Eva Diodati watched online in November as the Pittsburgh Public Schools board voted down the hotly debated district facilities plan.

Diodati was not surprised the vote failed because of its divisiveness among the community. But it left the newly-elected but yet-to-be sworn in member of the city schools board – as well as the two other new directors, Tawana Cook Purnell and Erikka Grayson – with a monumental and controversial issue they will likely have to deal with in their first few months on the job.

“I was watching it live on YouTube when it was happening,” Diodati said. “I was watching this in real time, and I texted Tawana and Erikka and I said, ‘Well, it looks like we got some work ahead of us.’”

A third of the nine-member PPS board is new as of Dec. 1, and the directors have some important work to do. In addition to the facilities plan, the district is seeking to solve issues that have plagued the city schools for years, such as poor reading scores and chronic absenteeism.

Advertise with us

But before that, the school board must pass a budget. The district budget must be approved before the end of the year.

District administration has requested the board approve a 4% tax increase — in what would be its first millage hike since 2021 — to hold the budget deficit at about $7 million. The board is expected to vote on the budget and tax increase on Wednesday, placing considerable pressure on the new directors right away. 

“It's incredibly stressful,” Diodati said. “Nobody wants to be the person who people are angry at, that's just a human trait. However the vote goes, I know there are people who are going to be upset.”

The millage increase sought by the district would increase taxes by about $40 per $100,000 a home is assessed for. Without the tax increase, the budget deficit would grow to about $14 million, according to Superintendent Wayne Walters.

In an interview in Arlington last week, Diodati signaled indecision on voting for the millage hike.

Advertise with us

Cook Purnell, however, said in a phone interview with the Post-Gazette that a tax increase was unnecessary, and the school district should not ask for more from residents when other options to improve finances can be explored.

“Until we do a better job of what we're supposed to do, how dare we ask people to pay more?” Cook Purnell said. “And until we go after UPMC and some of the other people who aren't paying their fair share, I think it's rude and insensitive.”

At least on the point that nonprofit organizations and corporations in the city — such as UPMC — could do more to help the district, Diodati agreed.  

“I couldn't help but nod my head when people are saying [during public comment], ‘Why aren't these massive, multi-billion companies helping to cover this cost?’” Diodati said. “And I understand that. I can completely respect that.”

Grayson, the other new school board member, could not be reached. This is the first time all three new directors are holding public office.

Advertise with us

The budget and possible tax increase will be the first major decision for the new board members. However, it will not be the last substantial choice they will make this term.

School board President Gene Walker said last week that the district’s facilities plan would be revisited, but he did not identify when that might happen.

Walker, though, acknowledged the three new directors would need time to educate themselves on the plan.

“With our new board members starting, it's important that we give them some time to get their feet settled and really look deeply into the work that we've been doing,” Walker said. “Then [we can] work with the superintendent and his team to see if and where there needs to be adjustments to make what we're trying to do work better for our families and our communities.”

Diodati and Cook Purnell both said it was necessary for the district to make changes to its footprint.

Advertise with us

Diodati worried about the poor state of some of the city’s schools and wondered what would happen if a building became unsafe or unusable in the middle of the year.

“If we can't afford to [upgrade schools] because it's so costly, but we keep the kids in the building, eventually the building will get to the point that you can't keep kids in it,” the school director said. “So then they're just going to have to be put in whatever school or place we can put them.”

For her part, Cook Purnell said she was “excited” by the facilities plan, appreciating that it attempted to make equitable changes and created distinct elementary, middle and high schools.

Cook Purnell said she thought the district could have done a better job communicating how the plan could improve the lives of students.

“I was very excited about the changes and thought it was bold and courageous,” she said. “I think they need to talk more about how the students will actually benefit from the changes. I don't know if that came across loud and clear.”

Advertise with us

There are many other significant issues the board will have to contend with in the coming months and years.

According to A+ Schools’ 2025 “Report to the Community,” about a third of district students were chronically absent – missing 10% or more days – in the 2024-25 school year.

Diodati, who has intimate knowledge of the district’s absentee problems because of her work as a librarian in the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh system, called the absentee rate “outrageous.”

“Working in the library, we're where the truant kids go if they don't go home,” Diodati said. “They come to the library because we're one of the few places that will let them be there even if it is during the school day. We do try to encourage them to go back.”

Cook Purnell said the district must improve reading scores.

Advertise with us

A presentation last week by Shawn McNeil, the city school’s chief academic officer, revealed that 44% of district third graders were proficient in English language arts on the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment and Pennsylvania Alternate System of Assessment standardized tests. That number has fluctuated slightly since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, but it has not exceeded 48%.

Reading should be taught throughout the curriculum and not just in reading classes, Cook Purnell said. For example, she said, many students struggle in math because they have a hard time reading word problems.

“The fact that fewer than half of the students in the city are reading at proficiency or excellence is very disturbing to me,” she said. “It is shameful. My personal objective is to get in there and figure out what's going on and why. What is happening, and what can we do?”

The new board members said they know there is much to do, but that their work is vital for the future of the students, the school district and the city.

As Diodati put it after the school facilities plan was voted down: “For me, it was just a focus of, 'OK, let's crack our knuckles and get to work.’”