Parents and community leaders almost immediately sought changes in the aftermath of a stabbing at Carrick High School in September.

Some wanted heightened security personnel as well as updated metal detectors and other equipment.

Others asked for increased community involvement and conflict-resolution training.

Pittsburgh Public Schools directors and administrators focused on another factor they believe was at least partially to blame for the violence: cell phones.

Advertise with us

“A lot of things that happen in school have their root in social media or something rooted in the cellular phone,” Superintendent Wayne Walters said in a recent interview, “and then [there are] the distractions that they cause.”

In the months after the stabbing, city school directors pointed to bullying on social media prior to the incident as they moved to enact a districtwide ban on cell phones during the school day. The board in December approved the ban — with exceptions — that will go into effect at the start of the 2026-27 school year. Before the board had approved the policy, the district said 44 of its 54 schools already collected cell phones during the day.

The conversation around cell phone bans in schools goes far beyond Pittsburgh and has broader implications than the impact it could have on bullying and violence. Lawmakers in Harrisburg have taken up the issue of cell phone bans because of the effect that electronic devices have on student learning.

State Sen. Devlin Robinson, R-Bridgeville, and state Rep. Mandy Steele, D-Fox Chapel, have sponsored bills calling for the governing body of each school entity to adopt a policy on cellphone possession and usage no later than the start of the 2027-28 school year. The effect of the bill would be to “prohibit the use of a mobile device during the school day while on school property.”

Studies have shown mixed results on the effect cell phone bans have had on academic outcomes and school climate. But some education experts say that limiting distractions in class has obvious benefits.

Advertise with us

“This isn't the sort of question that should require a research-based answer,” said David Griffith, national research director at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, an education-reform think tanks. “Anyone who owns a cell phone knows they are addictive and distracting, even for adults.”

The problem goes further than students sending an occasional text message or peeking at TikTok.

Mr. Griffith said studies show phone alerts are potentially causing dozens of distractions a day even if students don’t pull out their devices to look at them.

“It's constantly buzzing or dinging, telling them that there's something else that they're supposed to be paying attention to as opposed to fractions or Shakespeare,” he said. “And that just cannot possibly be healthy if the goal is for kids to focus and to learn."

Kathy Do, an assistant research scientist with the UCLA School of Education and Information Studies, who last year co-authored a report titled, “Strengthening Cellphone Policies to Support Student Learning and Well-Being,” said that while cellphone bans can have positive effects on students, there is also a risk for harm.

Advertise with us

“It can minimize the risk of bullying or capturing sensitive moments that might be spread online,” Ms. Do said. “But I think taking away the phone in and of itself and not connecting teaching to how to use it more responsibly, how to be sensitive to the needs of all students, is where we can't just stop at the restrictions.”

Ms. Do said a key takeaway from her research was that there is no one-size-fits-all policy. Schools must build equitable, age-appropriate policies to make sure all students can thrive with the goal of helping them build balanced digital habits.

Ms. Do recommended that school leaders pair whatever cell phone restrictions they choose with education for students and adults on why these restrictions matter, and to include educators, families and students when they design policies.

Certain policies, such as the so-called “bell to bell” plan that PPS will implement districtwide, may work better for middle schoolers whose self-regulation skills and the brain areas that support those skills are still developing, according to Ms. Do.

But school leaders may consider allowing more flexibility for older students, she said, so they can build healthy phone habits in and out of school.

Advertise with us

Any policy, of course, should allow for exceptions, Ms. Do said.

“We know, for example, some districts leverage cell phones in science experiments to offset not having iPads or things like that to help measure the rate at which objects drop,” Ms. Do said. “Also, for students with students with disabilities, they often use an auto transcription app to help deaf or hard of hearing students. So, there's lots of benefits when phones are used intentionally as part of instruction or to help students with disabilities.”

The city schools’ policy allows exceptions for students with disabilities as well as health, safety and emergency reasons. Devices may also be used at times for educational activities and other circumstances approved by administrators.

Mr. Walters said he understands that people want information instantly, but added that he believes cell phones cause more harm than good.

And while the district’s policy will go into effect in the fall, the superintendent said he’s already thinking about challenges the district will face from the next technological advance.

“You can go into LensCrafters right now, you can go online, and you can buy those Meta glasses, and you can record,” Mr. Walters said. “Where you think you're fixing one challenge, the movement of the world creates another.”