Union leaders at Pennsylvania Western University worry about stability and lack of faculty involvement in the state university’s plan to cut dozens of offerings at its three campuses.

During a council meeting Thursday, Mario Majcen — faculty union president at the California campus — called on PennWest leaders to be transparent about their decision-making process and mindful of the impact that cuts could have on PennWest’s academic integrity.

“Faculty understand the fiscal and enrollment pressures that drive this conversation… and we agree that thoughtful planning is necessary,” said Mr. Majcen, a professor of atmospheric sciences. “However, decisions about academic programs must be data-informed, mission-driven and meaningfully shaped by faculty expertise.

“Some of that has happened. But also to date, many faculty experience this process as rushed and opaque, with insufficient clarity about criteria, financial impacts and long-term academic consequences.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Majcen and two other campus union presidents with the Association of Pennsylvania State College & University Faculties shared their concerns during a Council of Trustees meeting Thursday afternoon.

The plan to cut dozens of majors, minors, certificates and concentrations at the struggling university was first reported by the Post-Gazette in December.

PennWest administrators say the proposed cuts aim to help the campuses adapt to modern learning experiences and respond to workforce needs. Last week, interim Provost James Fisher told the Post-Gazette that decisions were driven by data analysis and a student survey. Faculty and staff in academic affairs then put together programmatic recommendations.

Mark Kilwein, president of APSCUF-Clarion, said faculty were consulted about potential cuts — “but after the decisions were already made.” He called on the university to allow for greater faculty involvement.

“We see ourselves as experts in the process,” said Mr. Kilwein, a professor of psychology. “We believe that we should at the very least be participating as equal members [and] equally vested stakeholders in the academic array.”

Advertise with us

Moving forward, a university curriculum curriculum committee will make final recommendations on which offerings to sunset after a “shared governance” process, Mr. Fisher has said.

PennWest President Jon Anderson will then have the final say on cuts. Updated curriculum information is expected by late spring.

During Thursday’s meeting, Mr. Anderson said the proposed changes to academic offerings are student- centered.

“[Students] want clarity, flexibility and relevance,” he said. “They want to understand how their education connects to their goals, and they want the ability to shape that experience without increasing time to degree or cost.”

But Sam Claster, APSCUF-Edinboro president, worries that this move throws faculty into greater disarray. PennWest professors have been in a “perpetual state of change and instability” since PennWest’s three campuses merged in 2022, he told the council.

Advertise with us

“This whole experience is like being in the Bill Murray movie ‘Groundhog Day’ and we just can’t seem to get out of it,” Mr. Claster, a sociology professor, said in a statement. “Here we are, not even Feb. 2, and I’ve already seen my shadow… the faculty are yet again starting the spring semester with massive lift in terms of curricular work, all while doing our day-to-day work with students and dealing with all other changes we are still adjusting [to].”

He called on university leaders to seek targeted investments in training, faculty and state-of-the-art equipment. The university is at an “inflection point,” he believes.

Last month, Mr. Fisher wrote in an email that PennWest leaders intend to phase out six undergraduate programs, four graduate programs and 34 minors.

The tri-campus school is also considering ending nine bachelor’s degree programs on specific campuses. Also under the recommendations, 33 concentrations (undergraduate and graduate) and 28 certificates (post-baccalaureate and sub-baccalaureate) would be cut.

PennWest does plan to redesign some minors as certificates, and add a certification and concentration to two of its graduate-level programs.

Advertise with us

If the plan comes to fruition, the university’s offerings would include:

  • 43 bachelor’s degree majors (down from 47)
  • 23 master’s degree programs (down from 27)
  • 40 minors (down from 74)
  • 37 undergraduate certificates (up from 19)

Undergraduate majors to be cut at all three campuses include those in legal studies, theatre, commercial music technology, digital media technology (both bachelor’s and associate degree programs) and engineering technology (associate degree program).

Graduate majors on the chopping block are legal studies, corporate communication, athletic training and professional accountancy.

Mr. Fisher said a combination of holistic factors — including, but not limited to, enrollment — was considered in the cuts.

The provost does not anticipate any faculty or staff layoffs after cuts. Any student currently enrolled in an impacted program would be able to complete their degree on their home campus.

Advertise with us

The cuts have sparked backlash from some students, professors and alumni. A student-created petition to save the art majors at the California campus has garnered more than 1,300 signatures online, and California campus alumni told the Post-Gazette they are alarmed about the potential cuts.

University-wide enrollment stands at 10,135 students, Vice President for Strategic Enrollment Management Darren Wagner shared Thursday.