WASHINGTON — Two hundred bucks for an early cancellation fee from a cable and internet company. Security deposit administration fees of more than $300 when trying to rent an apartment. At least $160 in “airport concession” fees and “customer facility” charges tacked onto the advertised price for a rental car.
So-called junk fees from a variety of sectors can cost the average Pennsylvania family hundreds of dollars over a single month, according to a new report from U.S. Sen. Bob Casey.
Mr. Casey has called out what he calls corporate profiteering as the major cause of higher prices, while his likely Republican opponent in November, former hedge fund CEO David McCormick, has insisted President Joe Biden’s economic policies are to blame.
“From cable bills to rental cars, greedy corporations are ripping off hard-working American families with excessive fees to pad their bottom line,” Mr. Casey said in a statement. “It’s sinful, and one of the reasons Americans are feeling squeezed when it’s time to pick up the check or pay off their credit card.”
Mr. Casey, a three-term incumbent Democrat, has issued a series of reports highlighting increased prices and fees by agribusiness, food, service and finance companies that he says cost the average Pennsylvania family more than $3,000 each of the last few years. Last week, Mr. Casey asked the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress, to look at how those practices are hurting consumers.
His latest report says that Americans frequently find unexpected fees and other charges when they rent cars or go on trips, and often face steep early termination fees and bank overdraft fees that especially affect people living paycheck to paycheck. He said the Federal Trade Commission estimates American families would save more than $1.2 billion annually if event and hotel companies were required to switch to all-in pricing so customers can see the entire cost before making a reservation or purchase.
Read More
Mr. Casey last year cosponsored the Junk Fee Protection Act, which would require prices to reflect all of the added charges and effectively ban early termination fees. He also cosponsored the Airline Passengers’ Bill of Rights, which would bar unreasonable air carrier fees and require ticket prices to show the entire cost after all add-on charges.
Economists have attributed inflation to the billions of dollars in pandemic-related spending under both Mr. Biden and former President Donald Trump; high interest rates designed to tamper down spending, and problems with supply chains because of the pandemic and the Russian attack on Ukraine.
While inflation has cooled down, prices are still above pre-pandemic levels, giving Republicans a chance to blame high grocery, energy and other prices on Mr. Biden’s economic policies. Mr. McCormick says Mr. Casey is “in denial about what caused inflation — massive government spending that Joe Biden carried out with Bob Casey’s support.”
David Taylor, president of the Pennsylvania Manufacturers Association, wrote earlier this month that Mr. Casey’s assertion “that families’ higher grocery and fuel bills are the fault of the businesses that supply them rather than the economic conditions in which those businesses must now function” is similar to “the concept that wet streets cause rain.” He said Mr. Casey has it “exactly backwards.”
Congressional Republicans have opposed efforts to eliminate junk fees, while also fighting the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s efforts to regulate them.
Democrats in Washington and Pennsylvania continue to hammer the unpopular hidden fees.
Mr. Biden has called on Congress to ban the extra charges tacked onto online ticket purchases for concerts, ballgames and other entertainment events.
Earlier this month, the White House announced a proposal to reduce overdraft fees to as little as $3. But the banking industry plans to fight the proposed changes, and many banks may eliminate overdraft protection completely if the reduced fee rules go into effect next year, the Associated Press reported.
Last July, Pennsylvania Attorney General Michelle Henry used a U.S. Senate Banking Committee hearing to rail against junk fees. Ms. Henry said the fees mislead consumers because they think they are getting a lower price, only to be hit by surprise charges when they’re ready to check out.
“Consumers end up paying more than they expected for a product or service,” Ms. Henry told the panel. “Honest businesses lose out to competitors who charge junk fees because the competitors’ prices appear — at first — to be a better deal.”
U.S. Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, has co-sponsored the Fair Fees Act, which would ban airlines from charging unreasonable fees for bags, seat changes or cancellations. He also said he’ll keep working with the Biden administration and the CFPB to address third-party app fees and banking and credit card fees.
Last October, the consumer financial board said it obtained $140 million in refunds to customers hit with extra charges such as surprise overdraft fees, double-dipped non-sufficient funds fees, and charges for “fake paper statements and worthless add-on products” for car loans.
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.