The reaction of Pittsburgh-area voters to the news that President Joe Biden had dropped out of the presidential race was mixed, with some younger Democrats expressing excitement and some older ones much more skeptical.
The idea of Vice President Kamala Harris leading the ticket in November didn’t thrill many.
“My first reaction was, ‘Oh, there’s hope again,’ ” said Arianne Alfonso, 20, a Pitt student and registered Democrat from Collegeville, Montgomery County. “We asked for it not to be Joe Biden; we’re getting what we asked,” she said. “The only way [to win] is to unite behind one person, which hasn’t been what the Democrats have been doing.”
“No one wanted a rematch of 2020, everyone was kind of done with it,” said Dan Moore, 31, a registered Democrat from Bloomfield who said he was “pretty excited.”
Amelia Aceves, a 21-year-old Pitt student from Murrysville and a registered Democrat, learned the news when a friend texted a “big group chat we have, and we were all really excited,” she said. “We’ve all been hoping he would drop out.”
Ms. Aceves said Mr. Biden’s age and mental acuity were her primary concerns, citing his “embarrassing performance” during June’s debate.
Read More
Mr. Moore said, “I love Joe Biden, I think he did a great job, but I think the debate kind of proved that he’s not who he was in 2020, and unfortunately, it’s time to put someone younger in there, and I really don’t like Donald Trump, so I’m very much hoping we can get someone who can beat him.”
Both Ms. Alfonso and Ms. Aceves worry about a Trump re-election.
“Whenever I drive through Pennsylvania I see Trump signs,” Ms. Aceves said. “I think Trump is going to win Pennsylvania and the country.”
Madeline Fall, 28, a registered Democrat from Bloomfield, said “I’m actually kind of pissed about it,” as she ate a pickle cheesesteak on the sidewalk at Picklesburgh and contemplated the state of the Democratic Party.
“Everybody wants to be ideologically puritanical. Everyone is ‘the most woke,’ the most everything at all times,” she said. “Sometimes, we kind of sacrifice practicality for that. This was an old white man, and yes he was old, and yes he had a stutter, but are we really going to get anybody else by running Kamala? Now I love Kamala, don’t get me wrong, but are we really going to get anybody in the middle that we would have gotten before with a Black woman? I don’t really think so.”
“I love being a Black woman, but I’m just kind of afraid,” Ms. Fall said. “When I was walking around today, I saw a man with a MAGA hat on, and he was so proud to be wearing it. All I could think about was the fact that Hitler got duly elected in 1933 in Germany. He didn’t kidnap the country, he was duly elected, and then he went on to do everything he did. I live in fear that we have made a wrong move here, because the stakes are really high.”
“There are a lot of angry, disgruntled white men who hated Barack Obama and are not going to feel any better about Kamala Harris,” she said. “We’ll see, but if I have to go over the Canadian border, I’ll do it.”
Lynval Baker, a 53-year-old from Jamaica who lives in Pittsburgh, said “I don’t think [Mr. Biden] could manage the next four years.”
Mr. Baker said he’s a registered Democrat who voted for Mr. Biden last election, but had planned to vote for Trump this time. Now he’s unsure what he’ll do, or whether he’ll vote at all.
“If I decide to vote, it all depends who’s going to run against Trump,” he said. “I’m not sure Kamala is ready. We need someone strong.”
Enthusiasm for Ms. Harris was muted generally.
Mr. Moore said he thought Ms. Harris was “the natural successor.”
“Now that we no longer have the two oldest candidates in the history of the United States running, I think there will be plenty of enthusiasm,” he said. “They’ll rally around her. She gets to keep that mantle of continuing the administration with kind of a new, younger, energetic face on it.”
If Ms. Harris takes the top of the ticket, Ms. Aceves said she wouldn’t love it, but it’s better than the alternative. “At least she’s seen how to run things and she’s young,” she said. “But I don’t even know what she stands for.”
That sentiment was echoed by Abdur Rahman Shareef, 67, a registered Democrat from Wilkinsburg, who said “I really don’t want the vice president to be president, to be honest,” he said. “I don’t know if she did anything as the vice president.”
Biden’s withdrawal was welcomed by Nicholas Weller, a 38-year-old registered independent raised in Pittsburgh. He said he’s tired of seeing 70- and 80-year-old people in the Senate, Supreme Court and high office.
“Overall, I’m actually relieved,” he said. “I think it’ll help set a precedent for some of these politicians to step down.”
Zoe Livengood, 30, a Democrat from Shadyside, said “I think we hopefully have a little of a better shot at winning. At least we’re not gonna have two really old people – not to be reductive, cause there’s bigger problems there — but yeah, it was exciting to see that we may have some other choices.”
Mr. Weller does not want a second Trump term, but is weary of Kamala Harris, should she be nominated.
“I don’t think she’s really done anything as a vice president to show she has great leadership qualities,” he said. “There’s nothing that makes me want to vote for her.
“There were enough things about Biden that I liked what he was going to bring to the table,” he said. “Kamala doesn’t have that for me.”
Mr. Weller said he will likely vote third party unless someone he likes steps in. He said he would get behind Hakeem Jeffries if he were nominated, and would “wholeheartedly” vote for Josh Shapiro after witnessing his governorship in Pennsylvania.
Andrew Manski, 19, a Democrat from Westmoreland County, said he plans to vote for the Democratic nominee whoever it is — “unless somehow it’s worse than a felon, which would be really hard.”
None of the above would more accurately characterize 60-year-old Ali Mohamed’s attitude.
Mr. Mohamed, a registered Democrat from Upper Saint Clair, said he had already written Mr. Biden off “quite a while ago, with the Gaza war and the way he handled that. I not only wrote him off, I wrote the whole party off.”
Mr. Mohamed said the ongoing war in Gaza has changed him, as well as friends and family, into “single issue” voters. He’s been a long-time Democratic voter since 1996, but thinks the U.S. action in the Middle East will lose voters, specifically students.
Mr. Mohamed said Democrats need to “learn the hard way” this November.
“After that, we’ll come back,” he said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.