At polling place after polling place throughout Allegheny and Westmoreland counties on Tuesday, election judges shared the same story: Despite the nice weather, not many people came out to vote.
Robert Hand, a chief elections judge at the Adamsburg Fire Hall who has worked there since 2008, said Tuesday was a historic day there — it marked the lowest turnout for a presidential primary since that year.
“There are usually core voters who come in to vote. I have come to recognize almost all of them over the years … [and] there were a lot of people I didn’t see yesterday,” Mr. Hand said Wednesday.
In that electoral landscape, U.S. Rep Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, cruised to re-election in the 12th Congressional District’s Democratic primary against Bhavini Patel, an Edgewood Council member. With about 98% of the vote tallied, Ms. Lee was ahead of her challenger by about 22 points and more than 22,000 votes, according to unofficial results, which include mail-in ballots.
Berwood Yost, a political science professor who also runs public polling at Franklin & Marshall College, said Wednesday that primary elections tend to attract voters who are more partisan and activist in their beliefs.
“In this particular district, if you're talking about a lower turnout, you're probably talking about an older, perhaps more educated, and certainly more activist group,” Mr. Yost said. “And, so in this instance, I think that helped Summer Lee.”
Read More
Her district includes some slivers of western Westmoreland County, but the overwhelming majority of registered voters are in Pittsburgh and its eastern and southern suburbs.
Low turnout also shows the impact that progressive staffers and volunteers can have on a campaign, according to Joseph Sabino Mistick, a law professor at Duquesne University who was also chief of staff for former Mayor Sophie Masloff.
It’s tough to beat progressive campaigns with a “street game” of people knocking on doors, heading to the polls, and using other tools to get people to support their candidate, he said.
With all but four precincts reporting in Allegheny County, voter turnout across Democrats and Republicans was 26.85%. That’s the lowest it’s been in a congressional primary since 2018, when 19.11% of voters cast a ballot.
For Democrats in Allegheny County, 33% voted in this year’s primary (some precincts still need to be reported). That’s the lowest turnout for the party in a presidential primary since 2012, when 20% voted.
This year, 26.2% of Republicans voted in the primary (with some precincts still to be reported). That’s the lowest turnout for them in a presidential primary since 2008, when 24.2% of GOP voters participated.
It’s not an apples-to-apples comparison to look at past elections in Summer Lee’s district because it has only existed in its current form since 2022. That is when she first won in a five-way race in the Democratic primary, beating Steve Irwin, a former state official, by fewer than 1,000 votes.
Before that, former U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle served in a district for more than two decades that, broadly speaking, included Pittsburgh but did not extend as far east into Westmoreland County.
But that doesn’t mean low turnout didn’t have an impact on the race.
Larry Ceisler, a public affairs executive based in Philadelphia who closely follows Democratic politics statewide, agreed with Mr. Yost and Mr. Mistick — especially when the candidate already holds the seat, like Ms. Lee.
“Low turnout usually helps incumbents or candidates who are very well-organized, and have a passionate base of support,” Mr. Ceisler said.
Ms. Lee not only carried Allegheny County, but also Westmoreland County, according to unofficial election results. She was leading by 7 points and more than 700 votes in the Westmoreland portion of the 12th District.
She carried a majority of precincts in the Westmoreland portion of the district, demonstrating that she had broad support from progressives not only in Pittsburgh, but across the entire district, Mr. Yost said.
Election judges across Allegheny County and neighboring counties said Tuesday that one factor might have been playing into low turnout — President Joe Biden and former president Donald Trump are already the presumptive presidential nominees for the Democratic and Republican Party, respectively.
—Staff writer Mike Wereschagin contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.