As candidates gear up for the closing months of their primary campaigns for various offices throughout Pennsylvania, some — including Laurie MacDonald, a Democratic candidate for the 12th Congressional District — are having their petitions for candidacy challenged in court.

Ms. MacDonald, who is running against incumbent Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, and Bhavini Patel in the primary, has had her petition challenged by four registered Democrats who live in the district, which includes Pittsburgh and its eastern suburbs.

They state in their complaint that circulators assigned to collect signatures for the petition do not appear to be registered Democrat voters at the stated address. They also allege that there are numerous defects, whether it is the addresses and dates of signers, an inaccurate address listed (or none listed at all), duplicate signatures, people not being registered Democrats at their address, and other issues.

Ms. MacDonald said in a brief interview that she disputes the allegations, and is confident that she will have enough signatures to be on the ballot in April. She said that she has personally gone through the signatures and that while some might be thrown out, her campaign team aimed to get nearly 3,000 to have a buffer to qualify for the race.

Advertise with us

“I can assure you that the voters that we have are validated as solid voters, and that we will be on the ballot,” Ms. MacDonald said.

According to the state, a candidate for U.S. Congress must file a petition with 1,000 valid signatures from registered voters from their respective party in order to appear on the ballot. Ms. MacDonald’s campaign submitted 2,327 signatures from Democrats in the district. The challengers contend that zero of them are valid under state law.

A review of Ms. MacDonald’s petition shows many illegible signatures, and entries with missing information — including one page where it appears five different names have similar handwriting, and multiple entries that have “street” instead of the name of the road which the resident lives on.

Candidates must have filed their petitions with the state by Feb. 13, and any objections were due to the state by Feb. 20. Each individual challenge will be heard in the state’s Commonwealth Court in the coming weeks.

The challenge to Ms. MacDonald’s campaign is perhaps the most notable locally, given how closely watched the Democratic primary for the 12th District is. But there are other challenges to candidates in the county, and objectors that filed those allege similar issues on other petitions.

Advertise with us
  • Joseph Vodvarka, a Robinson resident and perennial candidate for U.S. Senate, has had his petition challenged. Mr. Vodvarka is running in the Republican primary against David McCormick, Tariq Parvez, Brandi Tomasetti and Cory Widmann. Senate candidates require 2,000 signatures on their petitions per state law. Mr. Vodvarka collected 2,439 signatures, and 577 are being challenged.
  • Nickole Nesby, a Duquesne resident and Democrat running for the 45th District in the state Senate. The district is based in eastern and southeastern Allegheny County and includes many communities in the Mon Valley. State law requires candidates for state senate districts to collect 500 signatures, and at least 396 of the 585 collected are being challenged. Ms. Nesby is running against 38th District state Rep. Nick Pisciottano, D-West Mifflin, and Makenzie White in the primary.
  • Kami Stulginskas, a Munhall resident running in the Republican primary for the 45th state Senate district. Ms. Stulginskas collected 699 signatures, and at least 247 are being challenged. She is facing Jen Dintini in the primary.
  • William Anderson, a Pittsburgh resident and Democrat running for state representative in the 24th District. The district, represented by La’Tasha D. Mayes, D-Allegheny, covers parts of the Hill District, West Oakland, Bloomfield, East Liberty, Homewood, Highland Park, Larimer, Lincoln-Lemington-Belmar, and surrounding areas. Mr. Anderson is required to collect 300 signatures from Democrats in the district, and 422 of 598 signatures are being challenged.

Successful petition challenges in Pennsylvania elections are rare, but not impossible. Cases are typically heard quickly, given the tight timing between the objection filing deadline and the primary election date — which this year is scheduled for April 23.