Diana Efthimiades was driving her normal school bus route in the Chartiers Valley School District Wednesday morning when she received a surprise. One of her students made her a Thanksgiving card to thank her for being the “best bus driver ever.”

Ms. Efthimiades, like other school bus drivers hired by the district, has created bonds with individual students and their parents, who drivers see each morning as they pick up children to take them to school and dropping them off in the afternoon.

But that routine could soon change.

Chartiers Valley — a district that serves students from Bridgeville, Heidelberg, Collier and Scott — is considering contracting with a transportation company to provide busing services rather than continuing to operate its own bus garage. On Tuesday, school directors authorized administrators to issue a request for proposals for student transportation.

Advertise with us

“I'm just disappointed,” Ms. Efthimiades said Wednesday. “We elected these guys in there and these ladies in there and you would think they’d try to exhaust everything else besides trying to outsource. … I just hope it comes, hopefully in our benefit and we keep our jobs.”

As things currently stand, Chartiers Valley operates a fleet of more than 70 school buses, which transport 3,400 students each day. As part of that department the district also employs 77 transportation staff, including drivers, mechanics and administrative personnel.

But the district is now looking to “evaluate the most efficient and cost-effective means of providing safe and reliable transportation for its students” by soliciting bids to possibly outsource its school bus transportation services, a district statement reads.

The district attributed the decision to rising operational costs, labor shortages and challenges related to maintaining an in-house transportation program.

“We are committed to ensuring that our students have access to safe, dependable transportation to and from school,” interim Superintendent Joseph Dimperio said in the statement. “By seeking bids, we can assess whether partnering with an experienced transportation provider could enhance our services while also being mindful of taxpayers’ dollars.”

Advertise with us

But, the possible changes would impact 65 jobs, Annie Briscoe, region advocacy coordinator for the Pennsylvania State Education Association’s western region, said Wednesday.

According to Ms. Briscoe, the possible changes come as district bus drivers have been working without a contract after their last agreement expired in June. She noted that negotiations have taken place since January. By the fall “it became clear that the district [had] an interest in outsourcing the transportation services,” she said. Negotiations are ongoing.

But by moving forward with collecting RFPs, Ms. Briscoe said, the district has taken its first step in potentially contracting with a private company for bus services.

“What this shows is there's interest at the board level to look for bids in transportation services, and the action last night authorized that first step in the process,” Ms. Briscoe said. “We have a lot of concerns about it, but logistically, it's not happening right now. Right now, what they did was open the door to invite outside for-profit, private companies to come in and submit information for what they would project their costs to operate our transportation.”

According to the district statement, RFPs will include detailed requirements to ensure “any potential vendor adheres to the district’s high standards for safety, punctuality, and customer service,” and would require vendors to comply with standards for driver qualifications, vehicle maintenance and emergency protocols.

Advertise with us

And, the district said, the RFP will include provisions allowing current drivers the opportunity to work with any selected bus company the district could hire.

“While this process will allow us to explore all options, no final decision has been made about outsourcing transportation services,” school board President Darren Mariano said in the statement. “The Board will thoroughly review all proposals submitted and discuss how it will move forward later next year. Throughout this process, we remain committed to transparency and engaging with our community.”

But the possible changes were met with swift pushback from residents and bus drivers, many of whom spoke out at Tuesday’s board meeting.

“I'm a little bit both angry and frustrated,” Keith Schoeneman, who has been a Chartiers Valley bus driver for five years, told the Post-Gazette Wednesday.

Mr. Schoeneman noted that the threat of outsourcing busing is something that comes up frequently in contract negotiations. But “they never actually had a vote to actually seek bids.”

Advertise with us

He called the decision a “bombshell.”

Mr. Schoeneman pointed to the ongoing school bus driver shortage that has plagued school districts across the country since the COVID-19 pandemic, questioning how things such as pay rates could be impacted if the district’s bus services are contracted out.

“We have drivers that want to work, and we want to continue working with the school district, working for the school district, and we just hope that they change their mind and we can get a fair contract,” Mr. Schoeneman said.

Ms. Efthimiades pointed to the connection the bus drivers have built with the community.

“I'm here every day … so you get that relationship with these kids, and they know that they're going to be safe going to and from school,” Ms. Efthimiades said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Briscoe noted there’s no timeline for how long the board can collect bids for the RFPs.

“For now I think it is very much the fear of the unknown for our members who are still getting up every day and going to work,” Ms. Briscoe said. “They're committed to these kids, they’re committed to these jobs.”