Austin Yasofsky had a hectic start to his teaching career.

The first-year educator was eager to get into his classroom at Dominus High School: The Charter School for Entrepreneurs in Wilkins before learning in mid-October the school wasn’t opening.

He pivoted, taking a job as an instructional support teacher. But he wasn’t passionate about it, and by late October, he landed a job at McKeesport High School teaching freshman science.

Halfway through, his role again changed, putting him in a chemistry class full of juniors.

Advertise with us

Yasofsky’s experience, unconventional for most new teachers, led him to a role he had always dreamed of. And the students, he said, were “super welcoming” and patient. The Turtle Creek resident recently wrapped up his first year of teaching.

“It feels like I’ve lived six lives,” Yasofsky said. “But honestly, I’ve had so much fun.”

The Post-Gazette reconnected with three Pittsburgh-area teachers who were profiled at the beginning and middle of the academic year to see how they felt about education as they completed the first year.

Jenna Kuba is living a lifelong dream of teaching kindergarten at Derry Area’s Grandview Elementary. She loves her job, but she faced a learning curve around students’ emotional needs, which often left her exhausted at the end of the day.

And Sarelm Brooks, a special education teacher at Duquesne City Schools, is already mapping out how to improve his skills next school year while celebrating his successes.

Advertise with us

In 2025, attrition rates for first-year teachers in Pennsylvania neared 12% — the fifth-lowest rate since 2008.

Their first years were often whirlwinds. But all three said they plan to stay in education moving forward.

Their decisions come amid a statewide teacher shortage, driven by a 7% attrition rate and a large decline in the number of in-state teaching certifications issued.

Those numbers hit new teachers — those within their first three years — particularly hard.

In 2025, attrition rates for first-year teachers in Pennsylvania neared 12%, according to Ed Fuller, an associate professor at Penn State’s College of Education.

Still, that’s the fifth-lowest attrition rate since 2008 — rates spiked at 19% in 2011 — and lower than the average rate for the 17 years included in the analysis.

Advertise with us

At the same time, the state is seeing an uptick in teacher preparation enrollees, a new dashboard from the advocacy group PA Needs Teachers found. In 2022-23, more than 14,000 people enrolled in the programs. That’s up from 12,000 in 2018-19.

But more work needs to be done to improve those numbers and to ensure students remain enrolled in preparation programs, said Laura Boyce, executive director of Teach Plus PA, a nonprofit that aims to build leadership qualities among teachers.

Efforts are underway, including the student teacher stipend and several grow-your-own teacher programs, which give high schoolers and paraprofessionals a teaching career pathway.

For now, Boyce is focusing on the positive, including the three Pittsburgh-area teachers who plan to stay in the classroom.

“Getting through Year 1 is a big milestone,” Boyce said.

Advertise with us

Building confidence

About halfway through the school year, Kuba made a decision: She wasn’t going to listen to school gossip and would instead focus solely on her students.

That decision, she said, caused her confidence as a teacher at Derry, a rural Westmoreland County district of 1,800 students, to soar.

“I finally realized my job is to shut that door and have my kids and just go for it,” Kuba said. “It definitely makes a difference with them.”

She has seen improved behaviors. At the start of the school year some kids would curse, and at times they turned physical, requiring Kuba to call in the school’s crisis team.

But as the year went on, she spent time working with kids to identify the best way to improve their actions — while also remembering they’re still only 6 years old.

Advertise with us

Those efforts paid off. Today, Kuba and her students are at “an understanding level,” she said.

She also saw improvements in student skills. At the start of the year, some students came in not knowing their letters or sounds.

Kuba, in response, implemented 100 minutes of small group sessions daily where students do tactile projects such as writing their letters in sugar or turning chalk into paint and writing on paper. When it dries, students run their fingers over textured words and letters.

Student growth in response “was insane” this year, Kuba said. And her success led her to present the methods to educators from Derry, Latrobe and the district’s PreK partners.

She realized she was “doing something right and people are recognizing that.”

Advertise with us

“Getting through Year 1 is a big milestone.”

LAURA BOYCE, executive director of Teach Plus PA

Her newfound confidence showed one day in May when Kuba led a STEAM — science, technology, engineering, arts and math — lesson in which students built a boat out of pool noodles. They placed blocks and dominoes on the boat, located in an aluminum tray filled with water, to see if it would float.

Students were excited about the project. Several would run to their teacher as she roamed the room, sitting with each group to help students improve their boats, asking her to come look at their projects.

It was a year filled with learning curves. But, for Kuba, it’s the start of a career she’s dreamed of since she was a first grader at Derry.

Kuba, who is in school to get her reading specialist certification, hopes to one day become a Title I teacher who provides extra academic support to students in reading and math.

She’ll see several of her kindergarten students over the summer when she teaches at the district’s Jumpstart program focused on reading and writing before teaching fifth grade next school year.

Advertise with us

News of the move was “a shock,” but she plans to create opportunities for collaboration through a big buddy program while building on connections she made this school year.

“I’m going to miss the age of my kids more than anything, but on the bright side, working in the older grades means I could have my little ones again, and that is something worth looking forward to,” Kuba said.

Celebrating wins

As the school year progressed, Brooks, a special education teacher at Duquesne, learned to keep bags of Doritos tucked in his desk. Students “are snack motivated,” he found.

A major success for Brooks this school year was finding ways to keep students engaged.

Top incentives included tokens such as the Doritos, or giving them a few minutes on the Nintendo Switch.

Advertise with us

“Every student has a different motivator, and I found those pretty regularly,” Brooks said.

Sarelm Brooks, a special education teacher at Duquesne City Schools, is already mapping out how to improve his skills next school year while celebrating his successes. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Brooks — who has a master’s in education from the University of Pittsburgh and is dual-certified in PreK-4 and special education — is a seventh and eighth grade special education teacher focusing on emotional support, learning support and life skills at Duquesne, an underfunded K-8 school that educates 460 students.

His first year was a roller coaster.

He said he wishes he could have helped kids progress further in their literacy and math skills, something he hopes to improve upon next school year by following a framework that encourages students to expand from recalling facts to thinking for themselves.

As he navigated the challenges of his first year, Brooks learned to take it one day at a time and to focus on his achievements, such as successfully advocating for a student to receive an individualized education plan.

Advertise with us

“Some days are going to be less productive, less good for whatever reason, and if you think you’re in the right field, like I think I am in the right field, then the next day can be better for any number of reasons,” Brooks said.

“A lot of teaching is rolling with the punches,” Austin Yasofsky, a science teacher at McKeesport High School, said. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Summer break

Yasofsky had settled into his role as a freshman science teacher when McKeesport, an underfunded district of 2,900 students, lost one of two chemistry teachers.

High school leaders turned to Yasofsky, who they knew had an interest in chemistry, and he jumped at the opportunity.

When he first made the shift, the chemistry team was testing a new curriculum, easing his transition. When Yasofsky took over, he didn’t know what the kids had already learned.

He had to adjust to an older group of students, a change from the start of the school year when both Yasofsky and his freshman students were adjusting to the new school.

Advertise with us

Juniors are “more set in their ways,” he said.

“The kids are great, they’re super friendly,” Yasofsky said. “But it took a while to get responses out of them while teaching.”

Despite the initial learning curve, Yasofsky said he’s “thrilled” to be in his current position — and he didn’t have anything bad to say about his experience so far, although he’s looking forward to his summer break.

“A lot of teaching is rolling with the punches,” he said. “This year has definitely helped showcase not only to myself but to administration and my fellow teachers that I am capable of being that flexible teacher.

“And no matter what is thrown at me, I can do it.”