A Norwin school director who filed a lawsuit in 2023 claiming his First Amendment rights were violated by the district following a controversial Facebook post plans to issue an amended complaint after a judge last month wrote an order that could lead to the suit being dismissed.

Alex Detschelt in an email confirmed his intentions to amend a claim made as part of the lawsuit that said his free speech rights were violated when former Norwin Superintendent Jeffrey Taylor made a public statement about a meme published by Mr. Detschelt in 2022 on a private Facebook page after it received criticism from the community.

The update from Mr. Detschelt came after U.S. District Judge W. Scott Hardy issued a Dec. 20 order that could lead to the dismissal of the lawsuit. But it allows Mr. Detschelt to file an amendment.

“The approach I took, when matched with the current law, resulted in the opinion to be written as it was,” Mr. Detschelt said in an email. “A different approach is required, which is what the court recognizes I am able to do.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Taylor and a Norwin spokesperson both declined to comment because it is not the judge’s final order.

Controversy started when Mr. Detschelt on Oct. 25, 2022 posted the meme to the “Norwin Area Talk” Facebook group. The post consisted of a photo using an outdated term for a person with special needs when describing someone wearing a facemask and who received booster shots during COVID. But it quickly received pushback from the community and in response, Mr. Taylor issued a statement condemning use of the term.

In the statement, sent to more than 7,700 community members, Mr. Taylor wrote, “it is important to note that his social media posts represent his personal views and do not represent, nor reflect, the views of the Norwin School District, the District Administration, or the Norwin Board of Education.”

But in the suit Mr. Detschelt criticized the statement for “omitting contextual and factual information that was necessary for a reasonable person to actually assess the totality of the circumstances and the nature” of his behavior.

The post, the suit reads, was made when Mr. Detschelt was not acting in his official capacity as school director. The district statement therefore “adversely affected” his protected speech and impacted his ability to perform school director duties, according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

And the statement, the suit contends, did not include or reference an apology made by Mr. Detschelt when he deleted the post after receiving backlash.

In all, the suit states that action taken by the school district following the post — which was non-threatening in nature and was not considered hate speech, the lawsuit reads — deterred Mr. Detschelt from “exercising his rights to free speech in the future and retaliated against him for exercising those rights in the past.” The statement, according to the suit, caused “severe emotional distress, mental anguish, embarrassment, and humiliation,” for Mr. Detschelt.

The suit sought compensatory and punitive damages for Mr. Detschelt.

In his opinion, Mr. Hardy agreed that Mr. Detschelt “engaged in constitutionally protected conduct when he posted the meme as meme-related comments — matters of public concern — as a private citizen, and thus that he sufficiently pleads the first element of a First Amendment retaliation claim.”

But the court ruled that Mr. Detschelt “failed to plausibly plead that Defendants engaged in a retaliatory act.” That, the order states, will be dismissed “for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Such dismissal will be without prejudice, however, and Detschelt will be given leave to amend his claim, should he choose to do so.”

Advertise with us

In his email, Mr. Detschelt said he now plans to indicate in the revised complaint that the retaliation was in the form of a censure that did not focus on the political message of the meme, but rather the use of the outdated term.

“I would like to show that retaliation (censure and email) must be related to a public official's workplace activity or their duty or lack thereof as a public official,” Mr. Detschelt said.

He added that providing a political meme or using the outdated term as a private individual on a private forum “has no bearing” on the function of the school district.

The amended complaint is due Friday.