For Anthony Angiulli of Murrysville, former President Donald Trump’s conviction on all 34 felony charges by a Manhattan jury in his hush money trial can only help his chances of re-election this November.
So say other area Republicans, who say the convictions won’t affect their support for the former president and presumptive 2024 Republican presidential nominee.
In fact, political consultants and GOP voters said that the trial served as a reminder that Trump enjoys the limelight as much as any other politician.
“To me, it’s less a criminal trial as it is a political circus,” Mr. Angiulli said before the verdict was read Thursday. “And it’s a shame we have to play it out this way in America. … I’m afraid the facts and information were embellished to whatever side of the coin it has flipped to.”
But in a race as tight as the one between Trump and President Joe Biden, with polls nationally and in Pennsylvania showing a tossup, even a slight shift among voters could be significant.
Even as 67% of voters in an NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist Poll released earlier Thursday said a guilty verdict would not affect their vote, 17% said they would be less likely vote for a convicted Trump and about 15% of said they would be more likely to vote for him.
Read More
“It doesn't have to affect that many to make a difference,” said Republican consultant Mike DuHaime, who backed former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie in the 2024 GOP presidential primaries. “Even 5% changing their minds could be a big deal. They’re really playing on the margins here. It doesn't take a large percentage of [Trump’s] voters to tip the balance in a close state.”
In fact, don’t expect any major shift of voters, said J.J. Balaban, a Philadelphia-based political consultant.
But in a state like Pennsylvania, where Mr. Biden beat Trump by just over 1 percentage point and roughly 80,000 votes in 2020, fine margins are important.
“It won’t do everything, but it doesn’t mean it won’t do anything,” Mr. Balaban said. “In a game of inches, it may end up making a difference. But if people were expecting a guilty verdict leading to a 5% shift in the polls, they're likely to be disappointed.”
Local GOP voters weigh in
Trump was accused of paying $130,000 to kill a story before the 2016 election that accused him of having an affair with porn star Stormy Daniels. Prosecutors alleged that Trump falsified checks and other business records in order to conceal that payment to his personal attorney, Michael Cohen — a key witness during the trial.
In all, Trump faced 34 charges. On Thursday, a jury found him guilty of all of them. He faces a fine, probation or prison time. That will be up to Judge Juan Merchan, who set Trump’s sentencing for July 11, just four days before Republicans will assemble in Milwaukee to nominate the former president for another term in the White House.
Trump, the first former president to be convicted of a crime, can appeal the verdict.
Mr. Angiulli has known about Trump’s business record for years. His brother was involved in construction on the Trump Taj Mahal casino in Atlantic City, he said, helping install marble and stone as part of the final building.
Trump refused to pay Avalon Commercial, the company supplying the marble, at a cost of almost $4 million, the Associated Press reported in 2016. It forced the company to close, Mr. Angiulli said.
But Trump’s business tactics are nothing new, the 70-year-old accountant said. And the charges against him, in the first of four criminal trials the former president faces, are a microcosm of how imperfect the justice system is, he said.
Other Pittsburgh-area Republicans said they agree with Mr. Angiulli. And even those who don’t agree with him acknowledge that the trial played into Trump’s image as a showman of a politician, one that plays to his base and will help drive up Republican turnout in November — and even increase his chances of winning.
“It's a rallying cry for his base,” said Vince Galko, a Republican strategist from northeastern Pennsylvania. “He has usually done a masterful job of spinning it every day as a ‘crooked’ judge and ‘trumped-up’ charges.”
Beth Painter, a retired Republican from Economy, said she won’t vote for Trump, but it has little to do with the trial.
Ms. Painter, 67, said she has been a lifelong Republican and voted for the former president in 2016 and 2020. But after the insurrection at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, that was the breaking point, she said.
Despite Trump’s troubles in court, she said she currently won’t cross the aisle to vote for Mr. Biden in November. Economic conditions have been tough in recent years, and retirement has been trickier for her and her husband than they originally thought, she said.
“I just feel that at this point in time, if these are our two choices, we’re in trouble,” Ms. Painter said Wednesday. “It’s not that I dislike Joe Biden, I just think he’s past his prime.”
Trial could energize Trump’s base for November
Multiple Republicans throughout the Pittsburgh region say the guilty verdict for the former president matters little because the trial itself was unfair and politicized from the start.
Rina Bellotti, 59, of Hempfield Township, said a guilty verdict improves Trump’s chances of winning. Ms. Bellotti said she grew up as a Democrat but switched to Republican about 20 to 25 years ago when she started to disagree with Democratic policy positions, including on the economy.
Ms. Bellotti, who works as an administrator for UPMC, said the charges brought against Trump have not been as clear-cut as some media coverage has portrayed. And the timing of the trial, during a presidential election year where Trump faces other felony charges in multiple other cases, seemed suspicious, she said.
“I truly believe if there was some wrongdoing, it should have been addressed and taken care of within a certain time frame … not at this time, and not during election season,” Ms. Bellotti said.
Mr. DuHaime, the consultant who backed Gov. Christie, said the trial didn’t have the same resonance as, say, one where a politician is accused of taking bribes, thus enriching him or herself.
Discussing the fine points of campaign finance laws, as in this case, is a lot less sexy than hearing about pockets of cash and gold bars, as in the trial of U.S. Sen. Robert Menendez, D-N.J., he said.
Some local Republicans cast doubt on Mr. Cohen, Trump’s former personal lawyer. Many political observers say Mr. Cohen was the key witness because of his close connections to the former president and his business practices.
Mark, 70, a retired accountant and Republican who resides in Zelienople and refused to give his last name, said that the $130,000 payment to Mr. Cohen was for legal fees, not to kill an unfavorable story.
While shopping in Cranberry Township on Wednesday, he said it’s evident that no matter what the verdict was going to be, the former president’s chances of re-election have already been bolstered.
Joe Richards, 32, of Cranberry, agreed. Mr. Richards, who works in maintenance at some local gas stations, said he holds libertarian views and is not registered with either the Democratic or Republican Party.
The trial publicity helped Trump, he said. And he said it appeared he was unfairly targeted during a presidential election year, especially when comparing the trial to the legal troubles involving Hunter Biden, the president’s son, who has been indicted on tax and gun charges.
The guilty verdict will do nothing to change the views of Mr. Richards or those of many other Republicans or Democrats, said Peter Fenn, a Democratic consultant and veteran of several Democratic campaigns.
What the trial did was motivate Trump’s voter base and helped him raise money for the coming months, Mr. Fenn said. The New York Times reported that Trump and the GOP raised more than Mr. Biden and the Democrats in April, cutting into the incumbent’s sizable fundraising advantage.
“His people don't give a damn,” Mr. Fenn said. “Those people who read it and get all excited, we’re already there. We think the guy is basically dishonest and he's a crook. Nothing’s going to change with this trial.”
The impact on undecided voters, though, could be significant, political observers said. Larry Ceisler, a Democratic, Philadelphia-based public affairs executive — with an office in Pittsburgh — said the impact of the trial on those voters will be difficult to calculate.
On one hand, there are Republican and independent voters who voted for Mr. Biden in 2020, but might not like his record in office, he said. On the other, Republicans and independents who voted for Trump in 2020 but are disturbed by the events of Jan. 6, 2021, might flip to Biden.
But the impact of the verdict will be hard to figure out because no one knows what many in those groups of voters are thinking, he said.
Some Democrats may feel the guilty verdict on felony charges should disqualify a candidate for president, Mr. Ceisler said.
But Republicans don’t, Mr. Balaban said.
"It is far-fetched to believe that any conviction would change the minds of a majority of Republicans,” he said. “As a practical matter, it is hard to posture as the party of law and order if the standard-bearer of your party is a convicted felon. He will still be the Republican nominee, but that doesn't mean there aren't issues. If 5% of Republicans who were voting for Trump found it disqualifying, it is not nearly enough to lose him the nomination but it is enough to lose him the election."
Ultimately, American voters will render the final verdict, Mr. Ceisler said.
“The only judge and jury that are going to disqualify Donald Trump are the American voters on Election Day,” Mr. Ceisler said. “If there’s going to be a punch out to Donald Trump, you want it to be by the voters.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.