Dozens of parents, students and teachers Tuesday called on board members of a now shuttered Beaver County charter school for answers after the organization abruptly announced its closure just weeks before the start of school.
A nearly hourlong meeting drew more than 50 families to the Midland Innovation + Technology School, many looking for answers as to why school leaders last week announced they were shuttering the 9-12 building, which first opened in 2022.
“I am appalled by the lack of communication on your end,” student Liliana Alvaradl, 15, a rising sophomore, said. “Not only did you give us 20 days to figure out a school when half of us came here … and we found a place here. You ripped that right from underneath us. You jeopardized all of our futures with your lack of communication.”
The special public meeting, held in Midland Innovation’s cafeteria, came less than a week after school leaders announced the school was closing. On Tuesday, board members unanimously approved a motion that the board will take all action necessary to close MITCS.
Solicitor Jordan Shuber in a statement made during the meeting attributed the decision to enrollment and funding challenges. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, Midland Innovation in 2023-24 had close to 130 students. But the school needed over 200 students to be self-sustaining, Mr. Shuber said.
And operating expenses “became too much,” Mr. Shuber said.
“The debt accrued, it’s accrued every year,” Mr. Shuber said. “It’s to a point where the school can no longer operate, donors or not. It’s just at a place where it cannot continue. And that is such a difficult message to deliver to the Midland community.”
Board Chair Maria Corradi in responding to dozens of comments made by the public, thanked parents and students for taking a chance on the school.
“This isn’t the platform I ever wanted to speak to any of you on, this was never the news I ever wanted to deliver,” Ms. Corradi said. “You can trust, whether you believe it or not, you were given such last-minute notice because we were doing everything we could to save this school.”
But for many, frustrations remained.
English teacher Bri Kovalesky said staff was “blindsided.”
“Not a single indication of any emergency was communicated with any staff members for months, possibly longer,” Ms. Kovalesky said. “We wish that leadership would have been more transparent about the financial situation of our school.”
She pointed to the timing of the announcement, which came two weeks before staff were set to return and three weeks before the students’ first day of school, as well as to an “emotionless email” saying staff were out of jobs and “students are left to fend for themselves.”
Rising seniors, she added, many of whom have only experienced Midland Innovation for high school, now have graduation plans “derailed.”
That was a key point for Audrey Wakeley, a 16-year-old who is preparing for her senior year — the New Brighton resident skipped a grade, allowing her to graduate early.
“Now I have nowhere to go and I might be forced [to get] my GED,” Audrey said. “You don’t understand how upsetting that is going from being so successful and planning out my college career and planning out my life to having to basically drop out of high school because I don’t have anywhere to go and you guys don’t care.”
Midland Innovation, Audrey said, allowed her to find herself and build her character.
“You just screwed over my future,” Audrey said.
Parent Kevin Tolejko, whose son Landon is a rising senior, raised similar concerns.
He pointed to college applications his son is currently working on, raising questions over how he will receive letters of recommendation necessary to complete those applications.
“Everyone on this board should be embarrassed and ashamed by this,” Mr. Tolejko said. “It’s inexcusable.”
In a statement posted on the charter school’s website last week, CEO Terrence Smith added that in addition to enrollment and funding struggles, the school received an invitation from another charter school to enroll Midland Innovation students, adopt the school’s most popular pathways and educate students at the current MITCS building, “but in the eleventh hour, the other school retracted its offer.” Mr. Smith did not name the other charter school.
“Every possible remedy was pursued, but no other solution is available,” Mr. Smith wrote.
In an interview with the Post-Gazette following Tuesday’s meeting, Mr. Smith said, “It’s just a hard situation.” He added that school leaders, who spent the summer trying to secure additional funding, were “literally maybe a month to two months away from being able to do another school year but yet there was no funds there to pay people. That’s what I was concerned about. If we could do it for free I would do it for free but that’s not fair.”
Midland Innovation officials are now encouraging families to enroll in their home school districts for the upcoming school year. Mr. Smith noted that school leaders hand-delivered most student transcripts to their home districts as required by state law. Only a handful were mailed.
The Pennsylvania Department of Education in a statement confirmed that on July 30 it received notification from the charter school’s chief administrator that the board had voted to close the school. PDE provided Midland with next step guidance and is in contact with the Midland Borough School District, which has authorized Midland Innovation’s charter in the past.
Now, other schools including the Beaver-based Lincoln Park Performing Arts Center are stepping up to help families find a spot for their child during the upcoming school year.
“We are both public charter schools, we’re part of the school choice movement, and any time a charter school has to close, well, we're disappointed, because we're supporters of school choice. .... But simultaneous to that reaction is, OK, you have X number of kids and families who are now displaced and it's our responsibility to try to help them,” Dan LeRoy, Lincoln Park’s director of writing and publishing, told the Post-Gazette last week.
Lincoln Park is now preparing for a possible influx of new applicants. Mr. LeRoy noted that officials are not expecting all MITCS students to apply. But those who do must pass a required rubric to be accepted.
Mr. LeRoy noted that Lincoln Park has pathways that lined up with what was offered at Midland. For example, students who studied nursing at MITCS could enroll in Lincoln Park’s health science pathway in the arts department.
Lincoln Park held its first special admissions seminar Monday. A campus tour for Midland students is scheduled for 5 p.m. Aug. 11.
For Midland Innovation officials, some are taking a positive outlook as they look to the future.
“They’re going to bounce back,” Mr. Smith said. “We’re all going to bounce back.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.