When the Pittsburgh Public Schools board closed Schenley High School in 2008, it didn’t just shutter classrooms — it scattered memories.

Those memories spilled into basements, closets and attics across Pittsburgh, where alumni still keep yearbooks, trophies, and even red Spartan towels that once were waved like Terrible Towels.

For Janel Young, who graduated 16 years ago, the memories live on in a bin filled to the brim with old Schenley High School sports memorabilia, tucked safely away in her childhood home. Inside are old sports jerseys and T-shirts, alongside Spartan towels, from the three years she spent at Schenley before the district closed the North Oakland school in 2008.

“I had so much Schenley pride and still do,” Ms. Young, now 34, said. “I really think that the community at Schenley, including the faculty, staff and the students, it was really unmatched. It built me up in my formative years. It built my confidence. It solidified my academic journey.”

Advertise with us

She spent three beloved years at Schenley before school directors voted to shutter the school — a controversial decision that forced her to finish her senior year in 2009 at the former Reizenstein Middle School building in East Liberty. In the years that followed, Ms. Young, who was the captain of the girls basketball team and served as class president, collected the sports items from a former athletic director.

This illustration of Schenley High School was taken from the 1947 yearbook which is part of the Detre Library and Archive at the Heinz History Center. (Courtesy of Detre Library and Archive)

The Pittsburgh Public school district is now weighing another round of closures focused mainly on elementary and middle school buildings. The district in July held a series of public hearings on the possible closures; the board now has to wait three months before it can vote on the proposal.

But the question looms: what happens after the last school bell rings? What happens to the traditions and the community built up over decades? And what happens to the artifacts that once defined a school’s spirit and continue to stir long-lost memories and pride for students from their school years?

Schenley is one of several Pittsburgh Public Schools that has closed over the district’s 190-year history. The school is still revered by former graduates, many of whom enjoy seeing items that gave the school its character such as yearbooks and trophies.

The limestone building constructed in 1916 as the nation’s first $1 million school building still towers over treelined streets, although now it’s filled with apartments. Prized possessions such as yearbooks, trophies and a Caesar statue were placed at Obama 6-12 where they can still be seen today. Other pieces, such as Ms. Young’s sports paraphernalia, have been privately collected by former Schenley students.

Advertise with us

Historical school items, Anne Madarasz, chief historian at the Heinz History Center said, have an important place because “it gets at everything.”

“It gets to kind of the broader American experience, and the role that the schools [play] in shaping the populace and the kind of civic life of the nation,” Ms. Madarasz said. “And it gets at what we value as a people.”

Across the Pittsburgh region, old school items are often spread between school districts and private citizens, Ms. Madarasz said, something that also happens with large industry or corporate collections.

She pointed to the Central Valley School District, established in 2009 following a voluntary merger between the Center Area School District and the Monaca School District. Today some items from both schools reside at the new Central Valley district in Beaver County.

At Pittsburgh Public, when officials are considering closing buildings, one of the first things they do is inventory each item in that school, Michael McNamara, the district’s chief operations officer, said. Championship trophies may move with the students, while extra furniture may be stored, auctioned off or relocated.

Advertise with us

Additionally, the district will lean on partnerships with organizations such as Friends of the Art, part of the Associated Artists of Pittsburgh. If a school closes, PPS works with the organization to see if any pieces could be moved to different school buildings.

The goal, Mr. McNamara said, is to work with school communities to understand their needs.

“When we're doing this, we're trying to be very thoughtful and we're not wanting to erase history or not celebrate some of the stuff that's happened at the buildings that are no longer in the district,” Mr. McNamara said. “Just really making sure that we stay thoughtful and we still honor the history of the school district as a whole even though we may be changing our footprint a little bit with the times.”

Sophia Facaros stands in front of the former Schenley High School, now Schenley Apartments, in Oakland on Thursday, Sept. 18, 2025. Sophia was principal at Schenley in 2008 when the school closed, and was tasked with packing up what was left. She is now mayor of Oakmont. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Schenley High

The summer of 2008 was hectic for Sophia Facaros.

That year the Schenley High School principal was informed her school was closing. The decision sent her scrambling as she managed concerns of teachers and staff who would have to search for new positions as well as worked with parents concerned about their children’s future.

Advertise with us

Plus she had to oversee the creation of an inventory list and the relocation of items accumulated in the school since its opening.

“I remember [former Superintendent Mark] Roosevelt saying to me, ‘I know you can handle this job,’” Ms. Facaros, now the Oakmont mayor, said. “And I said, ‘My God, wow, this is the biggest job I had.’ I didn’t ever think I would be the one closing Schenley.”

The decision to close the school came 92 years after the triangle-shaped building opened at the intersection of Centre and North Bellefield avenues.

In its time, Schenley was known for innovation education practices and diversity. And it boasted alumni such as the artist Andy Warhol, jazz great George Benson and Nobel Prize-winning physicist Clifford Shull. It later housed a teacher training initiative and new magnet schools including the International Baccalaureate program.

But over the years the school had ups and downs, and in the late-2000s it was struggling. In addition to plaster falling from the ceiling, concerns were growing about the prominence of asbestos throughout the building, the final nail in the school’s coffin.

Advertise with us

According to the district at the time, it would have cost between $42 million and $87 million to renovate, including fixing the asbestos and plaster.

Instead, the school board voted 5-4 in June 2008 to close Schenley.

Jonquil Schaller, who graduated as a Schenley student in 2011, remembers attending town halls and marching in front of the administration building.

“It was sad because the school itself was such a part of Schenley, it was such a part of the legacy, it just being there so long,” said Ms. Schaller, now 32 and living in New York City.

Following the vote, school directors permitted Schenley’s remaining 10th, 11th and 12th graders to attend classes at Reizenstein as Schenley students until they graduated.

Advertise with us
A model unit in Schenley Apartments, formerly Schenley High School, in Oakland on Thursday, Sept. 11, 2025. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

At that point, Ms. Facaros made sure that some items were moved to Reizenstein with the students. In all it took her two years to clear out the Schenley building.

At Reizenstein, Ms. Schaller recalls a closet filled with memorabilia such as yearbooks dating back to 1917, dance cards used during old school gatherings and letterman jackets. Ms. Young, who graduated in 2009 and has the box of sports paraphernalia, remembers a trophy room where athletic awards were displayed.

But, despite all the familiar items they brought along, Reizenstein never felt the same as Schenley.

Ms. Young said the Reizenstein building had few windows, a change from Schenley’s bright design. And the group shared the building with Obama 6-12 students. As Schenley students phased out with each graduating class, more Obama classes were added to the building. Schenley students were tucked into two hallways in a second-floor corner of Reizenstein.

“It felt like it was built like Legos,” Ms. Schaller said of Reizenstein. “It was so, so ugly.”

Advertise with us

During the final days of Schenley at Reizenstein in 2011, students were permitted to go through boxes filled with old Schenley memories. Ms. Schaller snatched a Schenley “S” previously attached to a letterman jacket. The “S” still sits in the childhood bedroom of her mom’s Pittsburgh home.

At the same time, school directors had voted to close Peabody High School. Obama 6-12 students moved into the Peabody building starting in the 2012-13 school year.

During that shift, several Schenley items were moved to the Peabody building — including the Caesar statue now located in the lobby. Yearbooks went to the Obama library.

Other items have made it into personal collections, such as one at Alison Babusci’s Stanton Heights home. There, Ms. Babusci, a 1988 Schenley grad, has boxes filled with recordings of old high school musicals directed by her dad, Roger Babusci, who taught English at Schenley for years. She also has T-shirts from every musical and a newspaper article from the year her dad retired.

And hanging on her wall are a handful of pins, one of which reads “I’m a famous teacher,” a nod to Mr. Babusci’s popularity at the school.

Advertise with us

“I have a really hard time letting stories die … It's just so important to me to keep these because the objects contain stories,” Ms. Babusci said. “All I have to do is pick up a photo of a particular time and then I can remember.”

The Heinz History Center has its own collection of old Pittsburgh Public items, established through private donations and gifts from Pittsburgh Public’s Board of Education donated in 1992 and 2010.

As for the building itself, Schenley continues to tower over North Oakland. But rather than being filled with raucous high schoolers, it’s been converted into apartments after being purchased in 2013 by the Philadelphia-based PMC Property Group.

The former auditorium remains fully intact, including the original dark blue seats, and today is used as a movie theater for residents. A half basketball court includes original pieces from the school’s court including those painted with Schenley’s red, black and white colors.

Chalkboards adorn the walls of some of the 180 apartments that range between $1,695 for a one bedroom and $2,105 for a two bedroom, and in the lobby a stone carving titled “Maiden with coffer” is attached to the wall, a gift from the graduating class of 1928.

Advertise with us

For many Schenley graduates, they look back at the memories fondly.

Jake Oresick, who graduated in 2001, used several of the old yearbooks and school newspapers to research his book “The Schenley Experiment: A Social History of Pittsburgh’s First Public High School.”

“I'd love to see the District partner with a museum, library, or both to ensure these wonderful artifacts can be enjoyed by the public,” Mr. Oresick said in an email. “The District staff is wonderful, but it's unfair to expect them to also be archivists. Let's team up with professionals who are trained to preserve these items and make them accessible.”

Pete Vitti, a former Schenley history teacher, agreed, noting that the items are important to those with roots in the schools, as well as for their children and grandchildren. He added that as a history teacher he talks about the importance of how history defines a people. Historical school items and buildings “define who we are as a city,” Mr. Vitti said.

Ms. Young added that when it comes to closing schools, officials and the community need to remember that the buildings are someone’s history.

“This is a collective group history and I would believe that there are many people who would express that some of their best memories have happened in some of these schools, or some of their closest friends and relationships that they’ve built and lessons that they've learned existed within whatever those physical walls were,” Ms. Young said. “And I do think it's important for us to recognize that and document and to hold dear to the things that we can.”