The Pittsburgh Public Schools board appears poised to reject an application for a charter school being spearheaded by a city schools teacher.
The board will vote at a legislative meeting Wednesday on a resolution that could deny Three Rivers Wildflower Montessori permission to open next year.
Stephanie Lapine, who teaches at Manchester PreK-8, has led an effort to start a charter school in Pittsburgh that uses the Montessori method — an education practice based on student self-directed activity, collaborative play and hands-on learning.
While Pittsburgh already has a Montessori elementary school in Friendship, Ms. Lapine — a teacher and teaching instructor of the method — said at a board meeting this month that the school does not offer the full Montessori model to students.
“It's vastly different from the Montessori magnet model [in PPS] in that children are not given assigned rounds,” she said, meaning that children may have math in the morning and language in the afternoon and assignments that go along with that subject. “In full Montessori with fidelity, they're not being told what to do by a teacher.”
Ms. Lapine said Montessori is a complete curriculum, which incorporates all grades, cultural subjects, math, language arts and more.
Read More
But Lisa Augustin, PPS director of charter accountability, presented the findings of the review of the charter application to the school board that identified a variety of deficiencies in the charter’s educational and business plans.
Charter schools must be approved by the school board of the district where they’re located.
The review found that the application did not provide evidence that the proposed charter school can provide comprehensive learning experiences to students, and the submitted curriculum does not meet the needs of students with exceptionalities. The submitted curriculum was not complete and comprehensive or aligned to state core standards, the review determined, and there was not explicit criteria for measuring student mastery.
In addition, there was not sufficient evidence that the school would improve student learning, increase learning opportunities for all pupils or use different or innovative teaching methods.
The review found that the description of the school’s governance structure was incomplete and the financial plan was deemed to be insufficient.
“One of the major deficiencies with this application is that there is no location provided,” Ms. Augustin said. “That is a requirement within a charter school application, that there is an address of a facility that we can visit, that we can inspect, that we can provide feedback on, and that we can determine whether or not it is suitable for children.”
The review panel, made up of seven PPS administrators and staff members, recommended that the board not approve the charter application.
Ms. Lapine, who could not be reached Tuesday, said at the early February board meeting that she believes the Montessori model is innovative and can benefit the city.
She said those involved in the planning of Three Rivers Wildflower would examine the review and seek ways to address deficiencies found in the plan.
“This is a learning curve,” Ms. Lapine said. “When we started this project, we knew that it was going to be a marathon — not a race. We are so dedicated to this work that you will see us again, we will come back and make sure that we satisfy all of the requirements.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.