According to Cambria County’s elections office, there were 5,386 registered Democrats in the city and 3,329 Republicans as of mid-September. More than 1,200 voters were either “no affilation” or “other.”
The city, now home to roughly 18,000 people, is laid out around a central park, where a farmers market was occurring the morning before Ms. Harris arrived at Classic Elements, the coffee shop and bookstore she visited Sept. 13.
It’s home to the Johnstown Inclined Plane, a funicular akin to the Monongahela and Duquesne inclines in Pittsburgh. And it’s the place Democrat John P. Murtha, the longest serving congressman in state history, called part of his home district from 1974 until his death in 2010.
Murtha’s name was well-known to both Democrats and Republicans at Ms. Harris’ appearance earlier this month.
Theresa Hilton, 70, of Johnstown, a Democrat who works in the food service industry, said political attitudes changed after Murtha died. The former congressman brought money and recognition to Johnstown, she said.
Ms. Hilton said she believes Ms. Harris will help working class people more than Trump. And she dislikes the former president’s claims of voter fraud, as she worked at the polls in Johnstown for two decades before stepping away from that work about 10 years ago.
Ray Costanzo, 75, is a retired carpenter who lives just outside Johnstown. He and his wife, Florence, 73, used to be Democrats but switched when Mr. Obama was in office. She attended a local rally for Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry in 2004.
In more recent years, they felt Democrats weren’t doing enough to support working-class residents — except for Murtha, who rose above politics to achieve bipartisan popularity, they said.
“He brought a lot of business here, and he was for the people of Johnstown,” Mr. Costanzo said.
Mike Butler, a Democratic political strategist in Pittsburgh who follows state politics, said Murtha was as much a household name in the Johnstown area as former President John F. Kennedy was to Catholic families nationwide in the 1960s.
It was hard to dislike the former congressman, even if you disliked his politics, Mr. Butler said. And he was a leader not only in Johnstown but also on Capitol Hill.
“He had huge appeal locally, but was a significant player in D.C., [and] brought beaucoup dollars back to the district, in an era where bringing home the bacon was kind of a congressman's primary task and how they were judged,” Mr. Butler said. “No one in the country did it better than him.”
Even prominent Republicans, such as Jackie Kulback, chair of the Cambria County Republican Committee, have been surprised by the surge in voter registration for the GOP this year. They hope Trump can win 75% of the county vote this year.
“These voters are just frustrated with how their lives have changed under the Biden administration,” Ms. Kulback said. “The price of housing has gone through the roof where young families can't afford houses, even here in Johnstown, unless you want to live in a troubled neighborhood, [and] the crime and the drug-related crimes have skyrocketed.”
Voters offer their assessments
Many families have deep roots here. William Felton, 60, can trace his family’s history to before the Great Flood of 1889, which killed more than 2,000 people.
He and other voters who were in Johnstown when Ms. Harris visited represented a microcosm of the current deep political divide.
Mr. Felton, who attended Trump’s rally in August, said Bethlehem Steel “crippled” the area economically when it closed its plant in 1992. He said he believes Trump would help to bring back economic vitality to Johnstown.

Christine Alvarez, 58, was finishing lunch with a friend at Coney Island Lunch — a business that has served patrons for more than a century — when she heard Ms. Harris was in town earlier this month.
A laundromat owner, Ms. Alvarez said economic conditions for small businesses “went to hell” with Mr. Biden as president. Ms. Harris would be no different, she said.
“I would like to get a loan, but I’m not getting a loan at the high interest rates that they’ve raised it to,” she said. “If Trump gets back in … interest rates are going to go down, [and] I can get new equipment for my business.”
Senda Harvey, 64, is a relative newcomer to Johnstown, having been in the city for about two years. A Laurel Highlands Health employee and Army veteran, Ms. Harvey said she strongly opposed the former president.
“I’m 100% committed to Harris, being a Black, female veteran. It’s ridiculous that I swore to uphold the Constitution, and Trump doesn’t seem to know what the Constitution is,” she said. “He’s a convicted felon. If I did anything close to that, I would be under the prison.
Maurice Reed, 40, moved to Johnstown from Philadelphia about 20 years ago. Mr. Reed, who owns Grind Hard, a custom T-shirt and apparel shop, said he supports the vice president.
He was surprised that the campaign did not further scout Black businesses in the area. Johnstown has a Black population of roughly 21%, and multiple Black supporters were present earlier this month hoping to see the vice president, who is of Black and South Asian heritage.
Mr. Reed, who is Black and a Democrat, added that local leadership — the mayor, City Council, and others — are responsible for helping revitalize cities like Johnstown. It’s not just the president, he said.
That’s where, despite being a supporter of Trump and a Republican, Judy Cramer, 63, agreed. Ms. Cramer, a nurse and owner of a Dairy Queen, said Johnstown city government must do more to help the city.
But there are still economic conditions for which she blames Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris. For example, propane needed for her Dairy Queen has gone up from about $400 a month to $1,100 since the two have been in office Ms. Cramer said.
And there’s the divisive political environment that has driven a wedge between her and her 29-year-old daughter, she said. Her daughter supports Ms. Harris, and the two don’t agree on pretty much any political issue — except perhaps gun rights.
“This is our last election to maintain freedom,” Ms. Cramer said. “Once socialism comes, you can’t vote it out.”
Earl Dixon, 62, moved from Pittsburgh to Johnstown three years ago when his landlord ended his lease. Mr. Dixon, who is Black, said he didn’t plan to retire in a conservative region like Cambria County, where he frequently sees Confederate flags and other hate symbols.
Mr. Dixon has voted for candidates from both parties in the past but said he supported Mr. Biden in 2020 against Trump, a “malignant narcissist.”
“Hannibal Lecter could have been running and I would have selected him,” he quipped.
Mr. Dixon compared Trump’s campaign to Germany in the 1930s and said he is leaning toward voting for Ms. Harris despite being unhappy with some of her policies, particularly her handling of the southern border.
The final stretch
Political observers say the Trump and Harris campaigns will continue to swing through rural areas in Pennsylvania.
In an election where polls show the race is close, neither candidate can take any area of the Keystone State for granted, they said.
Trump can’t assume he'll win by the margins he did in rural areas in 2020 and 2016. Ms. Harris would be unwise to exclusively rely on large Democratic cities alone to win the state, political observers said.
Most Democrats and Republicans — pollsters estimate over 80% — have chosen their candidate and aren’t open to appeals from the other side.
An example of a voter critical to both campaigns is Matt Chalich, 47, an independent.
The Johnstown native said outside Ms. Harris’ appearance at the Classic Elements coffee shop that both Republicans and Democrats were supporting candidates representing “corrupt rot” in Washington, D.C.
Trump’s ego, including about crowd sizes at rallies, turns him off, but Ms. Harris’ visits to coffee shops behind closed doors are “more scripted than Game of Thrones.”
He doesn’t know yet how he will vote.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.