Some Pittsburgh Public School directors want to pump the brakes on a more than a yearlong process that could lead to the closure of several school buildings until they have more information.

During Wednesday’s agenda review meeting, some directors raised concerns about voting next week on a resolution that would open state-required public hearings on the closing of 10 school buildings. The vote is the next step the board needs to take as it considers closing 14 schools, some of which would reopen as new schools, and changing grade structures at 12 others.

“I think it’s a big mistake this item is on the agenda for this month,” Director Jamie Piotrowski said, pointing to a lack of information such as cost estimates for proposed capital improvements, timelines for how long the improvements would take or when schools would actually close.

The discussion came as the board is considering a resolution to schedule public hearings for the possible closure of school buildings including Friendship, which houses Montessori PreK-5; Fulton PreK-5; Miller PreK-5; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; King PreK-8; Morrow PreK-8; Schiller 6-8; Conroy, a special education school; and the Student Achievement Center.

Advertise with us

Voting on the resolution is the next step in possibly implementing the plan officials have been discussing since January 2024 as the district began contending with declining enrollments — PPS has the capacity for 40,000 students but currently educates 18,380 — and a growing budget deficit. School directors recently passed a 2025 budget featuring a $28.1 million deficit.

In response, officials began looking into school closures. Final recommendations were made in October by district officials and the Massachusetts-based education consulting firm Education Resource Strategies. By February, administrators threw their support behind the proposal in a feasibility study, opening the door to the next state-required steps.

Read More

But during that February meeting, several board members pointed to a missing breakdown detailing cost saving or what costs could be incurred by implementing the plan. Others also called out the absence of information about transportation, classroom sizes and feeder patterns. (Many East End schools do not yet have specific details about feeder patterns.)

“I’m also concerned about moving this forward right now because I fear that we need to anticipate the questions that the public is going to ask us and that they’ve been asking us for the last year around feeder patterns, transportation, where their kids are going to school,” Director Emma Yourd said. “People are going to ask those questions and we likely will not have those answers by the time the public hearings start in the next few months.”

That lack of information, she said, is adding to frustrations among parents and community members who are already angry that school closures are being discussed.

Advertise with us

“People are going to be mad because they have been demanding the same answers for the last year from this board and from this administration and we have not done our own due diligence to provide those answers to them,” Ms. Yourd said. “We can’t say this is a priority and not put all of our board and administrative manpower behind doing our due diligence and getting people the answers that they deserve.”

Ms. Piotrowski echoed those concerns, pointing to a request for proposals issued earlier this month to hire a demographer to conduct an assessment of current attendance zones and feeder patterns. Responses to that RFP are due Friday.

She’s now calling on the board to take a step back until all the information has been collected.

“I don’t disagree at all that the district needs to look at its footprint. … There are a lot of positives about what we have so far but it needs reworked,” Ms. Piotrowski said. “It’s OK to pause and not keep following this sunk cost fallacy of ‘I spent all this money so I have to finish.’ I think it’s OK to pause and pivot and just wait and it’s really just flipping a couple steps but to really make sure that the public gets what they’re owed, that the board gets what they’re owed so that we can feel confident in our vote.”

But others, including board President Gene Walker, pushed back against that idea. Mr. Walker disagreed with waiting to vote because “We started this work, we should finish this work.”

Advertise with us

“I think it would be highly irresponsible if this collection of board members did not make a decision one way or the other on what to do with this plan and leave it for someone else just like the last board did to us and the board before that did to them,” Mr. Walker said.

He noted that voting to open public hearings is not voting to close schools, adding that there is flexibility within the process to make changes and to add in more information.

But his points were often questioned by Director Devon Taliaferro, who said that rushing through the process will hurt kids. She told Mr. Walker that now “I have a responsibility to finish what you started. Now I have to sit at this board table and make the tough decisions because you started a process that maybe didn’t have as much thought or understanding as it should have.”

Several board members came to his defense, including Yael Silk.

“I think that this is incredibly challenging and I think that previous school board have not done this work and so here it is,” Ms. Silk said. “We are doing it imperfectly. We are where we are now and we are the ones who are going to do whatever’s going to happen next.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Silk suggested she'd be comfortable moving forward with a vote next week if board members could agree on a common set of additional information they wanted the administration to provide. She asked for a list to be made public between now and next Wednesday’s legislative meeting.

Director Tracey Reed added that decisions made so far have been a board process.

“We’re responsible for this,” Ms. Reed said, “It’s very hard. We have to do that hard thing so let’s do it.”