The Woodland Hills High School auditorium, lined with posters of past student musicals, has recently looked more like a courtroom.

Superintendent Joe Maluchnik, who is facing allegations of gender discrimination, sits beside his lawyer, who has so far cross-examined four district employees. Those employees, represented by district lawyers, gave testimony against Maluchnik, captured by a court reporter. 

The proceedings are overseen by a hearing officer. School board directors act as a jury. 

The board is conducting the hearings under Section 1080 of the Pennsylvania School Code, which allows directors to hold a hearing and eventually vote on terminating a superintendent’s contract for “neglect of duty, incompetency, intemperance, or immorality.”

Advertise with us

Maluchnik, who was placed on paid leave late last year and moved to unpaid leave in March, is facing 10 allegations related to gender-based discrimination and harassment, charges he and his lawyer have denied. 

The hearings are rare, experts say. When they do take place, they are time-consuming. At Woodland Hills, the first two hearings have lasted around four hours each.

They also can be costly and can worsen already-strained divisions between districts and communities.

West Mifflin held one in 2019, which resulted in the termination of then-Superintendent Daniel Castagna. 

“It’s a shame when they do get to that point,” said Tom Ralston, an assistant professor in the University of Pittsburgh’s education school, executive director of the Forum for Western Pennsylvania School Superintendents and former Avonworth superintendent. He has not participated in 1080 hearings. “It’s not a good thing.” 

Advertise with us

A peek behind the curtain

The proceedings offer a rare glimpse into what are typically closed-door personnel discussions. 

The district presents charges and supporting evidence. The superintendent may then respond with information for the board to consider before it proceeds.

At Woodland Hills, district lawyer Allison Genard has presented copies of emails and other documents to support claims made by district employees, all women. She then questioned those staffers about what led to those emails while expounding on meetings and conversations the women said made them feel uncomfortable.

Allegations made in the first two hearings over the past month suggest Maluchnik promoted and gave raises only to male administrators, had arguments with female staff during which they felt uncomfortable and excluded female administrators from meetings and decisions they traditionally were involved in.

One teacher, Lori McDowell, also described an instance in which Maluchnik allegedly grabbed her hands and held them for 15 seconds during a disagreement. 

Advertise with us

In a joint statement issued last week, the women — Jill Regan, business manager; Pamela White, assistant to the superintendent for administrative services; Leah Sylvis, director of special education; and McDowell — said they remain concerned for the well-being of the district’s students and staff.

“Our hope is a simple one: a fair process, and a school environment where every student and every employee can do their best work, free from hostility and discrimination,” the statement read. “That is where our attention is, and where it will stay.”

Maluchnik’s lawyer, Manning O’Connor, has tried to discredit the claims. 

He said during the hearings that Maluchnik was hired to address financial issues and student performance, and to establish accountability, efforts not welcomed by some district staff. 

Board President Karen Lyons directed questions about the hearings to the district solicitor, Matthew Racunas. 

Advertise with us

The solicitor and O’Connor did not respond to messages seeking comment. 

A third hearing is scheduled for Wednesday evening. It’s unclear how many hearings the district could hold before there’s a public meeting to vote on Maluchnik’s contract.

1080 hearings 

School boards, which are tasked with hiring superintendents, previously could negotiate buyouts if they wanted to terminate their top leaders. But in 2012, lawmakers overhauled the Pennsylvania School Code to include Section 1080, which puts limits on severance packages. 

Terminations also can occur when boards do not extend a superintendent’s contract. 

After the hearings — the superintendent determines whether they will be public or private — the board holds a meeting to collect public input and vote on whether it will terminate the superintendent. 

Advertise with us

The superintendent can appeal the decision to the Court of Common Pleas. 

But the process can be costly — districts need to pay the hearing officer and court reporter, as well as their counsel. An appeal can lead to additional legal fees. 

By March 2019, West Mifflin had accumulated more than $151,000 in costs related to 1080 hearings that lasted for months. Castagna faced allegations that he paid members of a notorious biker gang to spook political rivals and that he helped a convicted killer get a school security job. Castagna and his lawyer maintained his innocence, but the board fired him in March 2019. 

Those costs rose in 2022 when a federal jury ruled the district must pay $2.9 million to Castagna after he sued the district and six board members, claiming the district’s allegations made during the hearing were retaliation by political rivals. 

It was not immediately clear how much Woodland Hills is spending on the hearings. 

Advertise with us

The hearings can also cause public mistrust.

During the two hearings at Woodland Hills — which already has a rocky relationship with the community — some sat quietly listening to the allegations while others scoffed or laughed as testimony was given. Many expressed distrust of the board. 

In recent months, several have questioned district spending. The Pennsylvania Office of the Budget is now conducting a full performance audit of the district’s finances. 

And Director Terri Lawson was accused in February of making nearly $10,000 in personal purchases on a Rankin credit card when she served as borough manager. She was fired from that position and resigned as Woodland Hills board president.

Overall, Ralston said, the hearings are a distraction. 

Advertise with us

The focus, he said, should be “on the learning that’s occurring, celebrating the wonderful things that children are doing.” Events such as the hearings shift the focus away from education. 

“It reverberates through the employees that work there, the families that the schools serve,” Ralston said. “And so it is oftentimes pretty upsetting, and it's unfortunate that they occur.”