Seven Washington County residents — with the help of the ACLU of Pennsylvania, Washington County’s NAACP branch, Center for Coalfield Justice and other organizations — sued the county’s board of elections on Monday, arguing that they and more than 250 other voters were disenfranchised because they weren’t allowed to correct mistakes on their mail-in ballots in the primary election.

The ACLU and Public Interest Law Center had initially sent a letter to Washington County Solicitor Gary Sweat in April, notifying the county of issues created by the decision of the county’s board of elections to not allow voters to fix mistakes on their mail-in ballots and envelopes, a process known as “curing” a ballot.

According to the lawsuit, the board’s decision to not notify voters of those mistakes constitutes a violation of the state Constitution because it does not allow due process for Washington County voters. That included notifying whether they had forgotten to sign their ballots or had omitted or put in an incorrect date, the suit stated.

“Instead, in the weeks leading up to the April 2024 election, the Board determined which mail-in ballots would not be counted, and then implemented a systematic process to keep that information from voters and the public, in many cases affirmatively misleading voters into thinking that their mail-in ballots would be counted. ... Due process is not a choice: the Pennsylvania Constitution demands it,” according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

The seven residents named as plaintiffs in the lawsuit are: Bruce Jacobs, 65, of Venetia; Jeffrey Marks, 72, of Washington; June DeVaughn Hython, 85, of Canonsburg; Erika Worobec, 45, of Cecil; Sandra Macioce, 64, of Canonsburg; Kenneth Elliott, 48, of Amity; and David Dean, 54, of Canonsburg.

In all, the suit alleges that because of the county board’s decision, 259 voters were disenfranchised from the April primary election.

Those who helped file the lawsuit said the county’s actions would also create confusion among voters in the months leading into the November general election. Mimi McKenzie, legal director at the Public Interest Law Center, said it’s crucial that the board rectify its past decision.

“The right to vote is fundamental to a well-functioning democracy and the right from which all others flow,” she wrote in a prepared statement. “The Washington board’s refusal to tell voters they made a mistake, and, in fact, to affirmatively mislead voters, is an assault on democracy.”

The county’s board of elections, consisting of the county’s three commissioners, voted 2-1 during a meeting in April to not allow voters to “cure” their mail-in ballots during the primary, according to the Observer–Reporter. Republicans Nick Sherman and Electra Janis said they were following a ruling of the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that said misdated ballots should not be counted in Pennsylvania. Democrat Larry Maggi voted against the measure.

Advertise with us

Neither Republican commissioner could be reached for comment by phone Monday. Mr. Maggi told the Post-Gazette he wasn’t surprised by the lawsuit and hoped the issue could be litigated quickly, before mail-in ballots are sent out to Washington County voters.

He said that he disagreed with his colleagues that the federal court ruling meant that Washington County was not able to cure mail-in ballots. The county’s solicitor had told him and the other two commissioners that the ruling didn’t weigh in on whether Pennsylvania counties should or shouldn’t cure mail-in ballots, he said.

Many neighboring counties, including Allegheny, allow the “curing” process, he added. Voters should be allowed to correct their ballot if they forgot to sign a date or signature on the security envelope, he said.

“My position is those people have the right to correct that mistake, and if they don’t come in to correct it, then they forfeit that right,” Mr. Maggi said.

Mail-in balloting has been a hot-button issue in recent elections. Many Democrats have said it’s needed to increase access to the ballot box. Some Republicans, however, say that more measures are needed to ensure accurate and secure counts during elections. Until recently, that included former President Donald Trump, who has claimed that the system is full of fraud, despite losing dozens of court challenges alleging such fraud in the aftermath of the 2020 election. Trump recently began to support voting by mail.

Advertise with us

The seven Washington County voters, ACLU, NAACP, and other partners on the suit are asking that the courts find the county’s board of elections’ policy in violation of the state’s constitution, according to the lawsuit. It asks that county officials rescind their current policy in order to notify voters to correct their mail-in ballots in time for Election Day, or that they can at least cast a provisional ballot.

“It should not be this easy for elected officials to strip 259 people of their votes, their voices in our political system,” said Sarah Martik, executive director at Center for Coalfield Justice, in a prepared statement.