Emma Hull wrapped up playing “Pomp and Circumstance” with her fellow bandmates at last school year’s graduation ceremony for the class of 2025 when the valedictorian gave a surprise reminder: the district will no longer consider class rank for future students.

Emma, who was a junior at the time, was taken aback by the announcement.

“I was very disheartened at it,” Emma, now a 17-year-old senior, said. “I was like, ‘Oh,’ And I looked at my mom, too, and she was shaking her head. And all my other friends around me, we were all just looking at each other.”

Connellsville in Fayette County is eliminating class rank this school year in favor of a tiered system that will recognize more students. The decision came after district leaders saw students packing schedules full of Advanced Placement and honors courses, and it followed a year’s worth of research that indicated eliminating the ranking system would not negatively impact students.

Advertise with us

But Emma is now one of several high school students pushing back against the changes as they worry how college and scholarship applications could be impacted, as well as concerns that students will no longer be motivated to take challenging courses.

So far the group has created a petition that garnered over 1,100 signatures. They’ve gathered at school board meetings to express their concerns and the group held a small protest, all efforts to try and get school leaders to reinstate class rank.

“I honestly think this eliminates competition, healthy competition, among students that you'll experience in the workplace,” 17-year-old senior Morgan Nicholson said. “After you graduate high school you’ll constantly be competing against someone else for either a raise or a better position.”

Connellsville, a district of 3,800 students, voted in 2023 to eliminate class rank starting in the 2025-26 school year. They instead have implemented the tiered system that identifies students with a GPA of 3.8 or higher as cum laude. Those with a 4.0 or higher, along with the completion of two or more AP classes, are identified as magna cum laude and those with a 4.15 or higher, along with the completion of four or more AP classes, as summa cum laude.

Last year, the district honored 76 students who fell into the summa cum laude category, rather than the traditional top 10 based on class rank. Students are honored during graduation.

Advertise with us

And in that time, Connellsville leaders did not know of any opposition to eliminating class rank, according to a statement provided by Superintendent Richard Evans.

“Having said that, the board and administration is always going to hear, consider, and take serious any concern that is brought forth by our students, families, and/or community,” the statement reads.

The decision to eliminate class rank came after several area districts made similar moves.

Most recently, Southmoreland in Westmoreland County voted in January to eliminate class rank. Seneca Valley in Butler County put less of a priority on the ranking starting in the 2017-18 school year, when officials stopped making the ranking public to students. And in Allegheny County, Hampton Township and North Allegheny no longer consider the ranking while Mt. Lebanon and Upper St. Clair have not used it for the past 20 years.

It’s part of a national trend that has been happening for years, David Lang, the chair of the economics department at California State University, Sacramento, said.

Advertise with us

“By and large teachers don't love it,” Mr. Lang said. “School districts don't love the headaches that it often winds up creating. … But the top end students in medium to large public school districts feel like they need this in order to differentiate themselves when it comes to applying to elite institutions across the country and to scholarships across the country.”

Given that, Mr. Lang said, both sides of the argument are correct.

Eliminating class rank, Mr. Lang said, “will overall reduce stress,” but only among some students. Those near the top of their class could see an increase in stress as they look for other ways “to differentiate themselves from their peers.” And while it can encourage students to take a healthier slate of course, elimination of the measure can also reduce “some of the incentive that comes along with taking a more challenging class,” Mr. Lang said.

He also pointed to measures colleges and universities use in admissions, something that is continually changing.

Penn State University does not consider class rank. The University of Pittsburgh takes a similar approach, but if the ranking is provided it will be considered by the admissions committee. And Carnegie Mellon University will also consider class rank as part of a student’s academic record if it’s provided, “but it is rarely included anymore,” a spokesperson said, adding that the ranking is not a key factor in the university’s admission decision process.

Advertise with us

Pushback at Connellsville

At Connellsville, the decision to eliminate class rank followed a year of research and discussion involving the former superintendent, school board, high school principals, guidance counselors and student groups, the district statement reads.

Officials found that "eliminating class rank would not have an adverse effect on those things,” the statement reads. It continues, saying that many colleges and universities are looking for well-rounded students who are involved in service groups and extracurricular activities rather than the number of honors or AP courses on a students’ transcript.

“In the end, it was the collective decision of the district to eliminate class rank, allow students to feel free to expose themselves to a wide-range of curriculum, be more well-rounded, pursue their passions, while still allowing highly-motivated, driven students to challenge themselves with as many high-level, rigorous, advanced placement courses that they would choose to take,” the district statement reads.

But some students continue to question the decision.

Natalie Mangus, a 17-year-old senior, said she is concerned how the changes could impact her as she applies to colleges and submits scholarship applications. But she doesn’t expect the motivation behind taking an AP class to change without class rank.

Advertise with us

“If they care about taking the AP classes then they'll take it,” Natalie said. “But I don't think that they should take AP classes for class rank. I think they should take it if it'll benefit them in college. Students aren't going to take classes like APs if there's no reason. And one of the reasons is college and another is, if you care, class rank.”

This year Natalie is taking four AP classes. Last school year, she had a 4.16 GPA.

Natalie joined her friends Morgan and Emma in creating a petition over the summer. The group only expected it to reach a handful of people. It now has more than 1,100 signatures alongside comments calling for the reversal of the decision.

Emma said she’s willing to compromise with the school board. During the past two graduations, she said, the district began phasing in the tiered system while still having a valedictorian, salutatorian, the top 10 and a pamphlet listing of where other kids fell in the Latin honors system

That combination, she said, should remain, allowing the district to get what they want — “more kids are getting recognized, but you're still having those who are at the top.”

Advertise with us

In an interview with the Post-Gazette, school director Robert Renzi Sr. suggested that it would be difficult to reinstate class rank.

“I haven't heard any good reasons why we could go back to class ranking… We gave this a lot of thought [two years ago] before we made this a thing. And, I mean, I can't say it's never going go back, but you talk to some of your other local high schools — there's a number of schools that don't have class rank anymore. We're not unique in that.”

Still, students have plans to continue pushing against the changes. Many are preparing to attend this month’s school board meetings. They are also planning another protest.

“It's wrong,” Emma said, “to not acknowledge those who worked hardest.”