Nearly 50 parents and children filled the Clairton High School library Monday evening, calling on school directors to reconsider a plan that will require some charter school students to take Pittsburgh Regional Transit to and from school each day.

Almost 120 charter school students living in the Clairton City School District will start taking PRT buses beginning Oct. 6. The switch from regular school buses comes as the district grapples with budget constraints exacerbated by a state budget impasse.

“Decisions like this are never easy … but when we are in a budget impasse and when we already are reduced in the funds that we have, we have to make those tough decisions,” Superintendent Tamara Allen-Thomas said after the meeting.

School districts are required by state law to provide transportation to students attending charter schools within 10 miles of district boundaries.

Advertise with us

But parents of the impacted students strongly voiced opposition to the plan, many of whom cited safety concerns and worries over public bus schedules and routes.

Dozens gathered outside the combined middle and high school before the meeting started, many holding signs reading “Safety first, scholars first” and “Our children. Our voices. Our safety.” At times the group broke out in chants, many of which focused on how all children deserve a ride to school.

“This is not right,” Deonna Jackson, a 28-year-old parent of two kindergartners who attend Propel McKeesport, said prior to the meeting. “You should have a bus to go to your school.”

Clairton originally voted to move forward with public bus passes for some charter school students during its June school board meeting. On Monday, directors voted on the start date.

The decision largely stems from budgetary constraints facing the district.

Advertise with us

Ms. Allen-Thomas pointed to the ongoing state budget impasse, which has delayed the flow of state dollars to school districts. She also referenced a 2023 ruling in which a Commonwealth Court judge deemed the state’s education funding system unconstitutional based on its reliance on property taxes. Clairton is among the top 100 underfunded schools in the state.

“Because it leaves communities like Clairton with fewer resources, that means we don’t get the funding we need to provide the same level of services that our wealthier districts do,” Ms. Allen-Thomas said during the meeting.

Transportation changes are expected to save Clairton more than $200,000 each year.

Ms. Allen-Thomas noted that Clairton students also do not receive transportation; rather all students attending the district walk to school.

Additionally, the district also has taken other cost-saving measures, such as eliminating administrative positions, reducing contracted employees and putting capital projects on hold.

Advertise with us

“These were not easy decisions, but they were necessary to protect our core mission — providing quality education in our classrooms,” Ms. Allen-Thomas said.

Still, many parents remained frustrated after the meeting, during which confusion arose over a sign-in sheet for public comment that resulted in two parents being able to speak about the transportation issue. Following public comment, many parents milled around the library speaking over the meeting, causing the board president to bang the gavel.

For most parents, concerns centered around safety on public buses.

“My 6-year-old, he does not have street smarts right now,” 35-year-old Tanika Chavis said. “He’s just learning academics and stuff, and I don’t think it’s safe for him to cross a busy street, be with strangers … getting on two buses to go get an education.”

Ms. Chavis, who sends her first grader to Young Scholars of Greater Allegheny Charter School in Versailles, said she does not have hope the school board will reconsider its decision. She pointed to the meeting during which she said “they just swept us under the rug.”

Advertise with us

Still, she plans to continue to “fight for my son’s future.”

Similar concerns were raised by 35-year old Rhea Patrick.

“I’m very worried about it,” Ms. Patrick, whose 16-year old son attends Propel Schools - Andrew Street High School in Munhall, said. “A lot of stuff has been happening on the buses around the world and I’m very scared for my baby.”

Ms. Patrick said that as the bus schedules currently stand, her son would have to catch a bus at 4 a.m. and make transfers to get to school.

Still, she remains hopeful that things will change moving forward.

“I’m still praying that it gets reconsidered, I’m still praying that we have a different outcome, a better outcome. I wish that we were heard more as parents, as families, as supporters of our children. But yes, we’re still going to keep fighting.”