It was a hard-fought Democratic primary re-election campaign for U.S. Rep Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, complete with outside funding, attack ads, and verbal barbs back and forth on the debate stage.

In the end, though, Ms. Lee’s victory over Edgewood Council member Bhavini Patel in the 12th Congressional District was very comfortable — she carried many precincts not only in Pittsburgh, but also throughout the suburbs. She won the majority of Democratic votes in western Westmoreland County, typically a conservative base compared to Pittsburgh and the immediate suburbs.

She won by more than 21 points.

Her performance was a sign of the typical advantage that incumbents have in primary elections, political observers said — along with the challenge that opponents can have in fundraising. It also shows the difficulty of candidates trying to differentiate themselves from someone who, despite differences on issues like the Israel-Hamas War, is still quite similar on a lot of policy areas, they said.

Advertise with us

Now, Ms. Lee, 36, looks forward to the general election in November, where she faces Pittsburgh businessman and economist James Hayes, who ran unopposed in the Republican primary.

Mr. Hayes, 62, faces a tall task. According to voter registration data from Pennsylvania, there are more than twice as many registered Democrats than Republicans in the district, a 58% to 27% advantage.

Still, Ms. Lee said during a victory speech on Tuesday that she wasn’t taking the general election for granted. And even though political observers said Mr. Hayes faces an uphill battle to win in November, the right kind of campaign could result in an upset victory.

“I think he faces some long odds — but the beauty of politics is anything can happen if all the pieces fall into place,” said Joseph Sabino Mistick, a law professor at Duquesne University who was also chief of staff to late Pittsburgh mayor Sophie Masloff.

Where Summer Lee won, and the state of progressive politics in the 12th District

When Ms. Lee won her first Democratic primary for Congress back in 2022, she prevailed in a five-way primary where the margin of victory over Steve Irwin, a former state official, was less than 1,000 votes.

Advertise with us

Last Tuesday, her victory was much more sizable — an indication that her progressive base and a large swath Democratic primary voters preferred her over Ms. Patel, a more moderate candidate. She won by more than 21 points and more than 22,000 votes.

Ms. Lee’s victory expanded not only in size, but geographic scope. In 2022, she won much of the city’s precincts and the immediate suburbs. But Mr. Irwin carried much of the outlying suburbs through the Mon Valley and in the easternmost edges of Allegheny County, while carrying nearly every precinct in the Westmoreland County portion of the district.

On Tuesday, Ms. Lee not only kept a majority of Pittsburgh precincts, but also won outlying areas such as Bethel Park and Upper St. Clair, communities that went for Mr. Irwin in 2022. She also carried the majority of votes in Westmoreland, and her support was spread throughout precincts in that portion of the district.

Political observers said that while Ms. Lee’s win was not surprising, it’s perhaps too soon to say whether progressive politicians like her will continue to win elections in the long-term in the Pittsburgh region.

Berwood Yost, a po­lit­i­cal sci­ence pro­fes­sor who also runs pub­lic poll­ing at Frank­lin & Mar­shall Col­lege, said that progressives and moderates will continue to battle for control in the Democratic Party in the Pittsburgh region. He added that a similar range of voters exists in the Republican Party too.

Advertise with us

“If you had a multi-party system, these different groups would break off and have their own [political] parties, but they don't,” Mr. Yost said. “So there's going to be this struggle — since both parties need to represent multiple factions, there will always be these factions battling within each party.”

In Swisshelm Park on primary Election Day, two Democratic voters showcased a microcosm of that struggle. Robert Malys, 35, supported Ms. Lee, while Brandon Friez, 18, backed Ms. Patel. At the Sarah Jackson Black Community Center, Mr. Malys and Mr. Friez had a lively debate about the two candidates, mainly on their stances on the Israel-Hamas War. Despite their differences, the two shook hands afterward and continued with their day.

Mr. Hayes, the GOP candidate, said in an interview this week that getting conservative Democrats like Mr. Friez to turn out in November is a must if he’s going to beat Ms. Lee. He said if he can run a campaign like Joe Rockey — the Republican candidate for Allegheny County executive who lost by less than 10,000 votes and three percentage points to Sara Innamorato — he has a chance.

Mr. Rockey appealed to Republicans, independents and moderate Democrats, Mr. Hayes said — and he didn’t have the benefit of having a portion of Westmoreland County, the part of the district that has more Republican than Democratic voters.

Ms. Lee’s campaign could not be reached for comment for this story. But during her victory speech Tuesday, she said that she and her team would be focused on building a larger coalition of support and that western Pennsylvania serves as a “blueprint for the country” regarding progressive politics.

Advertise with us

Hayes faces uphill battle, but says he offers alternative to Lee’s progressive politics

Mr. Hayes, a Shadyside resident, had a quiet primary campaign, running unopposed on the GOP ballot.

But now, the real test for him begins. According to state data from primary Election Day, there are nearly 319,000 registered Democrats in the 12th Congressional District. There are roughly 151,000 Republicans, and 81,000 voters who are independents or from other parties.

Capturing Republicans throughout the district, along with a solid swath of moderate Democrats and independents will be key if Mr. Hayes is to pull off an upset victory. The Cook Political Report’s partisan voting index, a widely-cited metric to determine the competitiveness of congressional districts, rates the 12th Congressional District at D+8. Multiple districts across Pennsylvania — including the neighboring 17th Congressional District, which Cook’s index rates as even — are seen as far more competitive.

While Mr. Hayes said he differs with Ms. Lee on issues like the Israel-Hamas War — an issue Ms. Patel focused extensively on, to success in Squirrel Hill but barely anywhere else — he also differs with the incumbent’s positions on public safety and the economy.

Mr. Hayes lost his son, 31-year-old James Michael Hayes, to gun violence in New Kensington in December 2022. It’s an event that encouraged him to try to do something about public safety in the region — and thus, run for Congress, he said.

Advertise with us

He doesn’t disagree with Ms. Lee that there needs to be more violence intervention programs and support for youth in communities impacted by gun violence, but he also doesn’t believe Ms. Lee is supportive enough of law enforcement, or has used her position to address crime issues in the district.

Ms. Lee should do a better job of advocating for federal money to be used to reopen the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center, he said.

“I think if she really wanted to do something for the region, that would be a priority,” Mr. Hayes said. “So it's not what people say, it's what they do.”

Ms. Lee has said on the campaign trail and in a debate with Ms. Patel that policing is not the only part of solutions for crime.

The campaign ahead

Heading into the months before the general election in November, Ms. Lee is in a position similar to the primary: She’s a sizable favorite to win, political experts said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Lee has focused on local issues close to home that are also priorities nationally — during her victory speech on Tuesday, she noted the importance of clean air and water, quality public education and fighting for good-paying jobs.

Mr. Hayes said this week that he shares Ms. Patel’s belief that the incumbent does not adequately represent the district.

The challenge is Democratic primary voters didn’t agree with Ms. Patel, since Ms. Lee won many more precincts in 2024 than she did in 2022.

General election politics are different than primaries — there is a wider base of voters, and the races for president and U.S. Senate may drive greater turnout, which could have impacts down the ballot, political observers noted.

Mr. Hayes said he was “absolutely not distancing” himself from former Republican president Donald Trump, but he added that by running a campaign like Mr. Rockey — focusing on kitchen table issues important to the region — he thinks he has a chance to win.

Advertise with us

Close watchers of local elections don’t disagree — they just believe he has little room for error. Larry Ceisler, a public affairs executive based in Philadelphia who follows elections statewide, said it will be difficult for Mr. Hayes. He’s running a race where other top-ballot races will have much more attention — unlike last year, where the Allegheny County district attorney or county executive races grabbed headlines because it was an off-year election.

“It would be a tremendous upset, running for a congressional seat in a presidential year with everything on the ballot,” Mr. Ceisler said.

Staff writer Hanna Webster contributed to this report.