A handful of Pittsburgh Public Schools parents and community members Monday spoke out against the district’s proposed 2025 budget, calling on the board to take a step back and stop a cycle of “reactionary decisions” they say officials have made over the past few years.
The problem, many said, is that in recent years — and in the 2025 proposed budget — the district has predicted significant budget deficits. But the past two years have ended in a surplus.
“This year, you conclude with another surplus despite earlier predictions of significant deficits,” Ghada Makoshi said during Monday’s budget public hearing. “These repeated forecasting inaccuracies have led to reactionary decisions such as the proposal to close schools.”
Ms. Makoshi’s comments come as the district is considering a 2025 budget that features a $28.1 million deficit. In all, the spending plan, which board members will vote on this month, totals $752.3 million and does not include a tax increase.
But the problem is that the past two years the district has projected similar budget deficits but ended each year in a surplus.
Officials in 2023 projected a $16.4 million deficit but ended the year with a $3.3 million surplus. And this year PPS is projecting a $5.5 million surplus despite originally expecting a $29.9 million deficit.
Read More
“PPS actually ended up with a surplus in 2024, which is great,” Arsenal parent Erika Gidley said. “Kudus to the district for ending the year strong when faced with such an alarming deficit at the beginning of budget planning last year. This shows me that PPS can handle these hard financial concerns. Because of this I am not concerned about a possible deficit for 2025 because historically PPS has been able to close the budget gap.”
What she is concerned about, Ms. Gidley said, is transparency.
She pointed to the district’s plan to close 14 schools and reconfigure the grade structures at 12 others. The plan has been in the works for more than a year as PPS faces budgetary issues — including high charter school tuition rates and tax appeals — and declining enrollments. The district announced in November that no buildings will close next school year.
“It looks like PPS is utilizing doomsday projections to close schools that the communities very much want to remain open,” Ms. Gidley said. “We were able to find close to $32 million last year. I believe we can do it again without sacrificing communities and our child’s education. There is still time to make decisions on our schools.”
Ms. Gidley also touched on the district’s decision to discontinue Summer B.O.O.S.T. — a summer learning program for K-7 students — to help save money.
The decision to shutter the no-cost program, which was designed to build positive relationships and create opportunities for exploration “that put youth on track for their future academic success in a thriving and fun environment,” the district website reads, came after the program had limited impacts on student outcomes and was plagued with inconsistent attendance.
But many in the community called on the district to reconsider.
“The program itself was not the issue; rather, poor communication and registration processes limited access,” Ms. Makoshi said. “B.O.O.S.T. was not only beneficial but also provided an inclusive setting for [extended school year], integrating children with disabilities alongside their peers. … There has been no effort to reconsider this decision or acknowledge the program’s value.”
Paulette Foster, special education organizer with the advocacy group 412 Justice, agreed, adding that the program allowed students to “have opportunities to flourish.”
“The district and whoever else plays a vital part in decision-making needs not to sit back and take the status quo approach to what’s best for our students,” Ms. Foster said. “Because it’s evident we the stakeholders are being pushed out of any serious decision-making.”
Parent Valerie Webb-Allman, like Ms. Makoshi, called those decisions reactionary.
Rather than making decisions that will help the district, Ms. Webb-Allman said, “what ends up happening is the most vulnerable students and communities are the ones that feel the cuts the most.”
The district now needs to do things differently, she said.
“We can’t keep kicking the can; we can’t keep doing the same things and expecting different results,” Ms. Webb-Allman said.
Parent Sarah Zangle added that this is time for the district to make positive changes.
“Let’s make sure that we are retaining the choice, driving equity, bringing everybody along with us and making sense of this,” Ms. Zangle said. “We have a way to do this differently, and we have a way to change our budget in the future. … No matter what your intentions are behind this, if you keep doing the same thing, you’re going to get the same result.”
A vote on the 2025 budget is scheduled for Dec. 18.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.