The New Brighton Area School Board took its first step this week to potentially sharing a superintendent with a neighboring Beaver County district.
During a board meeting Monday night, school directors unanimously approved a plan that would permit New Brighton to share Superintendent Joseph Guarino with the Rochester Area School District. That means Mr. Guarino would head both districts, located two miles apart.
The board vote included an agreement that runs from July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2031.The motion now goes to Rochester where directors will consider the measure during their Aug. 25 meeting.
“At this point, it's even more so a feeling of excitement and just hopeful for the future,” Mr. Guarino told the Post-Gazette on Wednesday. “Obviously, there's a next step for Rochester to still approve it, but knowing that we're halfway there at this point in the approval process just gives a lot of hope for where we're going.”
If approved, the proposal could save each district $350,000 over five years.
Monday’s vote was the first step in possibly implementing the plan first proposed in April. At the time, leaders from both districts cited declining enrollments and budgetary constraints as leading factors in the proposal.
New Brighton today serves more than 1,200 students from Daugherty, Fallston, New Brighton and Pulaski. Of those, 72% are economically disadvantaged and 21% are in special education. The district operates a $29.3 million budget, officials said this spring.
Rochester serves almost 750 students from East Rochester, Rochester Borough and Rochester Township. Of those, 66% are economically disadvantaged and 31% are in special education. Rochester operates a $19.9 million budget.
But those numbers are different from 25 years ago. In 2000, Rochester had 1,200 students while New Brighton had 2,100.
At the same time, Rochester Superintendent Jane Bovalino is set to retire at the end of the 2025-26 school year, creating “the perfect storm,” Mr. Guarino previously told the Post-Gazette.
Short-term goals of the proposal include maintaining and increasing community support, reducing duplication within both districts and remaining financially stable. Long-term goals would be increased educational opportunities, fiscal responsibility, shared services and the identification of opportunities for additional education sharing.
But for New Brighton Area School Board President John Ludwig, the decision boils down to the students.
“The students are why I want to do this,” Mr. Ludwig told the Post-Gazette Wednesday. “There may be cost savings but that's not my aim in this. My aim is about enhancing our curriculum to provide more educational opportunities or avenues for our students.”
Mr. Ludwig, who has sat on the board for 16 years, has long pushed for the merging of services with other area districts. He pointed to past initiatives that included sharing technology between Beaver Falls, Rochester and New Brighton.
So when he was presented with the most recent proposal, Mr. Ludwig was on board.
“I'm very confident,” Mr. Ludwig said. “I tell Joe this and I tell everybody in the community this: Joe Guarino is the right man for the job. If this can be done he's the man that can do it.”
He suggested that if sharing Mr. Guarino between two districts goes well, leaders in New Brighton and Rochester may pursue sharing additional administrative positions such as the director of student services, the business manager, buildings and grounds directors and those managing special education.
“Like building a building you have a good base, you build the first floor, then you build the second floor, and then you go up,” Mr. Ludwig said. “And that is my vision.”
In terms of the superintendent position, Mr. Guarino noted that if approved, both districts will have a year transition period before he would take the helm in July 2026.
During that time he plans to work with Ms. Bovalino before her retirement and Rochester’s administrative and business office staff “to get a real good handle on where they are and how the district functions and operates.” He will also get to know those in the Rochester school community “so I can start building relationships before day one even begins.”
He pointed to “all the good work” Rochester has been doing.
“It’s continuing those [initiatives] and then just trying to figure out how we work together for what's in the best interest of the kids in the communities in the future,” Mr. Guarino said.
Rochester’s meeting is scheduled for 6 p.m. Aug. 25.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.