STONYCREEK, Pa. — A day after their first and possibly only debate, both candidates for president appeared at the Flight 93 memorial in Somerset County to pay respects on the 23rd anniversary of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.
President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris emerged from behind a black curtain at the Flight 93 National Memorial wall about 12:35 p.m. Wednesday. They placed a white and red wreath at the memorial. Both were silent and did not address the crowd before walking through the memorial and to the crash site in a field about 150 yards away.
There were roughly 200 attendees — some of whom were relatives of the Flight 93 victims, and some of whom were Donald Trump supporters wearing Trump hats and T-shirts, including at least one that contained vulgarities about the vice president.
Forty passengers and crew members lost their lives in September 2001 after thwarting a planned terrorist attack on the nation’s Capitol. All told that day, nearly 3,000 people died in a series of attacks that also targeted the Pentagon and New York City’s Twin Towers. The passengers and crew of Flight 93 fought for control of the hijacked plane, resulting in the crash here.
Some of those in attendance at the ceremonies Wednesday said they were disappointed by the relatively low turnout, believing it to be a sign “that people are forgetting.”
Former President Donald Trump arrived about 1:50 p.m., about 45 minutes after Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris had left. He got some cheers from the crowd, flashing a thumbs-up before helping to place another wreath in front of the memorial wall with a family member of one of those on Flight 93. He, too, visited the site of the impact.
Read More
Upon returning to the wall, Trump paused to address the crowd still gathered. He thanked them and gave a few fist pumps, which was answered with more cheers.
According to pool reports, Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris also stopped at the Shanksville Volunteer Fire Department, where they greeted firefighters and paid their respects at a cross made from scraps of the plane that stands outside the firehouse. Not long after that, Mr. Trump visited the department, too, to recognize its efforts.
Mr. Biden put his arm around a man and crossed himself while looking at the cross. Ms. Harris appeared solemn and respectful, according to pool reports, flashing smiles occasionally as a firefighter spoke privately with the two.
Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris were then escorted inside to meet with family and friends of the passengers and crew.
They did not make public remarks.
Before Mr. Biden, Ms. Harris and Mr. Trump walked the memorial’s hallowed grounds, the National Park Service partnered with Friends of Flight 93 National Memorial, the Salvation Army, the Red Cross and Pennsylvania State Police to hold the 23rd ceremony recognizing the 40 people who made the ultimate sacrifice Sept. 11, 2001.
Under a clear sky, family members and people from around the country sat in solitude as the 40 names were read. Some relatives of those lost read the names of their loved ones. Fred Lukachinsky, president of Friends of Flight 93, and Donna Gibson, executive director of that organization, rang a large and small bell, respectively, as each name was read.
Some family members held back tears as the names were read.
For Mr. Lukachinsky, 58, every time here brings a new perspective. The Cranberry resident who did not have a family member on Flight 93 tries to visit the site at least monthly, he said.
“Every time I'm here, it's for the first time,” said Mr. Lukachinsky, finishing his third year as president of the organization. “And I mean that with all sincerity. And for me, that makes it tender, it makes it gentle. But it makes it very harsh at the same time.”
Kevin Rahn, a retired police sergeant with the New York Police Department, was visiting the memorial site for the first time since he made the trek in the months after the crash 23 years ago.
Mr. Rahn, 68, responded to the Twin Towers falling in New York City, and said he was about a block-and-a-half from the site when the second tower fell. He ducked beneath a truck and made his peace with God — and then, after he survived, he tried to find survivors.
He found out later that afternoon about Flight 93. Two months later, he visited the temporary memorial — a chain link fence and wooden posts. Someone had made wooden angels representing everyone on the plane. And an older man, probably in his 70s, was standing guard, holding a spiral notebook that served as a visitor log.
The man told Mr. Rahn that the memorial site was guarded 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
Mr. Rahn said first responders were brave that day, but it’s important not to forget about the flight crews, especially for younger generations, people who either were too young to process what was happening or were not yet born.
“I just want everybody to remember. And unfortunately, you ask some high school kids today what the significance of Dec. 7 is, and they don't know,” Mr. Rahn said, referring to the Pearl Harbor attack that brought the United States into World War II. “So I just don't want this day to become like that.”
Gov. Josh Shapiro, accompanied by his wife, Lori, and Lt. Gov. Austin Davis arrived at the wall of names 10 to 15 minutes before Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris arrived.
He told reporters after the two held the private wreath-laying ceremony with family members that Mr. Biden’s message to them was about America’s spirit and triumph after tragedies such as Sept. 11. Mr. Shapiro referred to a law that he signed months ago making sure that students in public schools statewide hold a moment of silence on Sept. 11, along with curriculum updates to ensure that they learn about what happened.
“What I'm humbled by serving as governor here is to welcome these families and to allow them the freedom to just share the stories of their loved ones, to share the stories of the people that mattered so much in their lives, and the way they've carried their memory on,” Mr. Shapiro said.
One of those family members was Patrick White, 72, of Naples, Fla., a cousin of Louis J. Nacke II, one of the men who rushed and broke into the cockpit after terrorists took over Flight 93. Mr. Nacke liked wine, fast cars, and had a Superman tattoo on his arm, Mr. White said. A Superman figurine was sitting at the foot of Mr. Nacke’s place on the wall of names.
Mr. Biden’s remarks at the private wreath laying were “very inspiring,” Mr. White said. And he said that losses in Mr. Biden’s life — a car crash that killed his first wife, Neilia and 13-month-old daughter, Naomi, in December 1972, and his son Beau Biden dying from brain cancer in May 2015 — were perhaps part of that.
“I believe he can identify with us because of the loss of his family members ... it’s heartfelt, I know that,” Mr. White said. “You feel it in his grip, you see it in his eyes.”
He also spent time with Trump at the crash site. Mr. White thanked the former president for bringing recognition to the events of Flight 93, and said Trump asked family members about the events of Sept. 11, 2001.
There also was a light-hearted moment as they came back to the Ceremonial Gate next to the wall of names. The gate only opens on Sept. 11 to allow family members to visit the crash site, according to the National Park Service.
Mr. Trump commented about how nice the golf carts were. They’re used by the National Park Service to traverse the memorial site and on Wednesday to keep the grounds secure.
“One of our other family members reminded him, ‘You’ve got some pretty nice ones too, sir,’” Mr. White said with a laugh.
Post-Gazette photographer Sebastian Foltz contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.