WASHINGTON — The debate was a chance for the Democratic candidate to assuage concerns that mentally, he was up to the job, an issue that dogged his campaign.
It didn’t work. He had difficulty expressing himself, speaking haltingly and mispronouncing words. At the end of the night, members of his own party wondered what they had wrought.
The debate in question occurred in 2022, when then-Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, recovering from a stroke, faced off against Republican challenger Mehmet Oz, the celebrity doctor, for a U.S. Senate seat. Democrats wrung their hands at Mr. Fetterman’s performance.
President Joe Biden’s dismal debate performance Thursday night against former President Donald Trump kindled similar worries.
“Many of the same concerns that you’re hearing about Biden were expressed by partisans [about Fetterman],” said Berwood Yost, director of the Franklin & Marshall College Poll. “They thought the race was over. They thought he had really created a problem for himself by trying to debate. All the same sorts of things that were being said about Biden were being said in ‘22 about Fetterman.”
Two weeks after the debate, Mr. Fetterman was elected with votes to spare, becoming the only candidate of either party to flip a Senate seat.
Read More
And on Friday Mr. Fetterman drew on that experience as he rushed to Mr. Biden’s defense, even as other Democrats — even the New York Times editorial board — openly questioned whether the president should continue running for a second term.
But the comparison may be off, experts said.
A senator is one of 100 lawmakers in one of two houses of Congress. A president is the singular leader of the most powerful nation on earth.
“The idea of trying to ameliorate the situation, holding out John Fetterman as an example, is not going to sway people, given the office,” Democratic political consultant Glenn Totten said. “The reality is we’re talking about a position that is still theoretically the most influential person in the world. The idea that Mr. Fetterman would be the poster child for rehabilitating Biden would be very wide of the mark.”
In addition, while Mr. Fetterman’s health was expected to improve, there’s no way to reverse the aging process, Mr. Yost said.
Mr. Fetterman’s “condition [was] caused by a stroke, and voters may have viewed it as temporary on the way to recovery,” he said. “The question about aging is different. You don’t recover. You age. It moves in one direction.”
Former U.S. Rep. Paul McHale, a Democrat who used to represent the Lehigh Valley in Congress, said, “In the case of President Biden, it is unfortunately debilitating and enduring.”
Mr. McHale said Mr. Biden should end his re-election campaign.
“It was manifestly clear that a very good man has outlived his capacity for the presidency,” Mr. McHale said. “His administration has protected us from what could have been four more years of Donald Trump. Now that we face that risk again, it is President Biden’s duty to withdraw from the race... and the Democratic Party should nominate somebody who has similar views but whose capacity is unchallenged.”
That may be easier said than done.
The Democratic Convention in Chicago is only seven weeks away. Three oft-mentioned potential successors to Mr. Biden — California Gov. Gavin Newsom, Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro — issued post-debate statements supporting the president. Under party rules, the only real way to replace Mr. Biden as the nominee is for him to voluntarily withdraw and release his convention delegates.
And there’s little indication he’s willing.
At a campaign rally in North Carolina Friday, Mr. Biden acknowledged his age and forcefully made a case for going forward.
“I know I’m not a young man,” he said, with an energy missing from Thursday night’s performance. “I don’t walk as easy as I used to. I don’t speak as smoothly as I used to. I don’t debate as well as I used to. But I know what I do know: I know how to tell the truth. I know right from wrong. I know how to do this job. I know how to get things done. And I know like millions of Americans know — when you get knocked down, you get back up.”
Mr. Biden spent Saturday courting wealthy donors in the Hamptons on Long Island and in New Jersey. The Associated Press reported that Democratic donors across New York, Southern California and Silicon Valley privately expressed deep concerns about the viability of Mr. Biden’s campaign. Some donors said they were going to pause their contributions; they also said the weekend’s fundraisers’ receipts still would be strong because tickets were sold before the debate.
The campaign on Saturday cited post-debate flash polls that showed little change in support for Mr. Biden, even as majorities in the unscientific surveys disapproved of his performance. Regular post-debate polls have yet to be completed and released.
“The debate did not change the horse race,” campaign chair Jen O’Malley Dillon said in a memo. “This mirrors what the campaign’s internal post-debate polling showed: The president maintained his support among his 2020 voters and voters' opinions were not changed.”
But even as Mr. Biden and Mr. Trump coasted to their nominations, multiple polls have shown that most Americans would rather have different candidates.
The race is essentially a dead heat — especially in battleground states like Pennsylvania, where the election could be decided — so even a relatively small fluctuation in the polls could be significant.
In many regards, Trump didn’t do himself any favors either. Convicted on 34 felony counts last month, he was tagged by fact checkers with more than two dozen falsehoods, refused to definitively say he would accept the results of the 2024 election, and renewed his baseless claims that the last election was “stolen” from him.
"We don't know the impact on the electorate yet,” said Lew Irwin, a political science professor at Duquesne University. “As much as we're focused on this painful-to-watch performance, I don't think former President Trump did himself any favors either. Swing voters, especially suburban women and the so-called double-haters, even as they're watching and dismayed by what they were seeing with President Biden, they were all being reminded about what they don't like about Trump."
Accordingly, Trump may not have been able to take advantage of Mr. Biden’s performance to win over the undecided voters he needs, Mr. Yost said.
“The candidates reinforced the images people already had,” Mr. Yost said. “That is the ultimate upshot here. We’ll see in the next few weeks as the polling comes out, but some of the preliminary indicators were that these voters who are going to decide the election didn't get what they needed from either candidate.”
In the meantime, Republicans are making as much as they can of Mr. Biden’s very bad night.
“Our party needs Joe Biden on the ballot in November, ” Allegheny County Republican Chairman Sam DeMarco said. “No other candidate can deliver the number of Trump votes that Joe Biden is capable of doing. As viewers watched the president’s life flash before their eyes, I’m sure they were thinking the same thing I was: In which direction will he tip over?”
Former Republican Gov. Tom Corbett left all jokes aside, saying he’s known Mr. Biden was struggling for a while now simply by watching his speeches.
“Have you ever used a teleprompter?” Mr. Corbett asked. “It’s a skill.” He said you have to know the speech, rely on the teleprompter to keep you on track and still make eye contact with the audience. Mr. Biden often is squinting, “which means he’s reading the speech — and having difficulty seeing it,” he said.
What you saw Thursday night, he said, was Mr. Biden without the teleprompter.
“I’m 75,” Mr. Corbett said. “I know. It’s time.”
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant The Associated Press contributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.