WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden’s historic decision to abandon his campaign for re-election upended an already chaotic race and thrust Pennsylvania into the center of a momentous series of decisions that will play out in the coming days and weeks.

As Democratic leaders race to rebuild their ticket with just 3½ months before election day, they will do so with Pennsylvania, the largest swing state, at the front of their minds. At the same time, the massive campaign infrastructure they’ve built to drive voters to donate to — and ultimately vote for — Mr. Biden will have to retool to serve a new candidate, with a new message that still appeals to millions in this closely divided state.

“Geography is always a driving consideration, and in this case, Pennsylvania is sitting right at the epicenter of the pathway to victory,” said Ken Gormley, president of Duquesne University and a presidential historian.

That puts Pennsylvania’s popular governor, Josh Shapiro, on the short list of potential candidates to fill out the two-person ticket. Mr. Biden endorsed Vice President Kamala Harris to succeed him as the party’s nominee, a decision that ultimately falls to the nearly 4,700 delegates who will gather at the Democratic National Convention next month in Chicago.

Advertise with us

Those delegates will gather during one of the most chaotic and unpredictable presidential elections in history — one that was rocked just a week ago by the attempted assassination of Donald Trump in a deeply Republican area of this crucial swing state.

“We’re still trying to digest the last unprecedented thing that happened, and now we’ve got to figure out this unprecedented thing,” said Kristin Kanthak, political science professor at the University of Pittsburgh.

As Ms. Harris scrambles to shore up support among the party’s elite and close the door on any potential challengers in the coming days, her selection of a running mate will be perhaps her most consequential decision — and one she’ll need to make soon, Ms. Kanthak said.

“By the end of this week, she needs to go from being a sitting vice president to being at the top of the ticket, and having chosen someone that is going to be second on the ticket,” Ms. Kanthak said.

Reset in a swing state

Mr. Biden’s weakness in Pennsylvania — as well as the two other “Blue Wall” states of Michigan and Wisconsin — in polls after his disastrous debate was a key argument made by the growing number of Democrats urging him to drop out. 

Advertise with us

“The reason there was so much pressure put on Biden was because it looked like he could not defend Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan,” Democratic consultant Modia Butler said. “The very idea of this [decision] is to put those states back in play, which puts the presidential race back in play.”

While polls of Pennsylvania voters continued to show the gap between Mr. Biden and Trump within the margin of error, the president hadn’t led since a Franklin & Marshall survey in March. The latest Real Clear Politics average put Trump ahead by 4.5 percentage points.

One survey last week by a Democratic-leaning pollster showed both Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris losing to Trump in Pennsylvania — but found that a Harris-Shapiro ticket moved into a one-point lead.

While the president, who hails from Scranton and spent most of his life in neighboring Delaware, was a frequent visitor to Pennsylvania, Mr. Biden’s high unfavorability ratings were weighing him down, said Berwood Yost, who runs the F&M Poll.

“Pennsylvania was looking more and more as a lost cause,” Mr. Yost said. “Whenever an incumbent is running, it’s first about the incumbent. Then people might make a decision based on the alternative. Pennsylvania is a state certainly winnable for Democrats but at the same time it was slipping away from Biden.”

Advertise with us

In a post-debate New York Times/Siena College/Philadelphia Inquirer poll released shortly before the Republican National Convention, 61% of likely voters disapproved of Mr. Biden’s performance in office. Just 38% approved.

A similar poll by the same group in May found Mr. Shapiro’s job approval at 57%.

“Certainly, Pennsylvania is one of those battleground states where you have large swaths of swing voters that will determine the election who have not been pleased with Biden’s performance,” said Rutgers University pollster Ashley Koning.

A proven ability to appeal to those voters was a factor in Trump’s choice of Ohio U.S. Sen. JD Vance as his running mate last week, and is a key reason why Michigan Gov. Gretchen Witmer, Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker and Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear are also in the conversation as potential running mates.

For Mr. Shapiro, there’s already a connection to the Harris household. Second Gentleman Doug Emhoff, who shares the governor’s Jewish faith, has closely followed the aftermath of the 2018 synagogue shooting, Mr. Gormley said. Mr. Emhoff was at the groundbreaking ceremony for the temple’s rebuilding in June — as was Mr. Gormley.

Advertise with us

“He had been carefully paying attention to everything going on after the Tree of Life shootings, and had been to Pittsburgh numerous times, and built relationships not just with the three synagogues involved, but the whole Jewish community and the broader Pittsburgh community,” Mr. Gormley said of Mr. Emhoff. “So there’s a clear link there with him and Pittsburgh. There’s a lot of connective tissue.”

While the internal debate rages over who should be atop the ticket, thousands of paid staffers and volunteers across the state have suddenly found themselves in a campaign with no candidate. Everything from door-knocking to phone-banking to advertising has suddenly been thrown into flux in one of the largest statewide political operations in the country.

“We were out today going to brunch, and there are all these Biden Harris signs,” Ms. Kanthak said. “Those signs are all obsolete.”

‘Healthy chaos’

For a political scientist who leans on data to put the political moment into context, Ms. Kanthak found herself adrift on Sunday afternoon. The convention where delegates will have the final say about the Democratic ticket is, for the first time in generations, going to be an actual choice by the attendees, rather than a coronation of the candidate who won the most primary votes, now that that candidate has dropped out.

“I don’t have much to grab on to,” she said. “This is going to be a thing that I’ve never seen in my lifetime, which is a convention where delegates are making decisions — real decisions — in real time.”

Advertise with us

They’ll have at least one advantage, though: Unlike Republicans right now, Democrats know who they’ll be running against.

“The GOP and Trump, they’ve shown all their cards. It’s Trump, and it’s JD Vance,” said Larry Ceisler, a public affairs executive based in Philadelphia. “The Democrats, at least from a strategic standpoint, haven’t had to show their cards yet. And they’re basically looking at what Trump’s hand is.”

Still, the potential for chaos within the Democratic ranks if another candidate mounts an organized challenge is real, analysts said.

“This close to the convention, to have this happen — it’s historic, and nobody knows how it’s going to play out,” said Paul Sracic, a political analyst at Youngstown State University.

That’s not necessarily a bad thing, Mr. Gormley said. For much of the first half of the country’s history, that’s how the parties picked their nominees

Advertise with us

“It’s a very American thing, quite honestly,” he said.

And it comes at a time when the vitality of U.S. democracy is a serious concern. Through polls, focus groups and even election results, voters this year had made it abundantly clear that they wanted a different choice than the one they slogged through last time, and were unhappy to be stuck with two candidates whose most noticeable change was that they’d grown older.

In Pennsylvania’s primary, nearly 160,000 Republicans voted for Nikki Haley over Trump, even though she’d dropped out of the race weeks before. In Allegheny County alone, more than 13,000 Democrats wrote in a name rather than vote for Mr. Biden.

“In some ways, it’s a healthy chaos,” Mr. Gormley said. “You’re seeing the will of the people be hashed out in real time in front of us, and that’s not a bad thing.”

“I think some of the events of the past, not just weeks, but years, have really made people rethink that we don’t have to settle for a path that we don’t like — that it is possible to re scramble the deck and try to push us toward what we believe is a good place for our country,” he said.

Advertise with us

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant 

Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com; @Wrschgn