The messy launch of the updated federal aid form impacted enrollment at nearly three-quarters of private colleges across the country, a fall survey found.
Of 251 private, nonprofit institutions, 74% said issues with the FAFSA rollout changed the composition of their freshman class, according to a November report by the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities.
Additionally, 49% of schools said their fall 2024 class was more difficult to fill, and 44% have a smaller freshman class this year than last year.
“The survey findings provide a clear picture of the disruption caused by the Department of Education’s chaotic rollout of the new financial aid application form,” NAICU President Barbara K. Mistick said in a news release.
Of NAICU’s nearly 1,000 member institutions across the country, Western Pennsylvania members include Allegheny College, Carnegie Mellon University, Chatham University, Duquesne University, Geneva College, La Roche University, Saint Vincent College, Seton Hill University, Washington & Jefferson College and Waynesburg University.
This survey offers one of the first clues into how FAFSA hiccups during the 2023-24 school year impacted higher education institutions.
Read More
Last year, a revamped FAFSA aimed to ease the application process for students and families — but improvements were overshadowed by a rocky launch.
Students and families who attempted to fill out the application often faced technology issues and limited time frames to actually complete it. Then, the Department of Education delayed its transfer of students’ financial information to schools, meaning that students and families waited longer than usual to find out how much aid they would receive in aid from schools to which they applied.
That particularly impacted high school seniors, who often weigh financial aid offers before choosing which college to attend. As a result, numerous schools pushed back their freshman commitment deadlines.
The rocky rollout resulted in significant drops in FAFSA submissions. In July, submissions among the high school class of 2024 were down over 10% nationwide and in Pennsylvania, according to the National College Attainment Network, which tracked submissions using data from Federal Student Aid.
In the NAICU survey, over half of schools reported that FAFSA issues impacted the amount of aid their institutions distributed.
And nearly all of the institutions also reported lackluster communication from the Department of Education. Nine in 10 said the department did not provide timely information about the revamped FAFSA, and 85% said the department was not transparent enough in its FAFSA progress.
“It should come as no surprise that college and university leaders are disappointed with how the department communicated throughout the rollout of the new FAFSA,” Ms. Mistick said.
NAICU’s November report comes weeks after National Student Clearinghouse Research Center shared that freshman enrollment is down 5% at colleges nationally this fall compared to fall 2023. Drops were more pronounced at private, nonprofit institutions, which saw a 6.5% decline in freshmen, the study found.
Looking ahead, Ms. Misktick said “lingering distrust” remains as the department prepares to rollout next year’s form in several weeks.
The department announced in August that the 2025-26 FAFSA form would launch on or before Dec. 1 — two months after the form has traditionally been available. During that two-month period, the department will undergo a “testing period” of the form, aiming to improve the application process.
“Colleges and universities, students, and families require better communication and transparency from the department going forward and in addressing the remaining challenges associated with the rollout, so we don’t lose another class of students,” Ms. Mistick said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.