WASHINGTON — When Pennsylvania State police alerted the Secret Service that local authorities had snapped a photo of Thomas Matthew Crooks — who was deemed suspicious but not yet a threat as he milled around outside the security perimeter of the July 13 rally for Donald Trump in Butler — the Secret Service responded by giving troopers a phone number.
The instruction was to send the photo of Crooks to that number, believed to be tied to “some sort of tactical asset” in the Secret Service, Pennsylvania State police Commissioner Col. Christopher Paris testified before the U.S. House Committee on Homeland Security Tuesday.
Less than a half-hour after the text was sent, Crooks — who authorities had lost track of until the last moment — opened fire, injuring Trump and two spectators and killing firefighter Corey Comperatore.
Lawmakers focused on that text multiple times during more than four hours of testimony, frequently expressing disbelief and frustration about potential security lapses and how federal, state and local authorities planned the Butler event and communicated with one another before Trump took the stage.
Democrats and Republicans alike said the shooting marked a massive failure for the lead agency, the Secret Service, whose director, Kimberly Cheatle, resigned during the opening minutes of the hearing.
Asked about the Secret Service’s follow-up to the texted photo of Crooks and whether there was any discussion of stopping Trump from going to the podium, Commissioner Col. Paris said he did not know and made clear that at that point the Bethel Park 20-year-old was not yet considered a threat.
Read More
While not berated by committee members the way Ms. Cheatle was at a House Oversight hearing the day before, lawmakers still peppered Commissioner Col. Paris with questions about state police procedure regarding communications, coordinating with the feds and local law enforcement, and what had gone so wrong to put Trump’s and others’ lives in jeopardy.
“Had we acted quicker, Mr. Comperatore would still be alive today, President Trump and two other people would not have been wounded,” said Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, who is not on the committee but was invited to participate because the shooting took place in his district. “In a greater sense, the American people have been wounded and lost confidence in how we protect people.”
PA State Police Commissioner Col. Christopher Paris testifies that the Butler County Emergency Services Unit was responsible for the security of the AGR building, where the shooter fired from at the July 13 Trump rally. pic.twitter.com/MSQeQGDbF7
— CSPAN (@cspan) July 23, 2024
On Tuesday, Robert Schmitt, 33, a resident of Beaver County, told the Post-Gazette the delayed reaction following alerts from local police at the rally has made him question the integrity of the U.S. Secret Service and, in particular, Ms. Cheatle, the former director of the Secret Service.
“I fully support the police force, and it seems like something that the Secret Service should have been more in charge of,” Mr. Schmitt said. “The fact that we have these people that are appointed that can’t answer questions makes me not trust the government.”
At the hearing, Mr. Kelly told Commissioner Col. Paris, “Every person I talked to there that day says ‘We did our job’ … so somebody else didn't do their job. At the end of the day, we don't have the answers we need.”
The Secret Service requested 32 state police personnel for the event, Commissioner Col. Paris said. The troopers acted in a supporting role, helping the Secret Service with the former president’s motorcade and manning security posts within the security perimeter. State police also provided two marked cars with uniformed troopers outside the perimeter to respond to incidents as they occurred, he said.
State police had drones available, Commissioner Col. Paris said, but did not provide any drone coverage for the rally because, to his knowledge, Secret Service didn’t ask for any. The shooter himself flew a drone near the site before the rally, lawmakers said.
State police also did not provide any dogs for a sweep of the site, although they could have done so if asked by Secret Service. Still, Commissioner Col. Paris said there was nothing particularly unusual or different from previous collaborations with the Secret Service for a presidential or campaign visit.
Commissioner Col. Paris also revealed that Crooks wasn’t the only suspicious person law enforcement had their eyes on in the hour before the shooting. He said there were three other individuals identified as “suspicious” and said authorities were also grappling with trying to help find a missing 6-year-old.
He noted that communications are critical and that “we’re always looking to get better.” If investigations reveal that changes are necessary, the agency would take the required steps, he said.
Commissioner Col. Paris added that the agency is supported through the governor and the state Legislature, and that “we have the resources moving forward to rise to the occasion,” with many lawmakers pressing the issue because Pennsylvania and other battleground states are expecting continued visits from the presidential campaigns.
“I pledge that any and all support we can give to protect Pennsylvanians … we will do,” he said. “We want a robust republic, and we want to secure people’s ability to express their views, and we have worked diligently and we will continue to work diligently to ensure that happens.”
Commissioner Col. Paris said he has instructed his commanders that when it comes to collaborating with Secret Service and others on such events, “we want more people there” and “people voicing issues” from planning and beyond.
The Secret Service has asked the Trump campaign to move its rallies and major campaign events indoors, the Washington Post reported Tuesday evening. Sources told the Post that Secret Service officials shared concerns about outdoor rallies following the Butler shooting.
Tuesday’s hearing came a day after committee members visited the Butler site — many of them standing on the roof where Crooks, likely aided by the fact trees blocked the view of at least one sniper team, fired eight shots.
Some law enforcement officials, including Ms. Cheatle, have said the slope made that roof unsafe for authorities.
“I can’t agree with that statement,” Commissioner Col. Paris testified.
Commissioner Col. Paris told the panel that based on everything he knows 10 days after the shooting, state police “met or exceeded” its responsibilities. He said the agency’s heart goes out to the victims.
Several lawmakers thanked Commissioner Col. Paris for being forthright compared to Ms. Cheatle. Although there were still several questions he had to defer to the Secret Service due to the ongoing investigations.
He told the Post-Gazette after his testimony that he could not speak to the timeline for state police’s two active investigations — one in concert with Secret Service on the homicide and attempted homicide during the rally, and the other an officer-involved shooting inquiry regarding the counter-sniper who shot and killed Crooks.
Lawmakers also focused on whether local personnel — assigned to the buildings near where Crooks had been lurking and eventually climbed to fire into the rally — missed an opportunity to stop him or at least spot him on the roof by leaving their post near a window to try to track him down.
At one point, two Butler Township officers — part of a seven-officer contingent assigned to traffic duty — peeled off their assignments and went to investigate reports from spectators that someone was on a roof nearby.
One helped boost the other up so he could grab the edge of the roof and pull himself up.
He was met with the barrel of Crooks’ rifle pointing at him, township Commissioner Edward R. Natali said. The officer dropped from the roof to avoid being shot, injuring himself in the process.
Commissioner Col. Paris said that encounter occurred mere moments before Crooks started firing toward the rally. It remains under investigation whether the officers were able to quickly make contact with Secret Service.
Rep. Glenn Ivey, D-Md., said even though he’s a former prosecutor and not a member of law enforcement, it was obvious that there were several rooftops and other issues with the site that made it dangerous. Other lawmakers questioned why no agents were stationed on a water tower at the site with 360-degree views.
“I counted about 12 rooftops,” Mr. Ivey said, recounting his visit to Butler Monday. “My thought was why would we pick a spot with that many rooftops available. It’s a bad site.”
He said he spoke with several people who decorated the site with bunting, and “none of those people were vetted. They were up at the stage and could have done anything.” Many, he said, had “not been interviewed by the FBI, Secret Service or local police.”
Rep. Lou Correa, D-Calif., said it remains unclear “who is in charge” when there’s a planning or security dispute between political campaigns and the Secret Service, especially with so many campaign events ahead of Election Day.
“I want to know who’s in charge of protecting our national candidates,” he said. “This is not a Democrat or Republican issue. ... From July 13 to today, we’ve all learned lessons. I want to know how we can help clarify these lines of command.”
Patrick Yoes, national president of the Fraternal Order of Police, said the event marked a critical security failure. He said that Ms. Cheatle’s comments early after the shooting seemed to pin responsibility on local authorities, which could have a damaging effect.
“It’s impossible for federal agencies to do their function without including local law enforcement,” he said. “That relationship is built on trust. When those comments were made … we felt the need to call her out.”
There are a series of investigations into the shooting, including one called by President Joe Biden. Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, who sits on the Senate Judiciary Committee, has sent letters to Beaver and Butler counties and state police requesting all videos and documents tied to the event.
On Wednesday, FBI Director Christopher Wray is set to testify before the House Judiciary Committee.
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail
Reporter Leonardo Frepoli contributed reporting.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.