GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. — Former President Donald Trump’s first post-convention rally looked a lot different than the one in Butler just before he was nominated for another term.
Security was tightened and new procedures were put in place following the attempted assassination at last Saturday’s open-air rally at the Butler Farm Show site two days before the Republican National Convention began in Milwaukee.
Unlike the Butler rally, Saturday’s event took place indoors in a 12,000-seat arena here.
Unlike Butler, there was no way for anyone to take aim at Trump from a building outside the secured area.
And unlike Butler, the Secret Service was under extra scrutiny for not adequately protecting the former president a week ago.
“The Secret Service is on notice that the failures are unacceptable,” said U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre. “I suspect future events will be conducted in a way with the highest level of security in an effort to protect President Trump. The failures that happened — to me — are so striking that they’ll be corrections put in place.”
Read More
Outside the arena, the streets were full of police officers standing on corners, sitting horseback and riding bicycles. Attendees lined up to be screened and have their bags hand-searched by Secret Service agents in gray and Transportation Safety Administration personnel in blue uniforms. Grand Rapids Police officers in blue with shoulder patches joined standard arena security guards along the concourses and inside the arena.
Dark-suited Secret Service agents lined both sides of the aisle as Trump walked to the riser in the center of the lower bowl, and then surrounded the stage as he spoke.
“What did I do for democracy? Last week I took a bullet for democracy,” he told a sea of red hats and blue and white signs.
Michigan Republican Party chair Pete Hoekstra, a former congressman, said the shortcomings uncovered after the Butler rally meant they were corrected before this one.
“Obviously something went massively wrong,” he said. “Obviously they’re going to be extra focused on this. When you go to an indoor venue, the risk decreases exponentially.”
Grand Rapids Police Sgt. Tom Warwick said that local law enforcement agencies didn’t change their procedures as a result of the Butler shooting.
“We would have had as big a footprint no matter what happened last week” Mr. Warwick said. “Our preparation is the same and would have been the same regardless.”
Streets were blocked around the arena. Police patrolled on horseback and bicycles. Grand Rapids police were stationed in the seating bowl. Area departments helped re-enforce security.
“We’re doing everything,” Mr. Warwick said. “The goal is to make sure everybody’s safe. We try to go above and beyond.”
Butler, though, remained on everyone’s minds.
Trump began his speech by reminding the packed arena that the “horrific event” was just one week ago, almost to the hour. He thanked the Butler hospital medical staff and the community for “the love that they showed us all.”
“Something very special happened,” he said. “What a time. Nobody’s ever seen anything like it.”
Trump’s vice-presidential pick, Ohio U.S. Sen. JD Vance, also referred to the week-old incident.
“I find it hard to believe that a week ago, an assassin tried to take Donald Trump’s life and now we’ve got a hell of a crowd in Michigan to welcome him back on the campaign trail,” Mr. Vance said.
And U.S. Rep. Tim Wahlberg’s invocation included a prayer for Corey Comperatore, who was killed in Butler, and for the two others who were seriously injured, as well as crediting a higher power for saving Trump’s life that day.
“If you don’t believe that God intervenes in the affairs of man, I hope you will reconsider,” said Mr. Wahlberg, R-Mich.
Mr. Trump also praised Mr. Comperatore, and the two others seriously injured in the shooting.
‘Corey was a hero and we will carry his memory in our hearts,” he said. “He was a big Trumper and we will never forget him.”
People began arriving for the rally on Friday, and the line for those waiting to get in stretched for at least two miles by early afternoon Saturday. They filled the lower sections of the arena and then the upper galleries.
“He’s the only one who’s fighting for the people,” said Michkaya Gauci, a small farmer who came to the rally with landscaping owner Chris Popoiecha from White Lake, Michigan. The two were dressed in matching red and white shirts with the location and date of the rally, like a T-shirt you’d buy at a rock concert.
Because the rally was held inside the Van Andel Arena – named for the family that co-founded Amway — and not outdoors as in Butler, securing the venue is "a lot easier," said Jason Russell, a former Secret Service agent who served during the 2004 and 2008 presidential elections, including time in Michigan, and is the founder and president of Grand Rapids-based Secure Environment Consultants.
"You'll see an additional amount of presence just because of what happened last Saturday,” Mr. Russell said. “Because it's the first one since the assassination attempt, that place would be locked down tight. There'll be no issues."
Before the rally, President Joe Biden’s campaign spokesman, Michael Tyler, said the race remained too close to call, and that the Biden campaign would win the election with a massive get-out-the-vote effort, “Trump has a fraction of our operation,” he said on a Zoom call with reporters.
He said Mr. Biden would return to the campaign trail within days once he recovers from COVID.
Mr. Tyler and U.S. Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., said abortion, making it easier for workers to organize, and prescription drug prices were among the issues favoring Democrats.
“This election is going to be about American families, their freedom, their democracy,” Mr. Tyler said. “The stakes are high. The choice is very, very clear.”
Ms. Stabenow said she has organized trips across the border into Canada for her constituents to get cheaper prescription drugs, while Trump supports repealing the $35 cap on insulin costs and price negotiations for prescription drugs that were passed under Mr. Biden over unanimous Republican opposition.
Asked about the growing number of Democrats who have urged Mr. Biden to withdraw from the race, including some in the U.S. Senate, Ms. Stabenow said they had to make their own decisions.
As for her, “we’ve not seen a president who’s been able to deliver more for Michigan than President Biden,” she said.
The other Trump campaign rallies scheduled this month — like this one — will be indoors: with vice-presidential nominee JD Vance in Middletown, Ohio, and Radford, Virginia, on Monday and one with Trump in Charlotte, North Carolina, on Wednesday.
Mr. Russell said indoor arenas rather than outdoor spaces give the Secret Service a limited space to secure and protect; Trump's motorcade can pull into a garage, so he doesn't have to get out of the vehicle until he's deep within the building, and there are no areas outside of the security bubble where someone can even see the former president, he said.
"Everything can be swept," Mr. Russell said. "There are no outer-perimeter concerns because he's going to be inside. So there's none of the typical concerns like you'd have with an outdoor rally."
Still, delegates to last week’s Republican National Convention remained concerned.
“I am worried,” said Mike McMullen of Hampton, a Pennsylvania delegate in Milwaukee who said he was about 20 feet from the podium at the Butler rally. “What happened in Butler changed the narrative. I think going forward, they’re going to look at a lot of things. I am genuinely concerned. What happened if this person was ex-military or trained? God only knows what could happen.”
Some of the rally attendees said they feared another attempt on Trump’s life.
“They haven’t given up on taking him out yet,” said Bill Fegel, a retired insurance salesman from Northern Shores. Michigan, standing next to his brother David, an inventor and Navy veteran. Both were outfitted in red and white Make America Great Again baseball caps to hawk buttons and coffee mugs emblazoned with a red, white and blue totem pole reading “Trump” that David erected in his front yard.
David Fegel, also from Northern Shores, said it wasn’t surprising that Trump was attacked in deep red Butler.
“The places where they’re going to try are the places you don’t expect they will try something,” he said.
Timothy Walenga, a former GOP chair of Kent County, which includes Grand Rapids, said he wasn’t concerned after seeing the security put in place at the Republican National Convention.
“I think it’s a different scenario,” said the Grand Rapids resident. “It’s an indoor venue and I think there’s certainly a very heightened awareness. With the Secret Service director under fire right now, I think security will be outstanding.”
And Kelly Smith of Ionia, Michigan, attending Saturday’s rally with husband Leon and their 19-year-old son Justin, said she felt safe. “They’ve tightened up enough,” she said.
Kent County voters backed Trump in 2016 when Republicans carried the state for the first time since 1988, but they supported Joe Biden four years later when Democrats won it back.
“It means we’re getting a lot of attention,” said Chuck Yob of Aida, a former Kent County GOP chair and former national Republican committeeman. “Everybody wants attention from the president. It gives them all these people and gets all these people close to him.”
The selection of Grand Rapids for the first post-convention rally illustrates how Michigan, along with Pennsylvania and GOP convention site Wisconsin, will be the major battlegrounds this fall.
“He was going to Michigan or Pennsylvania,” Mr. Hoekstra said. “You win one of these two states and he’s probably president of the United States. You probably need a shuttle flight connecting Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Detroit and Grand Rapids.”
Mike Wereschagin contributed to this report.
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.