Two more Pittsburgh-area school districts are moving forward with plans to close elementary schools amid declining enrollments and aging buildings.
Burrell in Westmoreland County announced this month that Stewart Elementary would close next school year. That decision was followed by Hopewell in Beaver County where school directors last week voted on a plan that will close three elementaries and lead to grade reconfigurations across the district.
“We want our schools to be viable options for our kids and our community for decades to come,” Hopewell Superintendent Jeff Beltz said Thursday, noting that officials have to look at where they want the district to be 30 years from now. “I think when you look at it that way it makes a lot of sense.”
Burrell and Hopewell are now among several Pittsburgh-area districts making similar decisions.
The Moon Area School District in August voted to close Hyde Elementary next school year. The Elizabeth Forward School District is contemplating the closure of three elementaries — Greenock, Mt. Vernon and William Penn. Those students would be consolidated into two elementary centers. The district could also see grade reconfigurations with kindergartners and first graders in one school, second through sixth grade at another and seventh and eighth graders moving into a new wing of the high school.
And Pittsburgh Public is considering a school closure plan. This month a district-hired consultant presented final recommendations in a facilities utilization plan that proposed the closure of 14 schools districtwide and reconfiguring the grade structures at 12 others.
Read More
Trends seen in the Pittsburgh area mirror what’s happening nationally as districts prepared for the end of COVID-relief funds and birth rates across the country continue to drop.
In 2021-22 there were 755 school closures across the country, 324 of which were elementary schools, while 133 were middle schools, the National Center for Education Statistics, the statistical agency of the U.S. Department of Education, found. And others could be underway. This week Seattle Public Schools proposed closing four elementaries next school year. Similarly the El Paso Independent School District is contemplating closing 10 elementary schools.
Also in 2021-22, the number of students enrolled in cyber, charter and homeschooling increased, a direct result of the pandemic. That year 21.2% of students enrolled in alternative schooling, a jump from 2015-16 when that number hovered around 15.7%, The Hamilton Project, an economic policy initiative at the Brookings Institution, found in an October 2023 paper. And between 2018-19 and 2020-21 12% of public elementary schools and 9% of middle schools saw a more than 20% decline in student enrollment,
Now, school districts are reacting.
Locally, Burrell School District officials are closing Stewart Elementary School next school year and reconfiguring the elementary and middle school grade structures.
The decision was in response to declining enrollments — today Burrell educates 1,750 students — necessary facility upgrades and educational programming needs, Superintendent Shannon Wagner said in a statement.
According to Ms. Wagner, work started two years ago when administrators engaged with an architect and district faculty and staff to create a plan that would help combat those ongoing issues. By June the board was heavily considering the closure of Stewart. At that time they held a public hearing.
This month, “the Board considered all the information from the past two years and made the unanimous decision to close the school,” Ms. Wagner said.
In addition to closing Stewart, the board also voted to establish building grade level configurations for the 2025-26 school year to include K-4 at Bon Air Elementary and 5-8 at Huston Middle School, although the board will consider costs of needed facilities upgrades before deciding on where fifth graders will be permanently housed, Ms. Wagner said.
And because the district has continually made staffing changes through attrition and reallocation, all current staff are expected to continue employment at Burrell once Stewart closes.
At Hopewell, school directors on Tuesday voted on a plan that will move grades 7 and 8 to the high school, creating a 7-12 facility. Three elementary schools — Hopewell, Independence and Margaret Ross — along with the middle school will close and a new K-6 school will be constructed.
The total project is expected to cost $112.6 million.
According to Mr. Beltz, the project is in response to aging buildings — the district’s five schools were built in the late 1950s or early 1960s meaning renovations are becoming necessary — and declining enrollments. In 2000 Hopewell had around 3,000 students. Today that number is close to 2,000 with students coming from Hopewell, Independence and Raccoon townships.
“So we have, in terms of buildings, an awful lot of extra space in our buildings right now, not necessarily the elementaries, but junior high school and the high school,” Mr. Beltz said, noting that Hopewell previously consolidated elementary schools.
Under the plan as it currently stands, about $30 million worth of alterations and additions are needed at the high school. The goal, Mr. Beltz said, is to keep seventh and eighth graders separate from high school students. Officials could also convert the former cafeteria and kitchen into classrooms. A new cafeteria and offices would be constructed at the front of the Longvue Avenue school.
While plans have not yet been finalized, the new K-6 school could be constructed on the land housing the current middle school and Margaret Ross Elementary. The middle school will likely be torn down; decisions have not yet been made regarding the elementary schools.
Now that a decision on the scope of the project has been made, district officials will construct a budget for the new building and will finalize its future location.
“We can now jump into that project with our team and architects and the financial planners to say, ‘How can we do this in a responsible manner,’” Mr. Beltz said. “And so we need to look at that timeline. So whether that means we have to phase projects, or can overlap or do them at the same time, all that comes into play, but that's the next step for us is the budget impact and how we're going to move forward in that manner.”
As for the community, Mr. Beltz said they have “identified that something needed to happen.”
He noted that the “very proud” communities that make up the Hopewell Area School District “rally around our kids and really appreciate our community.” Because of that, Mr. Beltz knows they want “what’s best for our kids,” they just want it to be done in a fiscally responsible manner.
“The community has been great,” Mr. Beltz said. “I think everyone acknowledges that we need to move forward and that something needs to be done with our schools. But they're reminding us, and they should be reminding us, that the taxpayers are going to bear the brunt of this decision.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.