Penn State’s Board of Trustees opted to shutter seven of the university’s branch campuses during a virtual meeting Thursday evening, despite statewide outcry that the plan could betray the university’s mission to offer an accessible public education and devastate education and economic mobility in the state’s rural communities.

Three campuses in Western Pennsylvania — New Kensington, Fayette and Shenango in Sharon — are now slated to close after the 2026-27 academic year. Other campuses impacted by closure include DuBois in central Pennsylvania and York, Wilkes-Barre and Mont Alto on the eastern side of the state.

Twenty-five trustees voted in favor of closure and eight voted against. Those who voted against the plan included Jay Paterno, Anthony Lubrano, Ted Brown, Donald Cairns, Lynn Dietrich, Barry Fenchak, Chris Hoffman and Nicholas Rowland.

Prior to the vote, trustees deliberated on the matter for nearly two hours. Penn State President Neeli Bendapudi also provided brief remarks urging trustees to vote in favor of closure.

Advertise with us

“We're charting a new course for the next century, for the future of our land-grant mission,” Ms. Bendapudi said. “The path that we recommend has been shaped by data, not just quantitative, but qualitative, narrative input as well.”

The decision now must be approved by Gov. Josh Shapiro’s administration. Mr. Shapiro has previously indicated state government would not interfere in the university’s decision on which campuses to close, and said it was clear Penn State needed to “right-size.”

Approval to close the campuses came after months of public pushback. Ms. Bendapudi announced in February that 12 of Penn State’s 20 branch campuses were at risk of closure. She then convened a task force that determined in three months which campuses would close.

The president informed the board of the closure plan earlier this month, and Penn State publicly confirmed which campuses were on the chopping block — and why — after reports leaked to the media last week.

The following justifications were given for the closures of each campus:

Advertise with us
  • New Kensington: 10-year enrollment decline of 35%, saturated market of Penn State campuses and other higher education institutions in the Pittsburgh region
  • Fayette: 10-year enrollment decline of 43%, competition from institutions like PennWest California and Waynesburg University, lack of residential housing, regional population losses and economic distress
  • Shenango: 10-year enrollment decline of 46%, local population declines, lack of housing, duplicative offerings to Penn State’s online World Campus and other regional institutions
  • DuBois: 10-year enrollment decline of 46%, demographically constrained region, narrow academic portfolio, lack of residential housing
  • York: 10-year enrollment decline of 40%, regional market saturation, high operating costs
  • Wilkes-Barre: 10-year enrollment decline of 46%, close proximity to other branches, lack of housing, small campus size
  • Mont Alto: 10-year enrollment decline of 35%, low housing occupancy, costly infrastructure

These seven campuses enrolled a combined 3,178 students in fall 2024. The Western Pennsylvania campuses enrolled 1,148 of those students, and currently offer a total of 28 bachelor’s degree programs and 13 associate degrees.

Penn State plans to invest in the five at-risk branch campuses spared of closure, which include Beaver and Greater Allegheny in McKeesport.

The seven highest-enrolled campuses — including Altoona and Behrend in Erie — were never at risk of closing, and neither was Great Valley, a graduate school in the Philadelphia area.

During remarks after Thursday’s vote, Ms. Bendapudi expressed optimism that open campuses will thrive as the university embarks on a “new chapter.”

“Higher education is changing, and yet, even in the midst of hard moments, we're not standing still,” she said. “We are moving forward with resilience, with purpose and with strength.”

Advertise with us

Trustee deliberation

Before the vote, trustees spoke passionately for or against closure.

Believing the closure plan was hastily put together, Mr. Paterno, who was elected to the board by Penn State alumni, expressed concerns that university leaders did not adequately explore other options for the campuses.

“We've always believed in a vision of Penn State because we always come through. We have never faltered. So why do we now believe we can't rally to the cause? Do we have so little faith in our people and the power of our 800,000 living alumni that we do not want to challenge them?” Mr. Paterno said. “Has this board and this administration lost the belief that our Penn State connection cannot overcome all?”

Mr. Hoffman, a farmer who was elected by delegates from agricultural societies, said taxpayers, students, alumni and rural communities should have been more involved in the decision.

“In my business, we don’t make decisions and then figure out how we’re going to do it,” Mr. Hoffman said. “We need to have a clear path moving forward.”

Advertise with us

Alumni trustee and former Penn State football player Brandon Short said though closure will have “painful effects,” trustees needed to “face undeniable realities.” Mr. Short ultimately voted in favor of closure.

“Penn State is not a business, and our objective isn't profitability. Our mission is to provide a world-class, affordable education — but the numbers matter,” Mr. Short said. “They do matter, and keeping under-utilized campuses open, despite shrinking enrollment, is not financially sustainable.”

And trustee Mary Lee Schneider, who was elected by the board representing business and industry, categorized closure as a means to survive. She believes the university will need to close more campuses in the future.

“I've had a lot of experience in making and living with these types of tough decisions, and by tough decisions, I mean the ones that disproportionately impact one group for the greater good,” Ms. Schneider said. “...The only challenge that I have [with this decision] is I think we should go deeper on the closures, as I fear we will be back here discussing the same facts and circumstances in a few years.”

What comes next

Closing campuses will continue to operate through the 2026-27 school year to ensure students can complete their bachelor’s degrees, associate degrees or the first two years of their education before transferring to University Park or other campus.

Advertise with us

Penn State admitted new students to the branch campuses for fall 2025. Ms. Bendapudi said all impacted students will be able to complete their Penn State degrees.

Faculty contracts and tenure will be honored after closures, and other employees affected by closures may be reassigned to another campus.

Looking to the future of the shuttering campuses, Penn State leaders say they will engage with elected officials, business leaders, community leaders, alumni and donors to “reimagine” how to repurpose each campus. The campuses’ futures may or may not involve Penn State.

University leaders will flesh out further plans for each campus during the two-year “wind-down” period, Ms. Bendapudi said.

How Penn State got here

Closure plans come after years of declining enrollment at the branch campuses, a projected decline in Pennsylvania’s college-aged population and what Ms. Bendapudi sees as a lack of funding from the state.

Advertise with us

Enrollment drops at the commonwealth campuses have been a years-long struggle. At Western Pennsylvania campuses between fall 2020 and fall 2024, student declines have varied from 7% (Penn State Behrend in Erie) to 29% (Penn State Fayette).

These enrollment challenges are exacerbated by a looming demographic cliff that will particularly impact the Northeast and Midwest. The Keystone State’s share of high school graduates is expected to drop 17% by 2041.

But despite these concerns, many have insisted that these campuses remain vital. Professors, students, lawmakers and community leaders have expressed concerns that closures could have a detrimental impact on the state’s education and economy, particularly in the more rural areas that many of the branch campuses serve.

Even some current and former members of the Board of Trustees or candidates for the board spoke out. In mid-April, Mr. Paterno, Mr. Brown, Alice Pope, Randy Houston and Jeff Ballou penned an opinion piece questioning whether university leaders have adequately explored other avenues before taking an ax to campuses. Penn State’s chapter of the American Association of University Professors also called on school leaders to keep all campuses open.

Though this is Penn State’s most drastic move regarding the campuses’ future, it isn’t the first big decision university leaders have made.

Advertise with us

The past year has seen Penn State already take significant steps to reduce costs at the branch campuses. School officials cut $49 million from the commonwealth campuses’ 2025-26 budget, dropping it to $340 million, and they announced in February that they plan to trim an additional $25 million from the campuses in 2026-27.

Last summer, Penn State officials also offered a buyout accepted by two in 10 eligible faculty and staff, and combined leadership at 11 campuses.

These moves were part of the university’s efforts to assuage a multi-million dollar deficit. Penn State’s 2023-24 deficit was $6.5 million, originally projected to be $44.5 million. School officials currently estimate a 2024-25 budget deficit of $34 million.