HARRISBURG — Former President Donald Trump’s first 2024 appearance in Pennsylvania on Friday offered a preview of his campaign to come in the nation’s most populous battleground state, one that could determine the next president.
As he highlighted his affinity for the state’s history, oil, steel, gun owners and his alma mater, the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, he accused President Joe Biden of presiding over crime-ridden cities, an influx of immigrants, gun control and too many electric cars on the road without enough juice to get very far.
Mr. Trump spoke before a National Rifle Association-sponsored event, assuring himself of a friendly crowd following a week in which a special counsel highlighted Mr. Biden’s age, 81, and the U.S. Supreme Court appeared ready to block efforts to keep the former president off the November ballot over his role in the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection.
“I don’t think there’s been a worse 24 hours for President Biden than what we have right now,” said Vince Galko, a Harrisburg-based Republican strategist. “It feeds into the narrative that not just Trump is putting out there but that most common-sense people have. Everyone can age gracefully, but being the leader of the free world is another thing. It’s concerning.”
Addressing a boisterous crowd at the NRA-sponsored Great American Outdoor Show, he also repeatedly maligned his successor as incompetent and seized on the counsel’s report on Mr. Biden’s mishandling of classified documents. It recommended that no charges be brought but highlighted concerns about the president’s age and memory.
“I don’t think he knows he’s alive,” Mr. Trump said at one point, drawing laughs from his supporters.
Read More
Mr. Biden’s allies showed they won’t let Mr. Trump’s attacks go unanswered.
Even before Mr. Trump took the podium, U.S. Sen. John Fetterman, D-Pa., described Mr. Trump as an agent of chaos and a liar, while fellow Democratic Sen. Bob Casey used Mr. Trump’s appearance to raise funds for his re-election, describing it as a “crucial moment” and saying the path to both the Senate and the White House runs through Pennsylvania.
Republican strategists say Mr. Trump’s trip to the state was designed to fire up his base at an opportune moment, coming right after primary wins in Iowa and New Hampshire that helped clear his path to the GOP nomination, and the special counsel’s report highlighting Mr. Biden’s age.
“It’s a good place for him to be,” Christopher Nicholas, a Harrisburg-based GOP consultant, said of Mr. Trump.
Most polls show a dead heat between Mr. Biden and Mr. Trump in the Keystone State. They also show concern by voters of both parties about Mr. Biden’s age, even as Mr. Trump is 77.
While he didn’t directly denounce absentee balloting Friday night — as he has for years, falsely claiming they lead to widespread fraud — Mr. Trump encouraged audience members to make sure they were registered to vote.
“I think Trump can win Pennsylvania just as he did in 2016, and win it by bigger numbers than he did in 2016,” said Charlie Gerow, a Harrisburg-based Republican strategist. “The transformation of Pennsylvania’s political landscape that’s been accelerated by Trump and his candidacy has been remarkable.
“Working-class folks who were historically Democratic registrants and voters are now Republicans. And now wealthy, elite suburbs have moved solidly blue. But more human beings are lining up in the red column.”
Democrats deployed a full-court press in response, defending Mr. Biden’s abilities while pouncing on Mr. Trump’s policies and tactics. They cast him as out of touch with what most Pennsylvania voters want on gun rights, abortion, immigration and the character of the person in the Oval Office.
“Every single time Donald Trump opens his mouth, he’s confused, deranged, lying or worse,” said T.J. Ducklo, a Biden campaign spokesman. “[Friday night] he lied more than two dozen times, slurred his words, confused basic facts, and placated the gun lobby.”
U.S. Sen. Chris Murphy, D-Conn., a member of Mr. Biden’s campaign advisory board, told the Post-Gazette that it “speaks volumes about how out of step Donald Trump is with what Americans care about that he’s holding his first big Pennsylvania campaign event with the NRA.”
Still, many Pennsylvania voters remain unconvinced that Mr. Biden’s economic policies are successful. And along with a new wave of headlines about Mr. Biden’s age and mental competency, both conservatives and liberals on the U.S. Supreme Court appeared ready to block efforts by states to bar Mr. Trump from the November ballot.
Democrats insisted the questions about the president’s age amount to old news.
Mr. Fetterman told reporters on a conference call Friday that Mr. Biden “is absolutely in full control,” calling the special counsel’s report “a smear and cheap shots” and accusing him of “taking things out of context.”
He said both candidates are elderly men, but that the choice in character is stark “both in Pennsylvania and all over the nation. Do we want chaos or order?”
J.J. Balaban, a Philadelphia-based Democratic strategist, said the special counsel’s report on Mr. Biden doesn’t change “any strategic equation” for his campaign. He noted that Mr. Trump, unlike Mr. Biden, faces criminal charges over his handling of classified documents, along with charges for his efforts to overturn the 2020 election, where Pennsylvania was Ground Zero.
“Voters will ultimately care more about results, so if this week’s good economic news continues, that will have a greater impact on how votes are cast in nine months,” Mr. Balaban said.
“I would argue that Trump quashing bipartisan immigration reform to reduce the migrant crisis might be a lingering issue from this week that sticks. It was an interesting moment in which he said ‘the quiet part loud’ — that he thinks he will benefit politically by there being more chaos. That would be more likely if he hadn’t admitted it publicly.”
Mr. Trump on Friday got at least one thing wrong about Pennsylvanians. He claimed they handed him two victories, in 2016 and 2020 — one of many election claims debunked by local, state and federal officials of both major parties.
In fact, Mr. Biden won the state by more than 80,000 votes four years ago.
Mr. Trump also depicted himself as the only person who could “save America,” and said if Mr. Biden wins another term, “you’re not going to have a country anymore, you’re not going to have a state anymore” — harkening back to his comments on Jan. 6, 2021, before his supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol in an effort to prevent Mr. Biden’s electoral votes from being certified.
With Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes pivotal for his re-election, Mr. Biden delivered his first major campaign speech of 2024 last month near Valley Forge to mark the third anniversary of the Capitol attack. He called Mr. Trump a threat to democracy, one of the major themes the campaign plans to highlight this fall.
“In America, genuine leaders — democratic leaders with a small D — don’t hold on to power relentlessly,” he said. “Our leaders return power to the people. And they do it willingly, because that's the deal.”
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.