Pittsburgh Public School officials are refining strategies to help improve third grade reading scores as students continue to struggle to reach proficiency levels.
Superintendent Wayne Walters during Wednesday’s education committee meeting gave an update on third grade reading scores, months after he laid out a plan to revamp how the subject is taught after the students did not reach district proficiency goals last year — in 2024, 46% of third graders were reading proficiently, falling behind a district goal of 47%.
During the mid-year update, test results found that the number of third graders who would perform at or above grade level on the PSSAs increased by 9%.
But the number of students struggling to master skills needed to access complex texts grew from 45% at the start of the year to 54% by the middle of the year.
“This decline emphasizes the need for intentional lesson design and differentiated instruction to address the diverse learning needs of our students, ensuring they can access, comprehend and analyze complex texts for overall success,” Mr. Walters said.
According to Mr. Walters, students are assessed multiple times throughout the school year. The first — the classroom diagnostic tool — measures key reading and comprehension skills. That assessment when given in the fall showed that 10% of third graders were likely to test proficient or advanced on the PSSAs. By the winter, that number increased to 15%.
Read More
But disparities remained between student groups.
White students saw the largest increase, 13%, between the fall and winter. That was followed by students who are economically disadvantaged, nearly 10%; Black students, 7%; English language learners, 5%; and students with individualized education plans, 3%.
The DIBELS Acadience test focuses on four subtexts including words correct, accuracy, retell — or the students ability to recall and retell details from passages read — and maze, where students read the passage while selecting the correct missing words from the text.
But that test showed that each group saw a decrease in students scoring at or above benchmark.
White students scoring at or above benchmark dropped from 73% to 69%; students who are economically disadvantaged dropped from 49% to 40%; Black students dropped from 47% to 37%; English language learners dropped from 29% to 25%; and students with IEPs fell from 27% to 20%.
“These disparities highlight the urgent need for targeted interventions and equitable support to ensure all students can achieve academic success,” Mr. Walters said.
The update came after Mr. Walters in November shared that third grade reading skills have fluctuated over the past few years. At the time, Mr. Walters shared three key strategies: lesson design, differentiated instruction and best practices.
Now, district officials are reworking those strategies to better meet student needs.
Over the past several months, lesson design has focused on creating visuals to serve as a guide for lesson design and implementation; conducting professional learning and classroom observations; and having assistant superintendents provide written feedback to school principals. But teachers and staff faced several challenges, such as not positioning lesson progression posters in visual spots and not allocating time for professional learning.
To address those concerns, officials will provide feedback to teachers on how to integrate structured lesson design effectively. Professional learning sessions will also be job-embedded to reinforce lesson planning and expectations. And principals must commit to observing teacher lessons for at least 90 minutes.
The second strategy focused on comprehensive data analysis, professional learning and principal support, technology-based tools and teacher observations. But the main challenge included principals conducting informal observations rather than full-period sessions.
To help improve that goal, PPS officials will prioritize formal, structured classroom observations; engage principals in ongoing training; and require school leaders to submit observation reports detailing their findings and action steps.
The third strategy, identify best practices, focused on data collection and analysis, observations, professional learning communities, principal engagement, professional learning, and monitoring and support. Challenges included inconsistencies in school visits and data analysis across schools. Inconsistent data made it difficult to determine which practices were working the best.
The district will now focus on solidifying lesson design and differentiated instruction before expanding broader best practices. And professional learning will be strategically designed to reinforce implementation consistency.
Following the presentation, school directors asked Mr. Walters what he needed to help improve the scores. A main point, Mr. Walters said, is adding more literacy academic coaches. Right now, PPS has 18 coaches covering K-12. Of those, 13 are in K-5 and K-8 schools.
Ideally, Mr. Walters said, the district would be one-to-one with school literacy academic coaches.
But in reality, Mr. Walters said, “I need a lot of money, I need a lot of time and I need a focused understanding that we need to do some things differently, very similarly to what we’re trying to do with our facilities utilization plan. To think differently and in a more innovative manner around educating our students right now because our current model, if it remains the same, will not sustain us for the long haul.”
School director Sala Udin said the board needs to prioritize funding for the science of reading, an increasingly popular body of research focused on how students learn to read. The idea places a bigger emphasis on phonics rather than encouraging students to guess words based on context clues. The district implemented the idea in 2023-24.
Board President Gene Walker said necessary change now needs to happen.
“Let’s go back to that idea that our students will not change until we do,” Mr. Walker said. “We need to continue to lean into that change that needs to happen. From an adult perspective, taking our emotions out of it as much as possible because our kids are bigger than that, our kids are more important than that.”
Director Sylvia Wilson pointed to the foundation that needs to be laid in kindergarten through second grade.
“If we all get on the same page,” Ms. Wilson said, “and we are following the same design we will see things become better.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.