WASHINGTON — Donald Trump won Pennsylvania and the presidential election in 2016, only to lose both to Joe Biden four years later.

Want to try for two out of three? The winner is likely to take the oath of office at the U.S. Capitol a year from now.

This year is Mr. Trump’s turn to be on offense after Mr. Biden, a native of Scranton, brought the Keystone State into the Democratic camp in 2020 for the seventh time in eight presidential elections.

“I would tell him to do everything he can to make this election a referendum on Biden,” said Washington-based Republican consultant Alex Conant, a veteran of Florida U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio’s 2016 presidential campaign. “If this election is about Trump’s character and behavior, he’s not going to do well with independents. What are independents thinking about when they go to vote? Is it Biden’s record on core issues or Trump’s tweets.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Biden leads Mr. Trump by less than 1 percentage point in Pennsylvania in the Real Clear Politics poll average. Most polls show a dead heat between the two.

But neither candidate is well-liked; Mr. Biden was viewed unfavorably, 55% to 41%, in a recent Quinnipiac University poll of Keystone State voters. For  Mr. Trump, it was 58% unfavorable and 38% favorable.

“I don’t know [that] the Republicans are going to win Pennsylvania,” said Mike DuHaime, a GOP consultant in New Jersey who supported former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie for the GOP presidential nomination until he withdrew before the Iowa caucuses.  “[Trump] makes it hard. People already know what they think of him. Most people don’t like him. While Biden may not be doing a great job, he’s more likable.”

Still, Mr. Trump doesn’t need much of a shift in support to win Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes (down from 20 in 2020). He lost last time by 1.2 percentage points, 50% to 48.8%, after winning in 2016 by seven-tenths of a percentage point, 48.2% to 47.5%.

“Can you flip a sliver of the electorate like Biden in 2020 was able to do?” said Christopher Borick, a pollster and political science professor at Muhlenberg College in Allentown. “We’re not talking about moving enormous sections of the electorate. We’re talking about moving marginal pieces. That’s the reality.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Conant suggested that Mr. Trump’s road to victory involves talking about issues such as immigration, education and even taxes, as many provisions of his $1.9 trillion tax law expire next year.

Republican consultant John Feehery, who is based in Washington, offered his own recipe for success: Talk about crime in Philadelphia and energy in Western Pennsylvania. He also suggested that the campaign schedule some campaign events in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, as polls show Mr. Trump drawing more support from Black men.

Vince Galko, a GOP strategist based in northeastern Pennsylvania, said Republicans must focus on “kitchen table issues” such as the economy rather than "hot button" social issues including abortion.

“Don’t get tied down to whatever the former president put on social media last night or whatever insult he hurled at someone yesterday,” he said. 

Both Mr. Galko and Mr. Feehery said GOP officials should promote absentee balloting, even though Mr. Trump claims it leads to widespread cheating.

Advertise with us

Almost 60% of the 3.5 million Pennsylvanians who voted for Mr. Biden in 2020 did so by mail, compared to just 18% for Mr. Trump. That meant Mr. Biden started Election Day with a 1.4 million-vote edge. Mr. Trump lost the state by fewer than 81,000 votes.

“It’s purely a numbers game at this point,” Mr. Galko said

And Mr. Biden now has a record that Mr. Trump can criticize, said former U.S. Rep. Jim Greenwood, a Republican who represented the Philadelphia suburbs. But Mr. Trump brings new liabilities as well, he said.

“It’s easier for Trump to run negative messages against Biden than it was four years ago, but also, the last time out, we didn’t have Jan. 6, we didn't have 91 indictments, we didn’t have all of this chaos that Trump brought. ... There are more negatives about Trump than there are about Biden.”

Mr. Trump first has to get past former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley to win the nomination for a third straight time. His recent double-digit victories in the Iowa caucuses and the New Hampshire primary have some Republican elected officials saying it’s time to pivot to the general election.

Advertise with us

“President Trump uniquely possesses the vision, experience, and ability to steer America back toward a path of prosperity,” U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, said on the social media platform X. “I am calling on Nikki Haley to suspend her candidacy immediately, as any future campaign efforts will only bolster Joe Biden and his radical Democrats.”

But there were warning signs in Mr. Trump’s wins, Mr. Greenwood said. In New Hampshire, for example, 43% of primary voters backed Ms. Haley, including close to two-thirds of independents and almost a fourth of Republicans, according to exit polls.

“There are a significant number of Republicans — and I think this would apply to Pennsylvania —  where it was as much an anti-Trump vote as a pro-Nikki Haley vote,” Mr. Greenwood said. “Trump is clearly romping in the first two primaries, but there’s a signal coming out of this that there are a significant number of Republicans who are turned off by Trump.”

While polls have given Mr. Biden poor marks for his handling of the economy coming out of a recession brought on by the pandemic, this month has brought one good piece of economic news after another. 

Pennsylvania motorists paid an average of $3.342 for a gallon of regular, down from $3.767 a year earlier, according to AAA. The Federal Reserve’s preferred measure of inflation dipped below 3%. The S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average both reached new record highs this month. The economy grew by 3.1% in 2023 and added 2.7 million jobs. Pennsylvania’s unemployment rate declined to 3.5% last month, declining from 4.3% in December 2022. The University of Michigan Index of Consumer Sentiment rose 21.4% last year.

Advertise with us

“There’s a long time between now and November,” Mr. Greenwood said. “Assuming the economy continues strong, that will overcome some of the resistance to Biden.”

Besides an improving economy, officials of Mr. Biden’s re-election campaign ticked other issues they planned to highlight, including democracy, abortion rights, lower drug costs, making corporations pay more in taxes, and reducing gun violence.

“Do we think we’re going to win? Absolutely,” campaign co-chair Cedric Richmond said on a conference call with reporters after the New Hampshire primary. “Because there’s too much on the line not to for the American people.”

To spread its message, the campaign already has staffed up in Pennsylvania and other battleground states, spokesman  Michael Tyler said.

“It’s all hands on deck now,” he said “We are full steam ahead going into the general election.”

Advertise with us

One problem Mr. Biden faces, however, is that some of his actions both attract and repel the constituencies he needs to win re-election.

Mr. Biden announced Friday that he was suspending permit approvals for new facilities to export liquefied natural gas, citing concerns over climate change. That was a step recommended by environmentalists and more than five dozen congressional Democrats, including U.S. Rep Summer Lee, D-Swissvale.

The action quickly drew criticism. “Biden’s announcement is being driven by politics and bad policy,” said state Rep. Jason Ortitay, R-South Fayette.

And Mr. Trump signaled it would be an issue in the presidential campaign.

"Joe Biden has once again caved to the radical demands of the environmental extremists in his administration,’’ Mr. Trump said Friday. “This decision to block the approval of new facilities to export American natural gas is one more disastrous self-inflicted wound that will further undermine America’s economic and national security.” 

Advertise with us

Mr. Biden’s strong support for Israel after the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas doesn’t sit well with some progressive Democrats. Some have disrupted his public appearances and gone after him for not trying to rein in Israel’s retaliation.

“You need progressives engaged for the Democratic coalition to win,” Mr. Borick said, including in Allegheny County, where Ms. Lee and county Executive Sara Innamorato, who occupy elective ofiices formerly held by more moderate Democrats, are needed to energize that wing of the party.

Republicans say Mr. Biden’s call for a two-state solution in the Middle East could repel some Jews who initially cheered his response to the attack by Hamas, designated as a terrorist group by the U.S.

“We gave him and the secretary of state [Antony Blinken] praise at the beginning, but even at the time, we caveated that we hoped, but didn’t expect, to have this level of support because he will cave to the ascending progressive left, which is anti-Israel,” said Sam Markstein, a spokesman for the Republican Jewish Coalition.

“The idea that you pick now to push a cease-fire, you pick now to push a two-state solution, really undermines the Israeli position,” he said. “The initial warmth to the Biden administration is already losing a little bit of its gloss and will fade.”

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania’s Jewish population is larger than in 45 other states, and the Republican Jewish Coalition has built a database of voters being contacted now through events, emails, texts, canvassing and phone calls. It’s no longer knocking on doors just because the occupant has a Jewish-sounding name. Initially, Mr. Markstein said that eight of every 10 homes that coalition volunteers contacted weren’t Jewish; now eight of 10 are.

While most American Jews have backed Democrats because of their stands on abortion, civil rights, social justice, eradicating poverty and other progressive issues, Israel and the subsequent spike in antisemitism have become more important factors since the Hamas attack, Mr. Markstein said.

“We’ve seen it in the polling and we’ve seen it on the ground,” Mr. Markstein said. “The issues that are on top of the Jewish community [are] the Israel-Hamas war and the spike in antisemitic hate crimes. ... What’s going on right now will be top of the minds of Jewish voters when they go and vote in November.”

So gear up for another hard-fought contest in the Keystone State, where the winner of Pennsylvania likely will be the next president of the United States.

“Pennsylvania is going to be very competitive,” Mr. Conant said. “In many ways, Pennsylvania is the story of America. You have rural parts of the state who are strongly supportive of Trump, urban areas that are strong supporters of the Democrats, and independents in the suburbs who decide elections.

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant. Washington Bureau reporter Ben Kail contributed to this report.